The Long Shadow of Superstars: Effects on Opportunities, Careers, and Team Production
Masaya Nishihata · 2025
Read The Long Shadow of Superstars: Effects on Opportunities, Careers, and Team Production by Masaya Nishihata (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-07218.txt.
Introduction
Masaya Nishihata studies a dilemma every organization faces: give scarce, valuable tasks to proven performers, or spread them to discover unknown talent? Temporary injuries to star Major League Baseball players create natural tests, suddenly reallocating playing time to teammates at the same position. Nishihata tracks allocation and performance before, during, and after these absences to separate learning effects from information effects.
Crowd-out is clear: when a star is out, same-position teammates receive greatly more opportunities. Yet the extra experience barely raises their batting productivity, during the absence or after, so learning by doing is not the main benefit. Instead, performance surprises during the window predict later employment and playing time, meaning teams use the revealed information in future decisions. Counterfactuals suggest that information can partly offset the short-run production loss.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Masaya Nishihata |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 49 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-07218
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Long Shadow of Superstars: Effects on Opportunities, Careers, and Team Production Thanks: I am grateful to Ryo Nakajima for his valuable comments and suggestions that greatly improved this paper. I thank Reio Tanji, a baseball analyst, for sharing his domain expertise and providing insightful feedback from a practitioner’s perspective. Comments from participants at the Kansai Labor Workshop (March 2025) were also helpful and are gratefully acknowledged. This work was supported by JST SPRING, Grant Number JPMJSP2123. Masaya Nishihata Abstract Superstars often dominate key tasks because of their exceptional abilities, but this concentration of responsibility may unintentionally limit on-the-job learning opportunities for others. Using panel data from Major League Baseball (MLB), this study examines how superstar presence affects teammates’ opportunities and career outcomes. To address potential endogeneity in team composition, we exploit plausibly exogenous variation in superstar availability caused by injuries. When a superstar is active in the same team-position unit, non-star teammates play significantly less. These short-term reductions in playing time extend to longer horizons: players who begin their careers alongside a superstar who remains active for a full season (i.e., not on the injured list) are about 1.7 times more likely to exit MLB earlier than comparable peers. A key mechanism is reduced skill development—limited playing opportunities hinder subsequent growth in offensive performance. At the team level, greater dependence on superstars raises immediate productivity but magnifies performance declines after their departure, indicating a trade-off between short-term success and long-term adaptability. Overall, the findings suggest that while concentrating key roles in top performers boosts output in the short run, it can restrict others’ development and retention. Similar dynamics may arise in other organizations that rely heavily on a few exceptional individuals. Keywords : superstar, human capital, long-term career JEL code : J24, J44, L83, M54 1 Introduction Even within the same workplace, worker productivity is rarely uniform. Such differences in individual ability can shape how tasks are allocated within organizations, as managers tend to assign more critical or visible tasks to higher-performing workers. This tendency may create disparities in learning opportunities and long-term career development among colleagues. 16 formalizes how differences in talent, combined with demand structures that reward quality over quantity, can generate “superstar” outcomes, as illustrated by markets for musicians, artists, and athletes. While these examples describe extreme cases in which technology amplifies small differences in talent, a similar—though less pronounced—concentration of responsibility likely arises in typical workplace environments as well. Understanding how such concentration affects coworkers’ opportunities for on-the-job learning and the dynamics of team production is crucial for thinking about the optimal allocation of tasks and talent within organizations. This study uses data from Major League Baseball (MLB) to examine how the presence of superstars affects the opportunities and long-term career outcomes of their non-star teammates. We first investigate whether sharing a team and position with a superstar reduces the playing opportunities, as measured by plate appearances, for their non-star teammates during a season. We then analyze longer-term effects by examining how exposure to superstars during a player’s MLB debut season influences their career length and the development of performance over time. Finally, we explore whether teams that heavily rely on superstars experience different trajectories of team productivity following their departure. Using MLB data to estimate the effects of superstars offers several advantages. First, the data provide detailed individual performance metrics over multiple seasons, making them well-suited for analyzing long-term impacts. Unlike typical workplace datasets, MLB records allow us to identify precisely who works with whom—linking each player to specific teammates and positions within a team—while tracking those same individuals throughout their professional careers. This structure enables precise measurement of both team composition and career trajectories. Second, identifying superstar effects requires addressing the endogeneity of team decisions, such as acquiring or releasing star players in response to their teammates’ performance. MLB’s institutional environment helps to mitigate this concern. In particular, the league operates a formal Injured List (IL) system, under which any player placed on the IL is prohibited from participating in games for a designated minimum period. These forced absences generate exogenous variation in teammates’ exposure to superstars, providing a natural experiment for identifying causal effects. This approach parallels 1 , who exploit the unexpected deaths of star scientists as exogenous shocks to estimate superstar effects. Finally, MLB data provide a transparent and objective definition of stardom based on All-Star game selections: as discussed in Section 3 , we define a superstar as a player who was selected for the All-Star game at least twice. This study contributes to three strands of literature. First, it adds to the research on superstar effects. 1 identify such effects among scientists, finding positive externalities through knowledge spillovers. 5 analyzes data from golf tournaments and shows that the presence of superstars reduces other players’ performance, interpreting the results through the lens of tournament incentives. However, these studies do not explore the mechanisms through which superstars might hinder their peers’ human capital accumulation. This study makes a novel contribution by focusing on this previously overlooked mechanism. A related study in management, 13 , shows that stars reduce non-stars’ learning. Yet their analysis relies on single-year survey data and is limited in addressing endogeneity. By examining long-term outcomes and leveraging exogenous variation from superstar injuries, this study offers new insights into how superstars affect human capital formation among colleagues. Second, this study contributes to the literature on peer effects in the workplace. While extensive research has examined peer effects, the evidence remains mixed. Positive peer effects have been documented in some contexts, such as among cashiers ( 14 ) , fruit pickers ( 2 ) , and swimmers ( 18 ) , whereas other studies find no evidence of such effects among professional golfers ( 9 ) or university scientists ( 17 ) . Moreover, heterogeneous peer effects have been observed depending on factors such as gender ( 4 ) , the nature of tasks, and the presence of monetary incentives ( 15 ) . However, most existing studies focus on short-term peer influences—how individuals adjust their immediate effort or performance in response to high-performing colleagues—while relatively little is known about their lasting implications for career outcomes. In contrast, this study investigates the long-term consequences of peer exposure, specifically how playing alongside a superstar shapes career trajectories over time. By analyzing long-term superstar effects in a highly professionalized labor market such as MLB, this study provides a new perspective on how peer influences affect career development rather than merely contemporaneous productivity. A recent insightful and closely related study by 7 uses National Basketball Association (NBA) data to show that rookies who join stronger teams tend to receive less playing time and exhibit lower performance. However, their analysis interprets playing time primarily as a matter of visibility and relies on a static framework. In contrast, this study adopts a dynamic perspective, focusing on how the concentration of key tasks in superstars may limit on-the-job training opportunities and hinder the human capital accumulation of non-star teammates. In this sense, our work complements theirs by highlighting a distinct mechanism through which superstars can affect their peers’ long-term development. Moreover, while 7 focus on the individual-level consequences for rookies, we extend the analysis to