Mapping Power Relations: A Geometric Framework for Game-Theoretic Analysis
Daniele De Luca · 2025
Read Mapping Power Relations: A Geometric Framework for Game-Theoretic Analysis by Daniele De Luca (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-07287.txt.
Introduction
Daniele De Luca maps power in games geometrically, without first choosing anyone's payoff function. Payoff assignments in game theory carry guesswork, and recent methods inherit it. De Luca instead defines a standard preference space in which each player's relational stance is a normalized vector. A game's payoffs and outcomes are projected onto this space, and the resulting landscape is summed up by metrics including a center of mass and structural markers for hierarchy and reciprocity.
Classic concepts, bargaining power, dependence, and reciprocity, reappear as geometric features, widened beyond their original settings. Demonstrations on the Prisoner's Dilemma, the Battle of the Sexes, and a Cournot duopoly reveal shared structure across very different strategic cases. The system treats power as a structural property of the mapping from preferences to equilibria, bridging cooperative and non-cooperative game theory.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Daniele De Luca |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 60 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-07287
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Mapping Power Relations: A Geometric Framework for Game-Theoretic Analysis Daniele De Luca Abstract This paper develops a geometric framework for analyzing power relations in games. We introduce the preference space , a canonical domain in which each player’s relational stance—altruistic, selfish, antagonistic, or neutral—is represented as a vector in a normalized projective space. We show how classical concepts such as bargaining power, dependence, and reciprocity can be recovered within this framework and extended to arbitrary non-cooperative environments. Applications to standard bimatrix games, economic models, and three-player games demonstrate that the preference space reveals structural similarities across different strategic settings, even when their strategy sets differ. In particular, we show how to compute indices that synthesize hierarchical and reciprocal structures at the game level. This unified perspective bridges cooperative and non-cooperative approaches to power, providing a relational measure of influence that is independent of the specific strategic form. 1 Introduction The study of power relations has deep roots in both economics and political science. Power is often defined as an actor’s capacity to alter another’s behavior or welfare. Foundational definitions by ( 13 ) , ( 33 ) , ( 3 ) , and ( 5 ) converge on this core idea of inducing change. Furthermore, as ( 11 ) and Stoppino in ( 25 ) stress, this change is typically directed to serve the power-wielder’s interests. From this perspective, positive (negative) power is the capacity of being favored (harmed) by others. Within economics, the Marxist tradition was one of the first to address the theme of power ( 28 ) . For Marx, the capitalist mode of production rests on the appropriation of unpaid labor time, producing a systematic asymmetry of power between classes ( 24 ) . Engels emphasized that this domination is not due to individual greed or wickedness but is embedded in the social organization of production itself ( 16 ) . Lenin extended the analysis to the global sphere, arguing that monopolistic control enables core economies to extract surplus from peripheral nations ( 23 ) . Later Marxist economists such as ( 15 ) and ( 35 ) developed this into a systematic theory of unequal exchange or dependence, showing how international trade reproduces global hierarchies of power. Across these strands, the Marxist view treats power as a structural inequality masked by the apparent equality of exchange in the free market. This conception is close to the previous one: the worker structurally favors the capitalist, and the peripheral country structurally favors the core. Classical cooperative game theory introduced power indices such as the Shapley–Shubik index ( 31 ) and the Banzhaf index ( 2 ) , which measure a player’s ability to alter collective outcomes in voting situations. Both indices distribute the total “value” or “power” created by a coalition among its members by asking a counterfactual question: what would have happened if this agent had not been present? At first sight, the political–economic tradition and the cooperative game-theoretic tradition appear distinct, if not opposite: for the former, power means to be favored; for the latter, power means the capacity to favor others. Yet both converge in conceiving power as strictly tied to utility and gain. With Aristotelian terminology, these two aspects can be described as the actual and the potential of power. In our framework, the preference space has a natural origin at the identity matrix I , where subjective and objective utilities coincide. This makes it intrinsically an actual/ex-post construct, representing realized or counterfactually realized payoffs. Potential or ex-ante aspects of power (e.g., capacity to change equilibria before they materialize) can only be recovered by averaging over distributions of preferences, as we do later in the bargaining power section. Subsequent research has investigated power in bargaining contexts, often linking it to the distribution of disagreement payoffs, commitment opportunities, or agenda-setting roles ( 8 ; 4 ; 29 ) . ( 30 ) emphasized the role of credible threats as a strategic source of power, while contest theory ( 34 ; 32 ) highlighted asymmetries in the conversion of resources into winning probabilities. In parallel, models of informational power have developed within Bayesian persuasion and information design ( 22 ) . What these diverse strands have in common is the counterfactual reasoning and the attempt to capture power as an influence over outcomes, whether by rules, resources, timing, or threats. Yet none of these approaches provides a general, non-cooperative analysis of power that applies across arbitrary strategic environments. Describing power is often challenging due to its relational nature: unlike standard economics, you need to consider the choices of a player in connection with the payoff of another player. ( 21 ) made a notable attempt to develop a measure of dependence in game theory, raising, for the first time (as long as we know), counterfactual question of the type: what would happen if a player plays assuming the utility of another? Their results build a bridge between non-cooperative and coalitional games. Along the same line of thought, a recent proposal by ( 20 ) defines a general measure of bargaining power as counterfactual influence. A player’s power is quantified by the extent to which the outcome distribution of a game changes when their preferences are substituted, normalized relative to the “local dictator” benchmark where all players adopt the same utility. Their axiomatic characterization shows that this measure is unique under natural requirements (null player, local dictator, proportionality, invariance, and compound games). Moreover, when applied to voting environments, it reduces to classical indices such as Shapley–Shubik and Banzhaf, thereby unifying older concepts within a general framework. The key insight is that power can be seen as a structural property of the mapping from preferences to equilibria, not reducible to material payoffs alone or to the credibility of threats. In the Görlach–Motz model, the set of "relevant" utilities U is chosen on a case-by-case basis: the authors describe it as ‘intentionally vague’ and acknowledge that specifying U is, in practice, a matter of researcher discretion. To counter this arbitrariness, they impose the axiom of invariance to irrelevant extensions (A1), meaning that adding utility functions to U does not change the measure of power. Yet the selection of U remains ex ante discretionary. While Görlach–Motz avoid the arbitrariness of strategic form by outsourcing to outcome probabilities, they reintroduce arbitrariness in the choice of the utility domain U . Our preference space removes this discretion: it provides a canonical, continuous, and game-independent domain where every player’s relational posture is defined up to scale. Unlike discrete specifications of U , this domain captures the full geometry of possible relations, including those necessary to sustain mixed-preference equilibria. In our preference space, each point represents a specific configuration of players’ social preferences (altruistic, selfish, antagonistic and so on). Each player may adopt altruistic, selfish, or antagonistic stances toward self and others. This idea has been developed within the tradition of interdependent preference models dating back to ( 26 ) , ( 19 ) , ( 27 ) , ( 6 ) , and ( 7 ) , and extended to inequity aversion and fairness considerations ( 17 ; 10 ; 12 ; 1 ; 18 ) . Empirical studies further stress the