Rethinking mass transfer: a unified semi-analytical framework for circular and eccentric binaries
A. Parkosidis, S. Toonen, E. Laplace, F. Dosopoulou · 2025
Read Rethinking mass transfer: a unified semi-analytical framework for circular and eccentric binaries by A. Parkosidis, S. Toonen, E. Laplace, F. Dosopoulou (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-07190.txt.
Introduction
A Parkosidis, S Toonen, E Laplace, and F Dosopoulou extend the theory of mass transfer in binary stars to eccentric orbits. Most studies assume circular binaries, but observations show mass transfer also happens on elliptical paths, especially in systems with compact objects. Part two of their series examines how nonconservative transfer, where some mass and angular momentum leave the system, reshapes such orbits under four angular momentum loss modes.
The modes behave distinctly: Jeans loss generally widens orbits and pumps eccentricity, loss through the outer Lagrange point shrinks and circularizes, and the other two sit between. Eccentric transfer can produce compact binaries that merge by gravitational waves within a Hubble time where circular modeling predicts merger during transfer instead. The system may also explain circumbinary disks seen around eccentric evolved binaries.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | A. Parkosidis, S. Toonen, E. Laplace, F. Dosopoulou |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 68 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-07190
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Rethinking mass transfer: a unified semi-analytical framework for circular and eccentric binaries A. Parkosidis, S. Toonen, E. Laplace, F. Dosopoulou Abstract Although mass transfer (MT) has been studied primarily in circular binaries, observations show that it also occurs in eccentric systems. We investigate orbital evolution during non-conservative MT in eccentric orbits, a process especially relevant for binaries containing compact objects (COs). We examine four angular momentum loss (AML) modes; Jeans, isotropic re-emission, orbital-AML and L 2 L_{2} mass loss – the latter is the most efficient AML mode. For fixed AML mode and accretion efficiency, orbital evolution is correlated: orbits either widen while becoming more eccentric, or shrink while circularizing. Jeans mode generally yields orbital widening and eccentricity pumping, whereas L 2 L_{2} mass loss typically leads to orbital shrinkage and eccentricity damping. Isotropic re-emission and orbital-AML show intermediate behavior. Adopting isotropic re-emission, we demonstrate that eccentric MT produces compact binaries that merge via gravitational waves (GW) within a Hubble time, whereas the same systems would instead merge during MT under traditional modeling. We further show that, in eccentric orbits, the gravitational potential at L 2 L_{2} becomes lower than at L 1 L_{1} across large range of mass ratios and eccentricities, naturally linking eccentricity to L 2 L_{2} mass loss. Since interacting binaries containing COs are frequently eccentric, L 2 L_{2} mass loss offers a new robust pathway to orbital tightening during eccentric MT, contributing to the formation rate of GW sources. This model can treat orbital evolution due to conservative and non-conservative MT in arbitrary eccentricities with applications ranging from MT on the main sequence to GW progenitors. II. Orbital evolution due to non-conservative mass transfer 1 Introduction The orbital evolution of binary systems is shaped by various physical processes. Among these mechanisms, RLOF has long been understood as a key process that determines the evolution and final fate of mass transferring binaries. Numerical models traditionally neglect orbital eccentricity during RLOF, assuming circular orbits or that tidal forces universally circularize orbits before the onset of RLOF ( 51 ; 22 ; 50 ; 3 ; 64 , e.g.,) . However, both observations of interacting binaries with non-zero eccentricities ( 48 ; 56 ) and theoretical studies predicting weak tides ( 11 ; 53 , e.g.,) challenge this assumption. Moreover, in recent years, a new picture has emerged in which eccentricity is a common feature of post-interaction wide binaries ( 37 ; 15 ; 24 ; 25 ; 23 ; 69 ; 39 ; 72 ; 61 ; 26 ; 40 ) suggesting that RLOF may not only preserve but in some cases even enhance eccentricities ( 58 ; 59 ; 42 ) . Despite growing interest in the role of eccentric MT in both analytical ( 16 ) and numerical studies ( 57 ) , large-scale population studies still face major challenges. Existing analytical prescriptions for the secular evolution of mass-transferring