Accessibility, Safety, and Accommodation Burden in U.S. Higher Education Syllabi for Blind and Low-Vision Students Conference: arXiv preprint; November 2025; Online CCS: Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI) CCS: Social and professional topics People with disabilities CCS: Social
Chadani Acharya · 2025
Read Accessibility, Safety, and Accommodation Burden in U.S. Higher Education Syllabi for Blind and Low-Vision Students Conference: arXiv preprint; November 2025; Online CCS: Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI) CCS: Social and professional topics People with disabilities CCS: Social by Chadani Acharya (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-07634.txt.
Introduction
Chadani Acharya audits whether course syllabi actually serve blind and low-vision students. A syllabus is often the only structured guide to deadlines, grading, safety, and how to request accommodations. Screen reader users can use it independently only when the file is machine readable and easy to navigate.
Syllabi from five United States institutions, from an elite private university to a technical college, were coded on five dimensions. Checks covered logistics readability, safety information, and the burden placed on students seeking accommodation. Gaps force extra emails and dependence on staff goodwill. The audit gives concrete fixes so access starts with the document itself.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Chadani Acharya |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-07634
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Accessibility, Safety, and Accommodation Burden in U.S. Higher Education Syllabi for Blind and Low-Vision Students Conference: arXiv preprint; November 2025; Online CCS: Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI) CCS: Social and professional topics People with disabilities CCS: Social and professional topics Accessibility design and evaluation methods CCS: Social and professional topics Vocational training Chadani Acharya Abstract . Course syllabi are often the first and sometimes only structured artifact students receive that explains how a class will run: deadlines, grading rules, lab safety procedures, and how to request disability accommodations. For blind and low-vision (BLV) students who rely on screen readers, independent access to this information depends on whether the syllabus itself is machine-readable and navigable. We audited publicly posted syllabi and master syllabi from five U.S. institutions spanning different segments of higher education: an elite private R1 university, large public R1 universities, a UC campus, a large multi-campus community college, and workforce-oriented community and technical colleges. We coded each document along five dimensions: (1) screen-reader legibility of core logistics (deadlines, grading, attendance), (2) screen-reader legibility of safety-critical procedures (e.g., welding requirements, biomedical lab conduct), (3) framing of disability accommodation (rights-based vs. documentation-gated), (4) governance model (instructor-authored syllabus vs. centralized “master syllabus” template), and (5) presence of proactive universal design language. We find two main patterns. First, across all institution types, many syllabi present logistics and even safety expectations as selectable text rather than screenshots or scanned images, suggesting baseline screen reader access to critical information. Second, the way accommodation is framed shifts systematically by institution type. R1 universities describe accommodations as removing barriers to ensure equal access, even while requiring advance paperwork. Community and technical colleges describe accommodations as conditional on student self-identification, documentation, and institutional approval, and this language is embedded in centrally issued master syllabi that replicate across every course section. These results suggest that accessibility in higher education is not only a technical PDF-formatting problem. It is also a question of governance and equity: who is told they have a right to access, who is told they must qualify for access, and how that burden scales in safety-relevant, workforce-preparation courses. 1. Introduction A course syllabus is typically the first structured artifact a student encounters in a class. Prior work in higher education describes the syllabus as both a roadmap to the learning experience and a quasi-contract that defines mutual expectations between instructor and student: it encodes what will be taught, how performance will be evaluated, and what policies govern student conduct, academic integrity, and attendance ( 4 ; 7 ) . In laboratory and applied technical courses, syllabi (and closely related “master syllabi”) also summarize critical safety expectations, required protective equipment, and procedures for using specialized or hazardous tools. At the same time, the syllabus usually embeds the institution’s disability accommodation statement, which tells students what they must do to obtain accessible materials or instructional adjustments. For blind and low-vision (BLV) students, this makes the syllabus a high-stakes access point: it is simultaneously a safety manual, a grading contract, and the gateway to accommodations. Independent access to this information depends on whether the document is machine-readable and navigable by a screen reader rather than being a scanned PDF or an unlabeled image of text. Accessibility standards such as the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG 2.1) emphasize tagged structure, logical reading order, and text alternatives as prerequisites for nonvisual access ( 12 ; 9 ) . BLV students often rely on screen readers as their primary interface to course content; tactile graphics, sonification, and other multimodal alternatives can help, but they require additional hardware, specialized training, and instructor coordination and therefore are rarely available at scale at the start of a course ( 3 ) . When the syllabus is not accessible, BLV students can lose access to deadlines, exam logistics, grading rules, and safety expectations on day one. Studies of disabled students in STEM and lab-based coursework document how inaccessible safety procedures, equipment instructions, and hazard warnings function as both logistical and physical barriers ( 8 ; 1 ) . These barriers can exclude BLV learners from laboratory participation, limit their ability to meet course requirements, or force them to depend on ad hoc human assistance for core safety tasks. In U.S. public higher education this problem is not framed solely as pedagogy: federal civil-rights guidance under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act makes clear that state and local educational institutions are obligated to provide accessible digital content and instructional materials to disabled students, including those who are blind or have low vision ( 10 ) . In response, accessibility and human-computer interaction (HCI) research has increasingly treated instructional materials as interactive systems rather than static documents. Work in nonvisual data visualization has shown that traditional “alt text” and long descriptions are often insufficient for BLV readers who need to interrogate charts and tables at the same analytical depth and speed as sighted peers. In a Wizard-of-Oz study with blind and low-vision participants, researchers collected nearly one thousand naturally occurring questions about common visualization types (bar charts, line charts, scatterplots, choropleths) and found that many questions involved higher-level interpretation such as trend analysis, extrema, and comparative reasoning rather than simple label reading ( 6 ; 3 ) . These findings motivate interactive techniques such as chart question answering, structured audio summaries, and multimodal feedback to support BLV analytical work in real time. This line of work reframes accessibility as immediate participation in the same cognitive task, rather than delayed accommodation. Accessibility, however, is not only technical. In U.S. higher education the syllabus itself is also a governance artifact. Research in inclusive pedagogy and institutional policy notes that at many research universities, syllabi are authored by individual instructors, which means tone, disability framing, and promises of flexibility vary by instructor and course. By contrast, many community colleges and technical colleges publish centralized ‘master syllabi’ that define learning outcomes, grading rules, safety procedures, and disability accommodation language for every single section of a course across campuses. This centralization creates leverage: a rights-based, access-forward template can improve conditions for thousands of students at once, but a gatekeeping template that emphasizes self-disclosure, documentation requirements, and institutional discretion can replicate barriers at scale rather than removing them ( 5 ; 11 ) . Parallel to these technical advances, disability services and higher education policy research have examined the social and procedural layer of access. The dominant U.S. model typically requires that a student (1) self-identify as disabled to a campus accessibility office, (2) submit medical or diagnostic documentation, (3) receive an official accommodation letter, and (4) present that letter to each instructor in advance; many institutions explicitly specify that accommodations are “not retroactive” ( 5 ) . Scholars of inclusive pedagogy argue that this workflow shifts administrative and emotional burden onto disabled students, who must repeatedly assert legal status and negotiate for access even in courses where inaccessible formats are predictable ( 5 ) . Universal Design for Learning (UDL) has been proposed as a proactive alternative: instead of treating accessibility as a negotiated exception, UDL encourages instructors and departments to build multiple modes of representation, flexible assessment, and accessible document structure into the baseline