Analysis and Implications of the Spatio-Spectral Morphology of the Fermi Bubbles

Ami Tank, Roland Crocker, Mark R. Krumholz · 2025

Read Analysis and Implications of the Spatio-Spectral Morphology of the Fermi Bubbles by Ami Tank, Roland Crocker, Mark R. Krumholz (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-07066.txt.

Introduction

Ami Tank, Roland Crocker, and Mark R Krumholz analyze the Fermi Bubbles, two gamma-ray lobes rising fifty degrees above and below the Milky Way's center, whose origin remains unknown. Using a template-free reconstruction of ten years of all-sky Fermi data, they extract the gamma-ray spectrum pixel by pixel across the bubbles. From each local spectrum they infer what parent population of cosmic-ray protons or electrons would be required to produce it.

Both hadronic and leptonic models fit the data equally well. The particle spectra must be broken power laws or exponentially cut off, with nearly constant break energies and indices that harden toward the southern tip. The leptonic option additionally requires electron energy density growing away from the Galactic plane and toward the edges. That disfavors cases where electrons are accelerated at the center and simply carried outward.

Catalog record

CREATORAmi Tank, Roland Crocker, Mark R. Krumholz
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-07066

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Analysis and Implications of the Spatio-Spectral Morphology of the Fermi Bubbles Ami Tank, Roland Crocker, Mark R. Krumholz Abstract The Fermi Bubbles are γ \gamma -ray structures extending from the center of the Milky Way to ± 50 ∘ \pm 50^{\circ} Galactic latitude that were discovered in data obtained by the Fermi /LAT instrument. Their origin and power source remain uncertain. To help address this uncertainty, here we use a template-free reconstruction of ten years of all-sky Fermi /LAT data provided by [ 27 ] to carry out a pixel-by-pixel spectral analysis of the Bubbles. We recover the position-dependent spectral shape and normalization that would be required for parent proton or electron cosmic ray populations to produce the Bubbles’ observed γ \gamma -ray spectra. We find that models in which the γ \gamma -ray emission is driven by either hadronic or leptonic processes can explain the data equally well. The cosmic ray population driving the emission must have either broken power-law or exponentially cut-off spectra, with break or cutoff energies that are almost constant with latitude but spectral indices below the break that harden towards the Bubbles’ southern tip. For the leptonic channel, reproducing the observed position-dependent γ \gamma -ray spectrum also requires a cosmic ray electron energy density that grows with distance from the Galactic plane and increases towards the edges of the Bubbles. This finding disfavors scenarios for the origin of the Bubbles where a population of cosmic ray electrons is accelerated near the Milky Way center and subsequently advected out to the extremities of the Bubbles. keywords Galactic center (565), Galactic cosmic rays (567), Gamma-ray sources (633), High-energy cosmic radiation (731) 1 Introduction Observations of the Milky Way halo by the Large Area Telescope (LAT) onboard the Fermi Gamma-ray Space telescope revealed two giant bubble-shaped structures extending \sim 50 ∘ above and below the Galactic plane. These structures were called the Fermi Bubbles (FBs) by their discoverers ( 33 ) . The origin of the FBs is still an open question. Their morphology suggests that they originate from the Galactic Center (GC), and their sky location and morphology suggest they are plausibly the gamma-ray counterparts to the “microwave haze” first discovered ( 13 ) in data from the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe ( 12 ; 26 , WMAP; also see) . Since the discovery of the FBs, structures coincident with or clearly morphologically related to them have also been detected at other wavelengths. The eROSITA telescope revealed two X-ray structures, now known as the eROSITA bubbles, extending up to 14 kpc above and below the Galactic plane ( 29 ) ; these encircle the FBs in projection and subsume previously-detected X-ray structures including the North Polar Spur (NPS) discovered by ROSAT ( 32 ) and the X- or hourglass-shaped structure detected near the GC ( 3 ) that is coincident with the edge of the FBs. In 2.3 GHz radio emission, 6 detected two giant, linearly polarized lobes coincident with the FBs at low latitudes, but extending to greater heights ( \sim 60^{\circ} ). There are also observations of both warm ionized ( 5 , e.g.,) , cool atomic ( 25 , e.g.,) , and cold molecular ( 11 ; 7 , e.g.,) material in or around the edges of the FBs, which may represent cool interstellar medium (ISM) that has been swept up by the same mechanisms responsible for producing the FBs. 30 provides a detailed review of the multi-wavelength observations near the FBs. Despite the large volume of observations available, numerous basic questions about the FBs remain open. What microphysical mechanism generates the Bubbles’ \gamma -ray emission? What activity provides the energy to inflate them in the first place? Relatedly, how old are the Bubbles? Where and how are the cosmic ray (CR) parents of the \gamma -rays accelerated? A successful model, along with answering these questions, should also be consistent with the full set of multi-wavelength observations. The question of mechanism arises because astrophysical production of \gamma -rays occurs via two primary channels: (a) the hadronic (p-p or proton) channel 1 1 1 In principle, this channel also encompasses heavier nuclei in either or both of the target and beam particles; in the absence of strong constraint on the abundance distribution for either of these, we ignore this complication. For Solar metallicity, the presence of heavy nuclei implies a \mathcal{O} (50%) upwards correction ( 21 ) to the efficiency of \gamma -ray production compared to a gas of pure hydrogen, which is small in comparison to other uncertainties, in particular, the target gas number density. and (b) the leptonic (electron) channel. In the former, cosmic-ray protons (CRp) collide inelastically with ambient, thermal protons and produce neutral pions, which each further decay into two \gamma -ray photons. In the latter, \gamma -ray photons are produced via inverse Compton (IC) up-scattering 2 2 2 Leptonic \gamma -ray emission due to bremsstrahlung is also important in some astrophysical environments, but is not competitive with IC for the ISRF and gas number conditions pertaining close to the FBs. of the interstellar radiation field (ISRF) – including the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) – by cosmic-ray electrons (CRe). An appealing aspect of the leptonic channel is that synchrotron radiation by the same population of electrons could also generate the microwave haze emission ( 33 ) . However, this is only suggestive, and we cannot at this point rule out the possibility that the \gamma -ray and microwave emission trace different underlying particle populations ( 10 , e.g.,) . The question of mechanism is tightly tied to the question of the FBs’ ultimate energy source. Models for this fall into two broad categories: those invoking AGN-like activity of the Milky Way’s central super-massive black hole, and those that posit that the FBs are powered by supernovae produced by bursts of star formation near the GC. The link between these scenarios and the emission mechanism is via cooling times. CRe would cool in at most a few Myr due to IC and synchrotron emission (which are comparably important given the \sim 10 \mu G magnetic field found even at relatively high latitudes within the FBs – 6 ), so if FB emission is driven by CRe accelerated near the GC, those CRe must be transported outward at \gg 1000 km s -1 to reach the FB edge before cooling. This is well above the typical speeds of supernova-driven winds ( 34 , e.g.,) , so in this scenario the CRe must either originate from a relativistic jet from the central black hole that was active in the last few Myr ( 15 , e.g.,) , or there must be some mechanism within the bubbles capable of re-accelerating a cooled electron population ( 20 ; 19 , e.g.,) . By contrast, the cooling times for protons are much longer ( \sim Gyr for ambient gas densities \sim 10^{-2} cm -3 ), easing the timescale constraint but conversely requiring a much larger CR energy density within the bubble to power the observed emission. This favors a scenario where the CRp population within the FBs is gradually built-up by the cumulative effects of supernova injection over \gg Myr timescales ( 8 ; 9 ; 10

Read the complete text