Oxygen vacancies in vanadium dioxide: A DFT+ V study
Oskar Leibnitz, Peter Mlkvik, Nicola A. Spaldin, Claude Ederer · 2025
Read Oxygen vacancies in vanadium dioxide: A DFT+ V study by Oskar Leibnitz, Peter Mlkvik, Nicola A. Spaldin, Claude Ederer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-07284.txt.
Introduction
Oskar Leibnitz, Peter Mlkvik, Nicola A Spaldin, and Claude Ederer compute how missing oxygen atoms change vanadium dioxide, a substance famous for switching between metal and insulator. Tests show oxygen vacancies suppress that transition, but the mechanism has lacked agreement. Using density functional theory with an added intersite coupling between vanadium atoms, the team treats the metallic rutile phase and the insulating monoclinic phase on equal footing.
Vacancies distort the monoclinic structure up close but, surprisingly, do not destroy the vanadium pairing usually credited with the insulating behavior. Even so, the monoclinic phase turns metallic, because the vacancies dope it, partly filling the conduction band in a rigid-band-like fashion. The result separates two rival explanations and credits simple electron counting, not structural collapse, for the lost switch.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Oskar Leibnitz, Peter Mlkvik, Nicola A. Spaldin, Claude Ederer |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-07284
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Oxygen vacancies in vanadium dioxide: A DFT+ V study Oskar Leibnitz, Peter Mlkvik, Nicola A. Spaldin, Claude Ederer Abstract We present a density-functional theory study of the effects of oxygen vacancies on the structural and electronic properties of vanadium dioxide (VO 2 ). Our motivation is the reported suppression of the metal-insulator transition by oxygen vacancies and the lack of a clear consensus on its origin. We use the DFT + V +V method with a static intersite vanadium-vanadium interaction term, V V , to calculate the properties of the oxygen-deficient metallic rutile and insulating monoclinic M1 phases of VO 2 on the same footing. We find that oxygen vacancies induce local distortions in the M1 phase, but do not destroy the dimerization usually associated with the insulating behavior. In spite of this, we find that the M1 phase becomes metallic as a result of the partial filling of the conduction band due to a rigid-band-like doping effect. I Introduction The metal-insulator transition (MIT) in vanadium dioxide (VO 2 ) has been proposed for a variety of applications, from memristive devices 69 ; 70 , ultra-fast electronics 68 ; 73 , to energy-efficient windows 63 ; 13 . In order to fully realize the application potential of VO 2 , the MIT temperature, T_{c} , as well as the transition hysteresis, and order of magnitude change in resistivity, should ideally be reliably tuneable. Besides epitaxial strain 9 ; 3 ; 1 ; 36 , and doping 60 ; 67 ; 30 ; 42 , oxygen vacancies (O V ’s), one of the most frequent point defects, have been studied extensively for their potential to mediate such tuning. In this work, we computationally investigate the effects of oxygen vacancies on the main VO 2 phases. The MIT in VO 2 is accompanied by a structural transition, from a high-temperature rutile (R) phase to a low-temperature monoclinic (M1) phase, at T_{c}=340 K 44 ; 14 . The transition involves V–V dimerization along the tetragonal c axis coupled to lateral displacements, causing a doubling of the unit cell, resembling a Peierls instability. In the R phase, 3d^{1} V 4+ ions situated in distorted VO 6 octahedra have partially filled a_{1g} and e_{g}^{\pi} states, resulting from a splitting of the t_{2g} manifold. In the dimerized M1 phase (Fig. 1 ), the a_{1g} band is further split into occupied bonding and unoccupied antibonding states 23 , while the e_{g}^{\pi} levels shift upward, resulting in a narrow insulating gap. Besides these Peierls effects, Mott-Hubbard correlation effects are needed for a full description of the physics of VO 2 52 ; 5 ; 74 ; 53 ; 31 ; 64 ; 19 ; 8 ; 46 , and a dual Peierls-Mott mechanism appears to provide the most appropriate description of the MIT in VO 2 6 ; 62 ; 24 ; 43 . Numerous studies consistently show that increasing oxygen vacancy concentration suppresses the insulating state of VO 2 . Oxygen vacancies lower the T_{c} even when strain effects are excluded 