The impact of precession and higher-order multipoles on cosmological inference

Charlie Hoy, Konstantin Leyde · 2025

Read The impact of precession and higher-order multipoles on cosmological inference by Charlie Hoy, Konstantin Leyde (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-07551.txt.

Introduction

Charlie Hoy and Konstantin Leyde check whether fancier gravitational wave models change cosmology answers. Merging black holes give distances and masses that together can measure the universe expansion rate without any light. That trick depends on wave models matching Einstein theory closely.

Precession and higher-order ripples add realism but also heavy computing cost. Comparing inferences with and without those effects shows no significant gain for expansion measurements in the cases tested. Simpler models may suffice for this task, saving scarce analysis time. The finding helps survey teams spend effort where it truly sharpens cosmic measurements.

Catalog record

CREATORCharlie Hoy, Konstantin Leyde
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-07551

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The impact of precession and higher-order multipoles on cosmological inference Charlie Hoy, Konstantin Leyde Abstract Gravitational-wave astronomy presents an exciting opportunity to provide an independent measurement of the expansion rate of the Universe. By combining inferences for the binary component masses and luminosity distances from individual observations, it is possible to infer H 0 H_{0} without direct electromagnetic counterparts or galaxy catalogs. However, this relies on theoretical gravitational-wave models, which are known to be incomplete descriptions of the full predictions of general relativity. Although the accuracy of our models are improving, they are also becoming increasingly expensive as additional phenomena are incorporated. In this work, we demonstrate that there is no significant advantage in including spin-precession and higher-order multipole moments when inferring H 0 H_{0} via the mass spectrum method for current and near-future gravitational-wave event numbers. Even when simulating a population of highly precessing and preferentially asymmetric-mass-ratio binaries, we show that the inferred H 0 H_{0} posterior changes minimally. Using a simpler, less accurate model, achieves comparable H 0 H_{0} estimates with six times less computational cost (on average). Using computationally cheaper models for single event inference may become crucial as thousands of gravitational-wave observations are expected to be detected in the near future. I Introduction Gravitational wave (GW) astronomy has attracted significant attention as it provides an independent probe to measure the expansion rate of the Universe: H_{0} LIGOScientific:2021aug ; LIGOScientific:2025jau . Indeed, the combined detection of GWs from two neutron stars LIGOScientific:2017vwq and its associated electromagnetic (EM) counterpart LIGOScientific:2017adf allowed H_{0} to be estimated within a relative uncertainty of 20\% , broadly consistent with measurements from the cosmic microwave background Planck:2018vyg and supernovae standard candles Riess:2019cxk ; Freedman:2024eph . An alternative method to estimate H_{0} from GWs uses the (redshifted) source-frame mass distribution, developed in Taylor:2011fs ; Taylor:2012db and further explored in Farr:2019twy ; Mastrogiovanni:2021wsd ; Mancarella:2021ecn ; Mukherjee:2021rtw ; Leyde:2022orh ; Karathanasis:2022rtr ; Ezquiaga:2022zkx ; Pierra:2023deu ; Leyde:2023iof ; Borghi:2023opd ; Farah:2024xub ; MaganaHernandez:2024uty ; Mali:2024wpq ; Agarwal:2024hld ; Mancarella:2025uat . When the GW propagates on an expanding spacetime, the signal depends on the source-frame mass, m_{\rm s} through the combination of m_{\rm d}=m_{\rm s}(1+z) , where this new quantity is referred to as the detector-frame mass. The so-called mass spectrum method, also referred to as the spectral siren method, estimates H_{0} by combining the measured detector-frame mass and the source-frame mass distribution into a redshift measurement. Using luminosity distance directly inferred from the GW data, constraints can be placed on H_{0} through the luminosity distance-redshift relation. Other approaches include using galaxy catalogs to build a three-dimensional prior on the compact binary coalescence (CBC) distribution Schutz:1986gp ; DelPozzo:2011vcw ; Gray:2019ksv ; Gray:2021sew ; Finke:2021aom ; Mukherjee:2022afz ; Turski:2023lxq ; Mastrogiovanni:2023emh ; Gray:2023wgj ; Borghi:2023opd ; Rauf:2023oiy ; Perna:2024lod ; Hanselman:2024hqy ; Leyde:2024tov ; Li:2025hrh ; Naveed:2025kgk ; Leyde:2025rzk , often referred to as the dark siren method. However, currently employed catalogs are essentially empty at the higher-end of luminosity distances associated with GWs . This is why we do not see a significant improvement in the H_{0} measurement despite