Manifest Symplecticity in Classical Scattering

Joon-Hwi Kim · 2025

Read Manifest Symplecticity in Classical Scattering by Joon-Hwi Kim (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-07387.txt.

Introduction

Joon-Hwi Kim examines how classical mechanics can make a basic conservation property obvious. The Liouville theorem says motion in phase space flows without compression, like an incompressible fluid. Kim compares two frameworks that each display that property in a different way.

Hamilton-Jacobi theory gives an in-out picture suited to scattering, where particles enter and leave. A newer exponential form gives an in-in picture focused on evolution itself. Worked examples show the key objects in each view differ, yet a matching calculation links them. The result is a clean, fully classical account of scattering built from first principles.

Catalog record

CREATORJoon-Hwi Kim
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE98 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-07387

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Manifest Symplecticity in Classical Scattering Joon-Hwi Kim Abstract The Liouville theorem states that classical time evolution is an incompressible flow in phase space. We investigate two formulations of classical mechanics in which this property is manifested. First, the traditional Hamilton-Jacobi theory provides an in-out formalism. Second, a recent idea employing an exponential representation of time evolution provides an in-in formalism. Through explicit examples, it is demonstrated that the on-shell action in the former and the exponential generator in the latter are disparate objects. Still, a concrete relation between the two is identified in terms of a matching calculation. A strictly classical derivation and formulation of classical scattering theory is provided. CALT-TH 2025-035 1 Introduction Picture two giant black holes orbiting each other, creating gravitational waves that will eventually reach our detectors at LIGO LIGOScientific:2016aoc ; LIGOScientific:2017vwq . To make theoretical predictions for such gravitational wave signals, it is necessary to grasp the classical gravitational dynamics of macroscopic astrophysical bodies. Interestingly, modern physicists find themselves using quantum field theory, i.e., the very framework developed for microscopic particles, to efficiently perform high-precision computations for such theoretical predictions KMOC ; Bern:2021dqo ; Bern:2019crd ; Bern:2019nnu ; Cheung:2018wkq ; Neill:2013wsa ; Levi:2018nxp ; Porto:2016pyg ; Goldberger:2004jt ; Kalin:2020mvi ; Kalin:2020fhe ; Mogull:2020sak ; Jakobsen:2021zvh ; Jakobsen:2021smu ; Jakobsen:2022psy ; Kalin:2022hph ; Jakobsen:2023ndj ; Jakobsen:2023pvx ; Dlapa:2021vgp ; Dlapa:2022lmu ; Dlapa:2023hsl ; Driesse:2024xad ; Dlapa:2024cje ; Dlapa:2025biy ; Haddad:2025cmw ; He:2025how . The idea is to think of astrophysical objects effectively as point particles and study their scattering amplitudes, encoding physical information about their dynamics. The slogan has been “extract classical observables classical observables from quantum scattering.” In particular, the systematics of this procedure has been thoroughly established by Kosower, Maybee, and O’Connell (KMO’C) KMOC . In the KMO’C formalism, the starting point is the quantum S-matrix . A formula for classical observables arises by splitting the S-matrix as identity plus the T -matrix. One then takes the \hbar{\>\to\>}0 limit while properly checking the cancellation of divergent terms dubbed superclassical terms. Meanwhile, another axis of development has been worldline techniques Levi:2018nxp ; Porto:2016pyg ; Goldberger:2004jt ; Kalin:2020mvi ; Kalin:2020fhe ; Mogull:2020sak ; Jakobsen:2021zvh ; Jakobsen:2021smu ; Jakobsen:2022psy ; Kalin:2022hph ; Jakobsen:2023ndj ; Jakobsen:2023pvx ; Dlapa:2021vgp ; Dlapa:2022lmu ; Dlapa:2023hsl ; Driesse:2024xad ; Dlapa:2024cje ; Dlapa:2025biy ; Haddad:2025cmw ; He:2025how . In this approach, the astrophysical bodies are modeled directly in terms of point-particle actions. To obtain classical observables, one can compute the on-shell action on-shell action by summing over tree diagrams in the quantum-mechanical perturbation theory. The on-shell action, also known as principal function, is a function of the boundary conditions specified for the worldline. Via the Hamilton-Jacobi framework, the on-shell action serves as a master object whose first derivatives derive the impulse of classical observables. This inherently describes an in-out in-out formalism, as the definition of the on-shell action requires a complete specification of the boundary conditions at the both ends of the worldline. A more suitable approach for classical physics, however, could be an in-in in-in formalism, where one deduces the unknown final state solely from the