On the strength of ultrafilters above choiceless large cardinals and their Prikry forcings
William Adkisson, Omer Ben Neria · 2025
Read On the strength of ultrafilters above choiceless large cardinals and their Prikry forcings by William Adkisson, Omer Ben Neria (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-07622.txt.
Introduction
William Adkisson and Omer Ben Neria probe set theory where the axiom of choice fails yet huge cardinals remain. Above a rank Berkeley cardinal, Gabriel Goldberg showed most regular cardinals carry well-founded uniform ultrafilters. What strength those ultrafilters truly witness was unclear.
Bounds on that strength are proved, and Prikry forcing is extended into this choiceless setting. Limits emerge on which cardinals such forcing can collapse or make singular. A new tensor Prikry system then builds models with fresh consistency results. The work maps how much order survives when choice, set theory usual safety net, is removed.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | William Adkisson, Omer Ben Neria |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 84 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-07622
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the strength of ultrafilters above choiceless large cardinals and their Prikry forcings William Adkisson, Omer Ben Neria Abstract We study the strength of well-founded ultrafilters on ordinals above choiceless large cardinals and their associated Prikry forcings. Gabriel Goldberg showed that all but boundedly many regular cardinals above a rank Berkeley cardinal carry well-founded uniform ultrafilters. We prove several bounds on the large cardinal strength that is witnessed by such ultrafilters. We then extend the theory of Prikry forcing in this context and place limits on the cardinals that can be collapsed or singularized. Finally, we develop the notion of a tensor Prikry system, and use it to give new constructions for several consistency results in choiceless set theory. In particular, we build a new model in which all uncountable cardinals are singular. 1 Introduction Large cardinals have proven to be powerful extensions of the axioms of set theory. These large cardinal axioms are often phrased in terms of the existence of elementary embeddings from V to a structure M ; the strength of the axiom is closely related to the closure of M , with embeddings into highly closed models giving rise to very powerful large cardinal properties. However, pushing their strength to its limits conflicts with the axiom of choice: Kunen famously showed that the existence of an elementary embedding from V to itself is incompatible with choice. Therefore, to explore even stronger large cardinal assumptions, one must leave the familiar setting of ZFC and enter the realm of choiceless set theory. While this shift allows for more powerful large cardinals, much of the useful structure provided by ZFC is lost without the axiom of choice. To overcome this loss, Woodin [ 20 ] has proposed using large cardinal hypotheses such as extendible and supercompact cardinals to derive some of the key consequences of AC. This line of research has seen tremendous developments in recent years, following works by Cutolo [ 5 ] proving key choice-like properties at successors of limits of Berkeley cardinals, Usuba [ 19 ] , who derived introduced the key notion of a Lowenheim-Skolem cardinal as a weak choice principle, and Aspero [ 2 ] who showed how to derive such large cardinals from the existence of a Reinhardt cardinal. Schlutzenberg [ 16 ] developed the theory of extenders in these settings and established structural results on elementary embeddings associated with choiceless large cardinals. This line of research has notably culminated in the recent work of Goldberg [ 10 , 9 ] , who unified and significantly expended these results to derive remarkable choice-related consequences for a proper class of cardinals, and then further develop the theory to shed light on the Continuum Problem. For the most part, the choiceless large cardinal being used to derive these results is a rank Berkeley, whose existence is implied by Reinhardt cardinals but is expressible in first-order set theory. A fundamental result in Goldberg’s work is the existence of well founded uniform ultrafilters on all sufficiently large regular cardinals. Theorem 1 (Goldberg [ 9 ] ) . Assuming there is a rank Berkeley cardinal \lambda there is some \kappa\geq\lambda (which is almost supercompact) such that for every regular cardinal \delta\geq\kappa there is a \kappa -complete uniform ultrafilter U on \delta . It is natural to ask about the strength of ultrafilters in these choiceless settings (above a rank Berkeley). In the ZFC setting, ultrafilters are often derived from large cardinals, and the strength of the associated large cardinal determines much of the behavior of these ultrafilters. A normal measure derived from a measurable cardinal behaves very differently than the array of measures that can be derived from strongly compact or supercompact cardinals. In this work, we aim to study the well-founded ultrafilters U on ordinals above a rank Berkeley cardinal through the following two perspectives: (I) Study properties of U that determine its (large cardinal) strength. (II) Study the theory of Prikry forcing \mathbb{P}(U) with U , and iteration of such forcings. There are several ways of making perspective (I) precise. The first is to examine the cardinality of restricted powers. Given an ordinal \gamma and a well-founded ultrafilter U on some set X , we can examine |\gamma^{X}/U| . Under choice, suppose \kappa is measurable, with a corresponding normal measure U on \kappa , and let \delta>\gamma . Then if \gamma<\kappa , or if there are <\delta functions from \gamma to \gamma , then |\gamma^{\kappa}/U|<\delta . On the other hand, if U is a \kappa -strongly compact-type ultrafilter on \delta , and \kappa\leq\gamma<\delta , then |\gamma^{\delta}/U|>\delta . Another approach is to use the notion of a (\kappa,\rho) regular ultrafilter. An ultrafilter U is (\kappa,\rho) regular for \kappa<\rho if it is \kappa -complete and has a subset of size \rho all whose intersections indexed by elements of [\rho]^{\kappa} are empty (see Definition 18 ). In the choice setting, the existence of an ultrafilter U on that is (\kappa,\rho) -regular reflects the strength of a \mathcal{P}_{\kappa}(\rho) strongly compact cardinal. Regarding (II), we can ask about the result of forcing with the associated Prikry forcing \mathbb{P}(U) . In the ZFC setting, if U is a measure derived from a measurable cardinal, Prikry forcing will not collapse cardinals. On the other hand, if U is derived from a \kappa -strongly compact measure on \delta then Prikry forcing with U will collapse all cardinals between \kappa and \delta . This perspective is closely connected to an independently interesting question: Can choiceless choiceless ultrafilters be used to construct a model where all cardinals are singular? Gitik [ 8 ] famously constructed this model from the assumption of a class of strongly compact cardinals. Apter [ 1 ] harnessed the power of AD to give a more direct construction of a model where all cardinals below \Theta are singular, using the result of Steel (see [ 17 ] ) that under AD, all regular cardinals in L(\mathbb{R}) below \Theta are measurable. If U behaves like a simple measurable, then one can try to extend Apter’s methods to singularize each \delta without collapsing it. If U behaves more like a strongly compact measure and will collapse many cardinals below \delta , then the existence of these ultrafilters would not give us any advantage over Gitik’s original construction. In this work we address these questions. Our main results stem from an analysis of well-founded ultrafilters on ordinals above a rank Berkeley, done in Section 3 , whose main finding is: Theorem 2 . For every \gamma above a rank Berkeley cardinal \lambda , and every well-founded ultrafilter U on a well-ordered set X , there is a surjection from {}^{\gamma}\gamma onto j_{U}(\gamma):=otp(\gamma^{X}/U) . The theorem extends Proposition 7.7 in [ 9 ] , which uses definability properties to show that for an even ordinal \epsilon , if U is a wellfounded ultrafilter on an ordinal \eta<\theta_{\epsilon+2} then j_{U}(\eta)=otp(\eta^{\eta}/U)<\theta_{\epsilon+2} . As an immediate Corollary of Theorem 2 , we get: Corollary 3 . For every strong limit cardinal \rho>\lambda , if \gamma<\rho and U is a well-founded ultrafilter on a well-ordered set X then |\gamma^{X}/U|<\rho . These results provide an answer to the first question we asked: in the sense of restricted powers, ultrafilters above a