Surprisingly Similar: The Mass Function of Gaia Neutron Stars and First-Born Double Neutron Stars NumPy ( 28 ) , SciPy ( 87 ) , Matplotlib ( 30 ) , pandas ( 53 ) , Seaborn ( 89 ) , JAX ( 10 ) , NumPyro ( 63 ) , ArviZ ( 39 ) , and corner.py ( 24 ) .
Aryanna Schiebelbein-Zwack, L. A. C. van Son, Maya Fishbach, Will M. Farr · 2025
Read Surprisingly Similar: The Mass Function of Gaia Neutron Stars and First-Born Double Neutron Stars NumPy ( 28 ) , SciPy ( 87 ) , Matplotlib ( 30 ) , pandas ( 53 ) , Seaborn ( 89 ) , JAX ( 10 ) , NumPyro ( 63 ) , ArviZ ( 39 ) , and corner.py ( 24 ) . by Aryanna Schiebelbein-Zwack, L. A. C. van Son, Maya Fishbach, Will M. Farr (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-07393.txt.
Introduction
Neutron star masses carry clues about how these dense stars form and evolve in pairs. Aryanna Schiebelbein-Zwack and colleagues compare two groups that should differ: Gaia neutron stars in wide orbits with sun-like stars, and the first-born recycled pulsars in double neutron star systems.
Against expectation, the two mass patterns look strikingly alike. Both show a narrow peak near one point three solar masses plus a broader spread toward heavier stars. Selection effects and different histories might have split them apart, yet the fits overlap closely. Readers get a careful test of whether birth history leaves a clear mass fingerprint.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Aryanna Schiebelbein-Zwack, L. A. C. van Son, Maya Fishbach, Will M. Farr |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-07393
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Surprisingly Similar: The Mass Function of Gaia Neutron Stars and First-Born Double Neutron Stars NumPy ( 28 ) , SciPy ( 87 ) , Matplotlib ( 30 ) , pandas ( 53 ) , Seaborn ( 89 ) , JAX ( 10 ) , NumPyro ( 63 ) , ArviZ ( 39 ) , and corner.py ( 24 ) . Aryanna Schiebelbein-Zwack, L. A. C. van Son, Maya Fishbach, Will M. Farr Abstract The mass distribution of neutron stars encodes information about their formation and binary evolution. We compare the masses of two distinct populations: I) the recently identified Gaia neutron stars in wide orbits with solar-like companions and, II) the assumed first-born recycled pulsar in Galactic double neutron star systems. Naively, one would expect their masses to differ due to both the presumed differences in their evolutionary histories, as well as astrophysical selection effects that can filter out configurations that would merge or be disrupted. Yet, we find that their mass distributions are strikingly similar. Using a two-component Gaussian model, we find that both populations exhibit a narrow component centred near 1.3 M ⊙ 1.3\text{ M}_{\odot} , accompanied by a broader, higher-mass component that extends the distribution toward larger masses. The highest density regions of their fitted parameter posteriors coincide by over 91.6%. Statistical tests further confirm the agreement between these distributions with a Jensen-Shannon divergence J S < 0.08 JS<0.08 and an earth mover’s distance of W < 0.063 M ⊙ W<0.063\text{ M}_{\odot} at 90 % \% credibility. This finding seems to imply that both mass functions reflect the natal mass distribution of first-born neutron stars in binary systems, supporting the hypothesis that neutron stars can be born with high masses. Consequently and perhaps surprisingly, binary evolutionary processes need not impart features on the NS mass distribution. I Introduction The shape of the observed mass distribution of neutron stars (NSs) is a consequence of multiple complex and still poorly understood physical processes, including stellar evolution, supernova physics, and the NS equation of state ( 81 ; 64 ; 82 ; 62 ; 36 ; 7 ; 61 ) . The global mass distribution of known NSs is commonly modelled as a bimodal function, with a sharp peak at \sim 1.3\text{ M}_{\odot} and a second wider peak near \sim 1.8\text{ M}_{\odot} ( 82 ; 36 ; 7 ; 5 ) . More recently, a study by 92 found that the masses of NSs can be described by a unimodal distribution when accounting for the mass accreted by recycled pulsars in binary systems. Regardless of the true structure of the NS mass distribution, it remains unclear whether the apparent structure and the overall shape of the mass distribution reflects the natal mass function of NSs or is instead shaped by