knowledge of the initial state. The systematics of the in-in formalism has been established through works Kalin:2020mvi ; Kalin:2020fhe ; Mogull:2020sak ; Jakobsen:2021zvh ; Jakobsen:2021smu ; Jakobsen:2022psy ; Kalin:2022hph ; Jakobsen:2023ndj ; Jakobsen:2023pvx . However, what would be the master object that derives the classical observables, in the in-in formalism? The on-shell action cannot be an answer, as it is inherently an in-out quantity due to its very identity as an action. Namely, what shall the in-in formalism compute? Recently, works wlf-ps ; ambikerr1 ; eikonal1 ; eikonal2 ; eikonal5 ; eikonalfield have revisited the foundations of worldline methods from the perspectives of Hamiltonian (phase space) formulation. For instance, Ref. wlf-ps has observed useful universal features of phase space worldline formalisms while implementing an in-out framework optimized for computing scattering amplitudes. In the meantime, Refs. eikonal1 ; eikonal2 ; eikonalfield ; eikonal5 have investigated the in-in formalism and identified a clear goalpost: scattering generator scattering generator . The earliest inception of this idea took place in the work ambikerr1 , where the current author proposed to identify the classical analog of the S-matrix as a symplectomorphism. The S-matrix is the map from the initial Hilbert space to the final Hilbert space in a scattering problem. In the same way, the “ S-symplectomorphism ” is the map from the initial phase space to the final phase space in a classical scattering problem. Arguments were given for a correspondence between the S-matrix and the S-symplectomorphism, inspired by ideas in symplectic geometry and quantization theory woodhouse1997geometric ; kontsevich . An explicit completion of this idea, however, was only facilitated through the works eikonal1 ; eikonal2 . There, a precise definition and formula was provided for the “logarithm” of the S-symplectomorphism, dubbed scattering generator \chi . It is explicitly identified that the scattering generator is the classical limit of the eikonal matrix Lehmann:1957zz ; Damgaard:2021ipf ; Damgaard:2023ttc \hat{\chi} that arises by the exponential parameterization of the S-matrix: \hat{S}=\exp(\hat{\chi}/i\hbar) . In this sense, the scattering generator \chi is also called the classical eikonal. Notably, this exponential parameterization facilitates a computation of the classical observables via nested Poisson brackets, in which the superclassical terms are absent by construction. Hence the slogan may be revised: “derive classical observables from classical scattering (as S-symplectomorphism).” This emphasizes that the classical limit is explicitly imposed from the very beginning. The nested Poisson bracket formula provides an alternative to the KMO’C formalism, systematically deriving the impulse of classical observables in a purely in-in fashion due to the very nature of the exponential map. As a result, the scattering generator \chi can serve as the master object in the in-in formalism. The nested Poisson bracket formula traces back to Ref. Damgaard:2023ttc and was also independently discovered by Ref. Gonzo:2024zxo in systems with symmetries, just before the release of Ref. eikonal1 . In sum, a well-organized landscape of worldline techniques arises, in terms of the question “What does it compute?”: In-Out Formalism \displaystyle\quad\text{computes}\quad\textbf{On-Shell Action}\,, In-In Formalism \displaystyle\quad\text{computes}\quad\textbf{Scattering Generator}\,. The perturbative computation of the scattering generator describes the Magnus magnus1954exponential series, not the Dyson series which the conventional Feynman diagrammatics employs. Hence the combinatorics for scattering generator differs from that for on-shell action, crucially. Figure 1: An illustration of symplecticity: time evolution preserves area element in phase space. Given the circumstance that our understanding on the scattering generator has been evolving lately ambikerr1 ; eikonal1 ; eikonal2 ; eikonal5 ; eikonalfield ; Haddad:2025cmw , it might be beneficial if the relation between these two currencies for classical observables, the on-shell action and the scattering generator, can be clarified. The purpose of this article is to provide a friendly introduction and review on both currencies, together with their detailed comparison. We aim for a purely classical presentation of these ideas so that this article might even be used as a class material in a classical mechanics course, eventually. The perspective taken in this article is the following. In quantum mechanics and quantum field theory, unitarity is a sacred principle: the conservation of probability. Notably, there exists a classical counterpart of this concept: Liouville property Liouville property . Liouville property is the

Read the complete text