The Use of O 2 in Gas Mixtures for Drift Chambers
C. Voena · 2025
Read The Use of O 2 in Gas Mixtures for Drift Chambers by C. Voena (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-07082.txt.
Introduction
A twenty-three-author team from the MEG II experiment reports that oxygen, long considered poison for drift chambers, is in fact essential to theirs. Oxygen is strongly electronegative, so even traces were believed to capture drifting electrons and kill the detector. Yet the MEG II drift chamber at PSI has run for years on a helium-isobutane mixture. That mixture deliberately includes a small amount of isopropanol and half a percent of oxygen by molar concentration.
Measurements show electron capture in this mixture is negligible for proper operation. The results also agree well with Garfield++ simulations once three-body capture is correctly accounted for. The paper documents how a supposedly forbidden ingredient sustains a working precision detector, a useful counterexample for designers of future drift chambers.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | C. Voena |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-07082
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Use of O 2 in Gas Mixtures for Drift Chambers C. Voena Abstract The use of Oxygen in gas mixtures for drift chambers is highly discouraged because Oxygen, being strongly electronegative, is generally believed to lead, even in very small quantities, to extremely reduced drift electron attachment values, thus preventing the detector’s operation. The drift chamber of the MEG II experiment at PSI has been operating for several years with a gas mixture that mainly contains He:Isobutane in relative proportions of 90:10 % by molar concentration, in addition to 1.5% Isopropanol and 0.5% Oxygen. Oxygen and Isopropanol are essential for the proper functioning of the chamber. The electron attachment in the mixture used has proven negligible for the proper operation of the chamber and agrees well with the Garfield++ simulation after correctly accounting for the three-body attachment simulation. However, it is important to note that, in the case of ternary or quaternary mixtures (as in the case of MEG II), it is not possible to provide Garfield++ with just the ingredients of the mixture used to obtain correct attachment values. Instead, the code needs to be properly modified and recompiled. 1 Introduction Since their introduction in the early 1970s, drift chambers played a leading role in tracking applications for both collider and fixed-target experiments. With the advent of solid state strip and pixel detectors, the use of such detectors in very high energy and high radiation environments declined. However, drift chambers are still the technology of choice at lower energies, where the tracking resolutions are limited by the multiple Coulomb scattering in the detector material. Despite the introduction of very thin silicon pixel detectors like HV-MAPS, the extremely low material budget of gaseous chambers still makes their performance unmatched. Moreover, their relatively low cost makes them advantageous when large volumes need to be covered. For these reasons, in the last decades drift chambers have been chosen for central tracking in the \phi -Factory and B-Factory experiments (KLOE [ 1 ] , BaBar [ 2 ] , Belle [ 3 ] and Belle-II [ 4 ] , BES-III [ 5 ] ) and in several low-energy applications like some muon decay experiments (TWIST [ 6 ] , MEG [ 7 ] and MEG II [ 8 ] , COMET [ 9 ] ). The MEG II cylindrical drift chamber, in particular, marked a significant evolution in the construction technology of these detectors, allowing large volumes to be instrumented with high granularity, and paved the way for their use at future e^{+}e^{-} colliders like FCC-ee, as proposed for the IDEA detector [ 10 ] . When having a low material budget is critical, drift chambers are filled with extremely light, helium-based gas mixtures. A very common choice is He:Isobutane in relative proportions of 90:10 % by molar concentration, which is proved to provide good stability at high gain (exceeding 2\text{\times}{10}^{5}\text{\,} in the MEG II drift chamber). However, when exposed to high irradiation, chambers operated with this mixture tend to develop electron field emission from the electrodes, where polymers originating from Isobutane can deposit and form a thin insulating layer (Malter effect). It results in anomalously large currents and possibly electrical breakdowns. It was observed anyway that the addition of low concentrations of water or isopropyl alcohol vapors can restore the correct operation of the detector. In the case of the MEG II Drift Chamber, deposits were observed in large portions of wires after large discharges happened during the commissioning of the detector. After testing several additives, a normal operation could be restored with the addition of isopropyl alcohol and a significant concentration of Oxygen, which is usually regarded as an unwanted contaminant because of the tendency of drifting electrons to attach to it, resulting in a suppression of the induced signals. In this paper we present experimental and simulation studies of the impact of Oxygen concentrations at a few permille level on some electron drift properties of the He:Isobutane 90:10 mixture. Our results support the semi-quantitative observation made in MEG II that similar concentrations of Oxygen can be used in drift chambers with small enough cells without compromising the overall performance of the detector. They will serve as a basis for the development of strategies to stabilize the operation of present and upcoming drift chambers, and could be critical in particular for the successful deployment of the drift chamber of the IDEA detector at FCC-ee. 2 The MEG II Drift Chamber and Its Operation 2.1 The MEG II Drift Chamber Figure 1 : The internal structures of the MEG II drift chamber The drift chamber of the MEG II experiment (described in more detail in the detector article [ 8 ] and the chamber performance article [ 11 ] ), shown in Fig. 1 , allows the reconstruction of positron tracks with a momentum of about 50 MeV/c in a non-uniform cylindrical magnetic field with a central intensity of 1.27 T, decreasing along the central axis of the chamber. It is a unique volume detector, consisting of a 1.93 m long and 35 cm external diameter cylinder filled with a gas mixture of Helium:Isobutane (C 4 H 10 ) 90:10, with small percentages of Isopropyl Alcohol ( 1.5\text{\,}\mathrm{\%} ) and Oxygen ( 0.5\text{\,}\mathrm{\%} ) added to stabilize the chamber’s performance, as we will see shortly. The volume is equipped with nine concentric layers of 192 gold-plated tungsten sense wires each, totaling 1728 wires, arranged in a stereo configuration with two views and approximately 10,000 silver-plated aluminum cathode and guard wires. The sense wires (20 micron diameter) collect the signals from the drift electrons, while the cathode and guard wires (40 and 50 micron diameter) form nearly squared drift cells and define the electric field within and at the boundaries of the sensitive volume; the cell dimensions range from 5.8 mm to 7.5 mm at the center and from 6.7 mm to 8.7 mm at the end-plates. The High Voltage (HV) operating point was set in the range of 1400-1480 V, with the outermost layer at the highest voltage, to achieve a gas gain of approximately 2.5\times 10^{5} . The HV can be set for groups of eight cells in 10 V steps which enables to account for differences in cell size due to their radial position within the chamber. Approximately 4\times 10^{7} positive muons per second are typically stopped in a target at the chamber’s center, exposing it to an intense flux of positrons produced by muon decay into a positron and two neutrinos. The normal current level observed for the eight consecutive anode wires (one "sector") powered by a single HV channel is around 10–20 \mu A . During initial operations with the pure He:Isobutane (90:10) mixture, an abrupt increase in current up to 400 \mu A was observed for some HV channels. A deep investigation revealed the formation of corona-like discharges along some wires. Several additives to the gas mixture were tested to restore normal detector operation. The reduction in high currents was achieved with an Oxygen level up to 2\text{\,}\mathrm{\%} , then gradually lowered to minimize electron attachment effects. Figure 2 : Currents in one sector of the drift chamber when reducing Oxygen content from 2~\%\rightarrow 1~\%\rightarrow 0.5~\%\rightarrow