binary evolution and observational selection effects. NSs are found in a wide range of binary configurations, including young pulsars with OB companions ( 33 ; 8 ; 70 ; 49 ; 6 ; 83 ) , wind-fed high-mass X-ray binaries ( 66 , e.g.,) , low-mass X-ray binaries with Roche-lobe–overflowing companions ( 25 , e.g.,) , recycled pulsars with white dwarf or NS companions ( 78 ; 77 , e.g.,) , non-interacting NS–main-sequence binaries detected astrometrically (e.g., Gaia NSs; 17 ), and gravitational-wave (GW) sources ( 2 ; 1 ; 3 ; 80 ) . These different subpopulations of NSs contribute to the global NS mass distribution in unique ways, representing snapshots of distinct binary evolutionary stages and offering insight into their histories and interaction pathways. Several studies have argued that binary interactions can significantly reshape a star’s core structure, altering both the SN outcome and the properties of the resulting remnant ( 69 ; 68 ; 42 ) . Consider electron-capture supernovae ( 54 ; 58 ; 59 , ECSNe;) , which may be more common in stars that have undergone binary stripping ( 64 ) . ECSNe are expected to produce NSs with a narrower mass range and smaller natal kicks compared to iron-core collapse supernovae, which yield a broader mass distribution extending to higher masses ( 81 ; 64 ; 69 ; 82 ; 62 ; 5 ) . Similarly, ultra-stripped supernovae (USSNe), following case BB mass transfer ( 16 ; 79 ) , are a subclass of stripped-envelope SNe that are thought to produce lower mass remnants with weak natal kicks ( 74 ; 55 ; 56 ) . Such differences in SN mechanisms and remnant properties influence the properties of surviving binaries. For instance, the gravitational wave population of NSs is proposed to originate from ECSN or USSNe due to these theoretical lower natal kicks ( 26 , e.g.,) . However, the broad, nearly uniform mass distribution (with perhaps a bias toward higher masses) seen in the gravitational wave NS population ( 41 ) , seems to be in contradiction with the sharp 1.25 \text{ M}_{\odot} feature associated with ECSN ( 69 ) . Lastly, the origin of the more massive end of the NS mass distribution has long been a subject of particular interest. Post-formation accretion is one possible contribution; millisecond pulsars can gain \sim 0.1-0.3\text{ M}_{\odot} through accretion, whereas the recycled, first-borns in Galactic double NS (DNS) systems are thought to gain only <0.02\text{ M}_{\odot} ( 36 ; 85 ; 7 ; 61 ; 77 ; 44 ) . Yet, accretion alone can not explain the high-mass features of the mass distribution since the difference in the 1.3\text{ M}_{\odot} and 1.8\text{ M}_{\odot} features exceeds the typical accreted mass required to spin-up a pulsar ( 36 ; 44 ) . The connection between accretion, spin-up, and mass is further complicated by observations such as those of PSR J1802-2124 and PSR J1807-2500B, which seemingly have histories of accretion due to their orbital properties and spins and yet have masses 1.24\pm 0.11\text{ M}_{\odot} and 1.3655\pm 0.0021\text{ M}_{\odot} respectively ( 61 ) . Hence, it is possible to spin-up a NS without making it overly massive. Growing evidence suggests that some NSs can instead be born massive depending on their final iron core mass ( 81 ; 82 ; 36 ; 7 ; 57 ; 73 ) . Still, theoretical predictions for the final remnant mass after a core collapse supernova often underpredict the location of the 1.3\text{ M}_{\odot} peak while overpredicting its width, which is especially narrow in the case of DNSs considering stochastic processes such as fallback ( 62 ; 57 ) , although 73 do find their model predicts an average NS mass of 1.38\text{ M}_{\odot} . In short, the relationship between features in the NS mass distribution and the physical processes that shape them remains unclear, and several of the currently proposed explanations appear to contain contradictions. In this work, we will compare two distinct NS populations — the galactic DNSs and the newly discovered NSs in Gaia data release 3 ( 17 ) — to assess how their presumed distinct evolutionary histories manifest in their respective mass distributions. As implied by the previous discussion, it is well established that NSs in different systems are expected to produce different mass distributions ( 64 ; 36 ) . According to isolated binary evolution models, the recycled NS in DNS binaries are