Decoherence from universal tomographic measurements
Dorje C. Brody 1,2 and Rishindra Melanathuru 2 · 2025
Read Decoherence from universal tomographic measurements by Dorje C. Brody 1,2 and Rishindra Melanathuru 2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-07369.txt.
Introduction
Dorje C Brody and Rishindra Melanathuru work out what happens when a quantum system is watched by measuring everything at once rather than watching one preferred observable. This universal tomographic watching is modeled in two equivalent ways: repeated positive operator-valued readings, and a continuous-time version of the Lindblad equation. The decoherence it causes is tracked through Stratonovich-Weyl quasiprobability distributions, which can dip negative for truly quantum states.
The authors show the watching step by step makes any such distribution manifestly positive, a concrete sense in which classicality emerges from being watched. More striking still, the decoherence time, the time after which every initial state's distribution is nonnegative, shrinks as the Hilbert space dimension grows. Larger quantum systems, in this model, lose their quantum nature faster than small ones.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dorje C. Brody 1,2 and Rishindra Melanathuru 2 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-07369
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Decoherence from universal tomographic measurements Dorje C. Brody 1,2 and Rishindra Melanathuru 2 Abstract The decoherence phenomenon arising from an environmental monitoring of the state of a quantum system, as opposed to monitoring of a preferred observable, is worked out in detail using two equivalent formulations, namely, repeated applications of universal tomographic measurements using positive operator-valued measures, and its continuous time unravelling from the Lindblad equation. The effect of decoherence is analysed by studying the evolution of Stratonovich-Weyl quasiprobability distributions on the state-space of the system. It is shown that decoherence makes an arbitrary-given quasiprobability distribution manifestly positive, thus modelling the emergence of classicality in some sense. The decoherence timescale, the minimum time that quasiprobability distributions of every initial state of the system become nonnegative, is shown to decrease in Hilbert-space dimension, and hence larger quantum systems decohere faster. The effect of decoherence resulting from a quantum system immersed in an environment is often modelled by an effective monitoring of a preferred observable of the system by the environment Zurek2003 ; Schlosshauer2007 ; Joos2003 ; Jacobs2006 ; Busch1996 . This results in the decay of the off-diagonal elements of the density matrix of the system in the basis of the preferred observable. But what if the environment monitors the actual state of the system itself, albeit a fuzzy monitoring, and not merely a single preferred observable? This question can be addressed by use of a tomographic measurement based on a positive operator-valued measure (POVM), where the outcome of a measurement is the point on the state space of the system, and the resulting outcome state is the quantum state corresponding to that point BGM . If a tomographic measurement were to be performed by the environment of a quantum system, then measurement outcomes will not be recorded, and we are led to a decoherence effect. The purpose of the present paper is to investigate properties of this effect. Our primary focus here concerns the timescale for decoherence. The decoherence timescale can be estimated in a variety of ways, for example by requiring the off-diagonal elements of the density matrix reducing below a threshold, but here we define decoherence timescale to be determined by the requirement that a given quasiprobability distribution on the state space becomes nonnegative. Of course, there is an entire parametric family of quasiprobability distributions, including, for example, the Wigner function, so what we will find is that there is a parametric family of decoherence timescales, one for each choice of the quasiprobability distribution. Assuming that the system-environment coupling is independent of the Hilbert space dimension N , we show that the decoherence timescale decays in N like N^{-1}\ln N for large N . This implies that for a macroscopic quantum system, irrespective of the initial state of that system, any quasiprobability distribution will lose its negativity virtually instantly under a tomographic decoherence model. The present paper is organised as follows. We begin by modelling decoherence effects using a universal state-space tomographic measurement BH2 . Unlike the conventional measurement-based formulation of decoherence where repeated measurements necessarily yield the same outcome, in the case of a measurement based on POVM, the outcome states are in general not orthogonal so that a measurement following immediately after another measurement will