Identifying the physical periods in the radio emission from the γ \gamma -ray emitting binary LS I +61 303

F. Jaron, V. Bosch-Ramon · 2025

Read Identifying the physical periods in the radio emission from the γ \gamma -ray emitting binary LS I +61 303 by F. Jaron, V. Bosch-Ramon (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-07056.txt.

Introduction

Frédéric Jaron and Valentí Bosch-Ramon disentangle the clockwork of LS I +61 303, a gamma-ray binary pulsing from radio to very high energies. Its light curves show periods near twenty-six point five days and twenty-six point nine days, plus a long cycle of four point six years. A signal near twenty-six point seven days appears occasionally, and all are interrelated by beating, so astronomers debate which are physical and which are interference artifacts. A fifth period near twenty-six point three days was recently claimed.

Staying purely phenomenological, the authors ran generalized Lomb-Scargle analyses on archival radio data and compared them with synthetic curves containing selected signals. Only synthetic data including all three periods together reproduced the observations, down to the noise level. All three, they conclude, could correspond to real physical processes.

Catalog record

CREATORF. Jaron, V. Bosch-Ramon
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE57 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-07056

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Identifying the physical periods in the radio emission from the γ \gamma -ray emitting binary LS I +61 303 F. Jaron, V. Bosch-Ramon Abstract Context. The γ \gamma -ray emitting binary system LS I +61 303 exhibits periodic emission across the electromagnetic spectrum, extending from radio frequencies up to the very-high-energy regime. The most prominent features are three periods with values P 1 = 26.5 P_{1}=26.5 d, P 2 = 26.9 P_{2}=26.9 d, and P long = 4.6 P_{\rm long}=4.6 years. Occasionally, a fourth period of 26.7 d is also detected. Mathematically, these four periods are interrelated via the interference pattern of a beating. Competing scenarios that seek to determine which of these periods are physical and which are secondary are under debate. In addition, the detection of a fifth period, P 3 = 26.3 P_{3}=26.3 d, was recently claimed. Aims. Our aim is to determine which of these periods are intrinsic (i.e., whether they are likely to be related to physical processes) and which of these are secondary (i.e., resulting from interference). We chose to avoid any assumption concerning the physical scenario and restricted our analysis to the phenomenology of the radio emission variability. Methods. We selected intervals from archival radio data and applied the generalized Lomb-Scargle periodogram. We fit the observational data to generate synthetic datasets that only contain specific signals in the form of pure sine waves. We analyzed these synthetic data to assess the impact of these signals and their interference on the light curves and the periodogram. Results. The two-peaked profile, consisting of P 1 P_{1} and P 2 P_{2} , was detected in the periodogram of the actual data for intervals that are significantly shorter than P long P_{\rm long} , provided that these intervals contain the minimum of the long-term modulation. The characteristics of the observational data and their periodogram could only be reproduced with synthetic data if these explicitly included all of the three periods, P 1 P_{1} , P 2 P_{2} , and P long P_{\rm long} , with the residuals being limited by noise. Conclusions. We have found, for the first time, that all three periods, P 1 P_{1} , P 2 P_{2} , and P long P_{\rm long} , could, in fact, correspond to physically real processes occurring in LS I +61 303. This should be considered when modeling the physical processes in this binary system. 1 Introduction The system LS I +61 303 is unique among the class of \gamma -ray emitting binaries ( 7 ; 3 ) because its emission across the electromagnetic spectrum, from the radio up to the very-high-energy regime, is characterized by the presence of several periodic signals. Timing analyses have thus far resulted in the firm detection of four period values. The first period, P_{1} , has been identified with the orbital period of the binary system at P_{1}=26.5 d ( 39 ; 10 ) . Timing analyses of optical polarization data, presented by 20 , indeed corroborates that P_{1} is the orbital period. The second period is P_{2}=26.9 d ( 24 ; 45 ; 13 ) . Competing physical scenarios are being discussed ( 5 ; 13 , and references therein) , but we have decided not to presuppose any specific physical process with P_{2} and, consequently, we refer to this period as quasi-orbital throughout this article. A long-term period was detected with a value of P_{\rm long}=4.6 years (first suggested by 32 , then confirmed by 9 ; 30 ; 10 ; 29 ; 13 ); this period is also referred to as the super-orbital period of the system. The long-term period manifests itself as a modulation of the peak flux densities of radio outbursts, which occur periodically once per orbit, and in a saw-tooth-like modulation of their orbital phase occurrence ( 10 ) . As with P_{2} , we mostly discuss P_{\rm long} from a phenomenological point of view and we do not presuppose any specific physical origin to it. The fourth period reported for this source is P_{\rm average}=26.7 d ( 34 ) , which we call “average” because its value is coincident with the arithmetic average of P_{1} and P_{2} . As pointed out by 14 , this is the period with which the radio outbursts actually occur, performing a 0.5 phase jump during each minimum of the super-orbital modulation. It was first pointed out by 24 that all of these four periods ( P_{1} , P_{2} , P_{\rm long} , and P_{\rm average} ) are interconnected with each other via the mathematical concept of a beating. In this scenario, at least two of the four periods are intrinsic (i.e., physical) periods, being related to physical processes at work in the source, while other periods may be the result of their interference. All of these periodic signals have remained remarkably stable over the observational history of the source. In particular, the long-term modulation has by now completed ten cycles since the beginning of radio observations of LS I +61 303 ( 13 ) . The presence of these periods has been confirmed for the emission at other wavelengths as well. 31 found evidence of periodicity in X-rays with a period of 26.7 d. 1 first suggested that the X-ray emission from LS I +61 303 is subject to the long-term modulation, which was later confirmed by 21 , and 8 reported the presence of P_{1} and P_{2} . Concerning the giga-electron volt (GeV) \gamma -rays, as observed by the Fermi -LAT, 11 detected the long-term modulation and 15 detected P_{1} and P_{2} (later confirmed by 5 ). A fifth period, P_{3} , has recently been reported by 47 to be present in GeV emission. This author performed timing-analysis of Fermi -LAT aperture photometry data and detected, along with the above mentioned P_{1} and P_{2} , a third period in that range with a value of P_{3}=26.3 d. The presence of such a period could, however, so far not be independently confirmed. In their reference to Fig. 3 (d) of 18 , 47 put importance to a feature in the periodogram of radio data that was not identified as significant by the authors. A detailed analysis of an updated dataset by 13 did also not result in the detection of any significant feature at a period compatible with P_{3} . Concerning the GeV emission itself, 5 presented a periodogram of the energy range 0.1-0.3 GeV, where, according to 47 , P_{3} should best be detected (black curve in their Fig. 5); however, such a feature is completely absent there (see blue curve in Fig. 2 of 5 ). In the analysis of radio data we carried out in this work, we revisited the issue of the possible presence of such a feature and payed attention if a period compatible with P_{3} was significantly detected or not. The debate surrounding the actual nature of the different periods detected in LS I +61 303, some of which might be the result of a beating between two of the intrinsic (i.e., physical) periods, must be resolved before a robust conclusion can be reached regarding the intrinsic physical processes behind those periods. Thus, the objective of the analysis presented here is to investigate

Read the complete text