systems are either restricted to extremely high eccentricities ( 58 ; 59 , hereafter referred to as the ‘ \delta -function’ model) or limited to conservative MT ( 16 , hereafter referred to as the ‘emt’ model) . It is not trivial to overcome these limitations when performing binary evolution simulations for many stars. For instance, 57 switch from the \delta -function to the classical RLOF model when the eccentricity e\leq 0.05 , while 17 presents an ad hoc extension of the emt model to the non-conservative regime 1 1 1 The model accounts for mass loss, but not for angular momentum loss. . These inconsistencies highlight the need for a unified framework that can treat both conservative and non-conservative MT across arbitrary eccentricities; an essential requirement for realistic large-scale binary evolution simulations. In 42 , hereafter Paper I, we developed a unified semi-analytic framework for the orbital evolution of mass-transferring binaries. In that work, we treated mass loss, AML, and mass exchange as perturbations to the general two-body problem. We demonstrated that in the case of MT via RLOF, additional perturbations arise due to the anisotropic mass ejection from the donor and accretion onto the companion, and thus treating the binary components as extended bodies rather than point masses is a more accurate approach. For the position of the ejection point, we introduced the Global- L_{1} fit; the most accurate prescription to date for the position of the L_{1} Lagrangian point as function of systemic parameters. Additionally, we adopted the phase-dependent mass transfer prescription developed by 16 and we derived secular evolution equations for the orbital elements in the adiabatic regime. Finally, we implemented these orbit-averaged equations into the General Mass Transfer ( GeMT ) code, and applied it to isolated binaries assuming conservative MT (see Paper I for more detail). Here, we focus on specific scenarios of non-conservative MT. Non-conservative MT, is a process especially relevant for systems containing COs accretors ( 36 ; 73 , e.g.,) . For COs, accretion is typically limited by radiation pressure in the accretion flow, resulting in very low accretion rates (i.e., Eddington-limited accretion). Additionally, observations confirm that binaries with both CO accretors can retain significant eccentricities ( 56 ; 13 ; 61 ; 10 , e.g.,) . Therefore, modeling orbital evolution under non-conservative MT in eccentric systems is essential for explaining eccentric post-MT binaries, as well as CO mergers detected by LIGO–Virgo–KAGRA ( 1 , e.g.,) and future GW sources accessible to LISA ( 29 , e.g.,) . We consider an eccentric binary with component masses M_{\rm don} (donor) and M_{\rm acc} (accretor), defining the mass ratio q=M_{\rm don}/M_{\rm acc} . The orbit has a semimajor axis a , an eccentricity e and period a P_{\rm orb} . We assume that both stars rotate uniformly at spin angular velocities \mathbf{\Omega}_{\rm don} and \mathbf{\Omega}_{\rm acc} aligned with each other and with the orbital angular velocity \mathbf{\Omega}_{\rm orb} . In our semi-detached configuration, the donor loses mass at a rate \dot{M}_{\rm don}<0 via RLOF, and the accretor gains mass at a rate \dot{M}_{\rm acc} . In the non-conservative regime, a fraction \beta of the transferred mass is accreted, while the rest escapes the system so that the net mass loss rate is \dot{M}=(1-\beta)\dot{M}_{\rm don} . We further parametrize the specific AM carried away by the ejected matter as \gamma (hereafter referred to as the ‘AML-parameter’) times the specific AM of the binary J_{\rm orb}/M , such as \frac{\dot{J}_{\rm orb,ml}}{J_{\rm orb}}\equiv\gamma\frac{\dot{M}}{M}=\gamma(1-\beta)\frac{\dot{M}_{\rm don}}{M_{\rm don}+M_{\rm acc}}. (1) The AML-parameter is a measure of the efficiency of AM extraction during non-conservative MT. During RLOF, the donor star transfers mass to its companion, the accretor, through the inner Lagrangian point L_{1} . The position of the L_{1} point, relative to the donor’s center of mass, is given by the Global- L_{1} fit X_{\rm L1}(f_{\rm don},q,e) (see Appendix B in Paper I ), where f_{\rm don} represents the donor’s spin angular velocity \Omega_{\rm don} normalized to the orbital angular velocity at periapsis, f_{\rm don}\equiv\frac{\Omega_{\rm don}}{n}\frac{(1-e)^{3/2}}{(1+e)^{1/2}}, (2) and n=2\pi/P_{\rm orb} . Similarly, the accretor gains mass from the position r_{\rm acc} relative to its center of mass. This position can be a point on the accretor’s surface or the outer edge of the accretion disk. In Paper I we made the two simplifying assumptions below, which we