yield a different outcome. Therefore, one can repeat the measurements, progressively decohering the state of the system. In the case of a tomographic measurement, we first work out the effect on the density matrix of the system, followed by an analysis of its corresponding Stratonovich-Weyl quasiprobability distribution defined on the whole of the state space. We show, in particular, that for a quasiprobability distribution of degree \sigma , its negativity necessarily disappears when the number of measurements exceeds the smallest integer greater than (1+\sigma)/2 . We then consider a continuous-time version of the model, given by a Lindblad equation, with the property that the solution to the Lindblad equation interpolates the outcome states of the iterated POVM measurements at discrete times. By expressing the solution in terms of the Stratonovich-Weyl quasiprobability distribution, we derive the decoherence timescale arising from a continuous-time tomographic monitoring of the system. This timescale is defined by the property that the negativity in the quasiprobability distribution necessarily vanishes for all quantum states. We remark that the identification of a continuous-time unravelling of the universal tomographic measurement in terms of a Lindblad equation, and the investigation of the classicalisation timescale in terms of the positivity of the quasiprobability distribution, has recently been pursued in Xu2025 , although the correct timescale was not obtained therein. Let us begin by remarking that quantum state tomography concerns the reconstruction of the state of a system from measurements on an ensemble of identically prepared copies of the system James2001 ; Paris2004 ; Chiribella2004 ; Bagan2006 ; Durt2010 ; Toth2010 . There are many ways of achieving this, but here we consider a universal tomographic measurement BH2 , by which we mean a maximum POVM measurement where the measurement outcome is the position \psi of the state in the space of rays through the origin of Hilbert space, and the output state is the pure state |\psi\rangle corresponding to that state. Such a measurement is called “universal” because it involves only the structure of the state space, without any preferred observable. The fact that such a measurement forms a POVM follows from the resolution of the identity \int_{\mathcal{PH}}|\psi\rangle\langle\psi|\,{\mbox{$\rm d$}}\mu_{\psi}=\mathds{1} . Here the integration measure \mbox{$\rm d$}\mu_{\psi} is the usual Fubini-Study volume element brody2001geometric of the projective Hilbert space \mathcal{PH} , scaled by the Hilbert space dimension N . Under such a measurement, if the initial state of the system is given by the density matrix {\hat{\rho}} , then the probability of detecting quantum state \psi in the region A of the state space is \displaystyle\mathbb{P}(\psi\in A)\;=\;\int_{A}Q(\psi)\,\mbox{$\rm d$}\mu_{\psi}\,, (1) where Q(\psi)=\langle\psi|\hat{\rho}|\psi\rangle is the expectation of the initial state {\hat{\rho}} in the pure state |\psi\rangle , which is nonnegative and defines a probability density over the space \mathcal{PH} of pure states brody2011information . If the state of the system is monitored by the environment, then the measurement outcomes are not recorded. In this case we average over all possible results to characterise the state of the system. In particular, this “nonselective” measurement results in the update of the state of the system, after a single universal tomographic measurement, given by \displaystyle\hat{\rho}^{(1)}\;=\;\int_{\mathcal{PH}}|\psi\rangle\langle\psi|\,Q(\psi)\,\mbox{$\rm d$}\mu_{\psi}\,. (2) To analyse the effect of this transformation rule, it is convenient to expand the density matrix in the so-called generalised Bloch representation Nemoto ; Hioe1985 ; Zhong2013 ; Bertlmann2008 ; bengtsson2017geometry ; NielsenChuang \displaystyle\hat{\rho}\;=\;\frac{1}{N}\,\mathds{1}\;+\;\frac{1}{2}\sum_{a=1}^{N^{2}-1}r_{a}\,{\hat{\lambda}}_{a}, (3) where \{{\hat{\lambda}}_{a}\} are the generators of the Lie algebra \mathfrak{su}(N) . These generators are trace-free Hermitian matrices normalised by \mathrm{tr}({\hat{\lambda}}_{a}{\hat{\lambda}}_{b})=2\,\delta_{ab} , and obey the commutation and anticommutation relations [{\hat{\lambda}}_{a},{\hat{\lambda}}_{b}]=2{\rm i}f_{ab}^{~~c}\,{\hat{\lambda}}_{c} and \{{\hat{\lambda}}_{a},{\hat{\lambda}}_{b}\}=\frac{4}{N}\delta_{ab}\,\mathds{1}+2d_{ab}^{~~c}\,{\hat{\lambda}}_{c} , with f_{ab}^{~~c} and d_{ab}^{~~c} the antisymmetric and symmetric structure constants, respectively. The real coefficients r_{a}={\rm tr}(\hat{\rho}{\hat{\lambda}}_{a}) therefore determine the state {\hat{\rho}} of the system, which can be viewed as forming the generalised Bloch vector \vec{r} . In this representation, the action of the universal tomographic POVM channel on the state becomes transparent: The identity component remains invariant, while the Bloch vector contracts by a fixed damping factor set by the measurement strength or number