an increased GW catalog when adding in galaxy catalog information LIGOScientific:2021aug ; LIGOScientific:2025jau ; LIGOScientific:2025yae ; LIGOScientific:2025hdt . Inferring H_{0} from GW observations is challenging since our estimates for the source properties depend on the theoretical waveform model used for inference; our models are not perfect descriptions of the full predictions of general relativity, and systematic errors due to mis-modelling known physical effects, often referred to as waveform systematics, can cause discrepancies in e.g. the inferred luminosity distance and detector-frame component masses. For example, when analysing GW231123_135430, a short duration GW signal from the first part of the fourth GW observing run LIGOScientific:2025rsn , the inferred luminosity distance varied from 0.7 – 4.1 Gpc depending on the model used; each model inferred a large distance uncertainty: \sim 2\,\mathrm{Gpc} . However, typically the difference between models is much smaller. Refs. Kunert:2024xqb ; Dhani:2025xgt explored the impact of waveform systematics on our ability to infer H_{0} by injecting and recovering different models that include the same underlying physics. They showed that for a population of binary neutron stars (BNSs) , the expected biases from different modelling frameworks – effective-one-body Pan:2013rra ; Babak:2016tgq ; Bohe:2016gbl ; Pompili:2023tna ; Cotesta:2018fcv ; Cotesta:2020qhw ; Ossokine:2020kjp ; Ramos-Buades:2023ehm ; Gamboa:2024hli , phenomenological Husa:2015iqa ; Khan:2015jqa ; Hannam:2013oca ; Khan:2018fmp ; Pratten:2020fqn ; Estelles:2020osj ; Estelles:2021gvs ; Hamilton:2021pkf ; London:2017bcn ; Garcia-Quiros:2020qpx ; Estelles:2020twz ; Khan:2019kot ; Pratten:2020ceb ; Thompson:2023ase ; Colleoni:2024knd and post-Newtonian Blanchet:1995ez ; Blanchet:2004ek ; Mishra:2016whh – are below statistical uncertainties of current detectors (using the bright siren method), while for binary black holes (BBHs) it is possible to obtain unreliable measurements for H_{0} in future GW observing runs. Another source of systematic errors is the exclusion of known general relativistic phenomena when inferring the source properties from GWs ; typically, simplified models are initially developed and improved upon over subsequent years by incorporating additional physical effects. Two examples are spin-induced orbital precession – the general relativistic phenomenon where spins misaligned with the orbital angular momentum of the binary causes the orbital plane to precess around the total angular momentum ( Apostolatos:1994mx ) – and higher-order multipole moments ( Goldberg:1966uu ) . A major benefit of using models that include spin-precession and higher-order multipoles is that they break degeneracies in the parameter space, particularly the distance – inclination degeneracy ( Usman:2018imj ; CalderonBustillo:2020kcg ) . Refs. Feeney:2020kxk ; Vitale:2018wlg explored the impact of missing physics on our ability to infer H_{0} for a population of neutron star black hole binaries with electromagnetic counterparts. Ref. Feeney:2020kxk showed that by including spin-precession in their models, a \sim 40\% improvement in their estimates for H_{0} can be obtained. Ref. Vitale:2018wlg demonstrated that more precise distance estimates can be obtained for precessing neutron star black hole binaries compared to non-spinning binary neutron star mergers. By assuming that the inferred redshift and peculiar velocity of the host galaxy were perfectly known, this leads to a reduced H_{0} uncertainty. In this work, we investigate how missing physics impacts our ability to infer H_{0} for a population of BBHs when using the mass spectrum method. By analysing both real and simulated GW data, we show there is no significant advantage in performing inference with models that include spin-precession and higher-order multipole moments when estimating H_{0} ; other statistical errors dominate the uncertainty. We verify that we only see minor differences in the inferred H_{0} when simulating a highly spinning, non-astrophysically motivated population with preferences for asymmetric binary masses, where spin-precession and higher-order multipole moments are expected to contribute significantly to the GW morphology. Our conclusions are based on both current and future sensitivities of the Advanced LIGO LIGOScientific:2014pky and Virgo det4-VIRGO:2014yos GW detectors. This paper is structured as follows: in Sec. II we review the different waveform models used in this work, as well as single-event and hierarchical Bayesian analyses. In Sec. III.1 we analyse publicly available GW strain data with waveform models that include different underlying physics and investigate the impact on estimating H_{0} . In Sec. III.2 we consider how our conclusions change for a population of BBHs with large spin magnitudes and preferentially asymmetric component

Read the complete text