16 ; 15 ; 28 ; 4 ; 57 . Field-switching experiments reveal a corresponding decrease in the critical voltage 71 , and O V ’s can modify or even eliminate hysteresis 72 ; 35 . Isotope-labeled oxygen studies directly confirm that these effects arise from oxygen vacancies 28 . Quantifying the vacancy concentration remains difficult, with most studies offering only qualitative comparisons, such as different vacuum annealing times 11 . X-ray photoemission spectroscopy provides rare quantitative estimates, reporting \delta=0.07\,-\,0.20 66 ; 71 in VO 2-δ . Despite this phenomenological consensus, the literature diverges on the nature of the physics underlying the change in T_{c} , with two main interpretations emerging. First, several studies suggest that oxygen vacancies stabilize the R structure below the T_{c} of the stoichiometric phase. Xu et al. 66 observe a softening of Raman modes associated with the M1 phase and a lowering of the structural transition temperature in thin films of VO 1.92 . The proposed explanation is a weakening of the V–O hybridization and the V–V dimerization by the electrons donated by the vacancy. Kim et al. 29 similarly observe a reduction in the structural transition temperature, but attribute it to a weakening of the V–V dimers by oxygen-vacancy-induced compressive strain. Zhang et al. 71 report Raman mode softening at a temperature below T_{c} and link it to a stabilization of the R phase due to the dopant electrons. Matsuda et al. 38 show spectroscopic evidence of a confinement of the V–V pairing to nanodomains within an undimerized R-like VO 2 structure at room temperature, consistent with partial rutile phase stabilization due to oxygen deficiency. Guo et al. 25 report a decrease in T_{\text{c}} with Ar-plasma irradiation in VO 2 nanobeams and link it to oxygen vacancy induced stabilization of the R phase; however, no experimental phase characterization is performed. Passarello et al. 47 demonstrate that ionic liquid gating induces oxygen vacancy formation and stabilizes the R structure down to 270 K. The retention of R symmetry is confirmed spectroscopically and attributed to a combination of vacancy-driven lattice expansion and epitaxial clamping of the in-plane lattice constants by the TiO 2 substrate used. Figure 1: Crystal structure of the M1 phase in the M1 primitive cell (dashed line). Green and blue arrows indicate the short and long bonds (SB and LB, respectively) along the c direction. V (O) atoms shown in (light) gray. Inequivalent oxygen sites in the M1 structure (O {}_{\text{SB}} and O {}_{\text{LB}} ) are indicated in green and blue, respectively. The second interpretation common in literature is the emergence of a metallic M1 phase. This phase has been observed through pump-probe spectroscopy and reported in non-equilibrium studies on photoexcited VO 2 45 ; 65 . A variety of other studies support the stabilization of such a metallic M1 phase in oxygen deficient VO 2 . Li et al. 33 observe a vacancy-induced metallic M1 phase in VO 2 nanobeams and associate it with orbital-selective carrier doping. Schrecongost et al. 54 ; 55 ; 56 demonstrate reconfigurable nanoplasmonic devices based on metallic M1 phases patterned via oxygen vacancy or free carrier injection using atomic force microscopy, attributing the metallicity to the associated carrier injection. The monoclinic nature of the observed phase is confirmed using micro x-ray diffraction and electron diffraction. Vacuum annealing experiments reveal a metallic M1 phase, confirmed by hardening of Raman-active V–V modes, dimer stabilization, and robust room-temperature metallicity, and attribute it to changes in electronic correlations and a shortening of V–V bonds 11 . The effect of oxygen vacancies has also been studied using first-principles methods. Several DFT +U studies 16 ; 11 ; 34 ; 2 report a metallic M1 phase as the ground state of VO 2 , even at low vacancy concentrations, though their interpretations vary. Guo et al. 25 find partial filling of the conduction band in an oxygen deficient M1 structure and deduce a stabilization of the R phase from this result, although they do not explicitly calculate the non-stoichiometric R structures. Chen et al. 12 also only study the oxygen-deficient M1 phase, finding weaker V–V dimerization from which the authors infer a total de-dimerization into an R phase under