Report on first plasma processing trial for a FRIB quarter-wave resonator cryomodule

Walter Hartung, Wei Chang, Yoo-Lim Cheon, Kyle Elliott, Sang-Hoon Kim, Taro Konomi, Patrick Tutt, Yuting Wu, Ting Xu · 2025

Read Report on first plasma processing trial for a FRIB quarter-wave resonator cryomodule by Walter Hartung, Wei Chang, Yoo-Lim Cheon, Kyle Elliott, Sang-Hoon Kim, Taro Konomi, Patrick Tutt, Yuting Wu, Ting Xu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-06732.txt.

Introduction

Walter Hartung and colleagues report the first plasma processing trial inside a working accelerator module at the Facility for Rare Isotope Beams. Plasma cleaning can restore superconducting cavity performance in place, sparing the huge job of removing a cryomodule for refurbishment. The facility runs hundreds of quarter-wave and half-wave resonators that could benefit.

Earlier tests drove plasma through the fundamental power coupler with promising results, and driving with a higher-order mode promised denser plasma with less mismatch. The January 2024 trial treated quarter-wave resonators inside their cryomodule. Cold tests afterward showed a significant drop in field emission X-rays, the signature the team hoped cleaning would produce.

Catalog record

CREATORWalter Hartung, Wei Chang, Yoo-Lim Cheon, Kyle Elliott, Sang-Hoon Kim, Taro Konomi, Patrick Tutt, Yuting Wu, Ting Xu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-06732

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Report on first plasma processing trial for a FRIB quarter-wave resonator cryomodule Walter Hartung, Wei Chang, Yoo-Lim Cheon, Kyle Elliott, Sang-Hoon Kim, Taro Konomi, Patrick Tutt, Yuting Wu, Ting Xu Abstract Plasma processing has been shown to help mitigate degradation of the performance of superconducting radio-frequency cavities, providing an alternative to removal of cryomodules from the accelerator for refurbishment. Studies of plasma processing for quarter-wave resonators (QWRs) and half-wave resonators (HWRs) are underway at the Facility for Rare Isotope Beams (FRIB), where a total of 324 such resonators are presently in operation. Plasma processing tests were done on several QWRs using the fundamental power coupler (FPC) to drive the plasma, with promising results. Driving the plasma with a higher-order mode allows for less mismatch at the FPC and higher plasma density. The first plasma processing trial for FRIB QWRs in a cryomodule was conducted in January 2024. Cold tests of the cryomodule showed a significant reduction in field emission X-rays after plasma processing. I Introduction Superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) cavities provide high accelerating gradients with low power dissipation for modern particle accelerators, but they cannot always operate in the best possible environment and do not always reach the best possible performance. Plasma processing has been developed and widely adopted by the electronics industry for modification of surfaces Lieberman and Lichtenberg 2005 . Plasma processing has been applied to SRF cavities in recent years, with the goal of improving SRF cavity performance or reversing performance degradation. In-situ plasma processing provides an alternative to time-intensive and labor-intensive removal and disassembly of cryomodules for refurbishment of each cavity via repeat chemical etching and rinsing. Pioneering work at the Spallation Neutron Source (SNS) showed that plasma processing can be beneficial for an SRF accelerator Doleans et al. 2016 ; Kim et al. 2017 . SRF-cavity plasma processing studies are now underway at several other facilities Berrutti 2018 ; Tyagi et al. 2018 ; Wu et al. 2016 ; Wu et al. 2018 ; Huang et al. 2019 ; Giaccone et al. 2019 ; Giaccone et al. 2021 ; Giaccone et al. 2022 ; McIntyre et al. 2023 ; Berrutti 2023 ; Cheney 2023 ; Powers et al. 2024a ; Powers et al. 2024b ; Hedji et al. 2024 ; Zhu et al. 2024 . Notable recent results include in-cryomodule plasma processing for LCLS-II Giaccone et al. 2022 and in-tunnel plasma processing work at CEBAF Powers et al. 2024a ; Powers et al. 2024b , both further demonstrating performance improvement with plasma processing. In addition to the work on multi-cell elliptical SRF cavities for SNS, CEBAF, LCLS-II Giaccone et al. 2019 ; Giaccone et al. 2021 ; Giaccone et al. 2022 , and on ILC-type cavities Tyagi et al. 2018 ; Hedji et al. 2024 ; Zhu et al. 2024 , plasma processing is being studied for quarter-wave resonators (QWRs) at IJCLab Cheney 2023 , half-wave resonators (HWRs) at IMP Wu et al. 2016 ; Wu et al. 2018 ; Huang et al. 2019 and Argonne McIntyre et al. 2023 , and spoke resonators at Fermilab Berrutti 2018 ; Berrutti 2023 . The Facility for Rare Isotope Beams (FRIB) is an SRF linac which accelerates ions to \geq 200 MeV per nucleon; user operations began in May 2022 Wei et al. 2022 . The beam power ramp-up from 1 kW for initial user experiments to the ultimate performance goal of 400 kW is ongoing Wei et al. 2024 . As the linac contains 104 QWRs (80.5 MHz) and 220 HWRs (322 MHz) Zhang et al. 2021 , the risk of cavity performance degradation due to contamination is a concern for long-term operation. This concern let us to initiate a plasma processing development effort for FRIB cavities in 2020. This paper summarizes the QWR development efforts and presents the first results of off-line plasma processing of a spare FRIB QWR cryomodule, with before-and-after cold tests of the cryomodule to assess the impact of plasma processing on cryomodule performance. II FRIB cavities and cryomodules FRIB production cavities were fabricated from sheet niobium; jacketed cavities were delivered by industrial suppliers Compton et al. 2015 ; Xu et al. 2017 , and then cold tested at FRIB Zhang et al. 2021 after buffered chemical polishing (BCP), and high-pressure water rinsing (HPWR). Certified cavities were assembled into cryomodules Compton et al. 2017 and cold tested at FRIB Chang et al. 2019 before installation into the linac tunnel. RF pulse conditioning has been used to mitigate field emission during cryomodule bunker testing and in the linac tunnel Cheon et al. 2024 ; Cheon et al. 2025 . Additional spare cryomodules are presently being fabricated. The first spare \beta_{m}=0.086 QWR cryomodule was used for the first FRIB cryomodule plasma processing trial ( \beta_{m} = optimum normalized beam speed v/c ). The cryomodule contains 8 cavities interleaved with 3 superconducting solenoids, all operating at 4.5 K Miller et al. 2019 . Several of the cavities for the spare cryomodule were tested more than once, with iteration on BCP and HPWR in an effort to reduce field emission below the onset levels seen during FRIB cryomodule production. All of the cavities had a low-temperature bake-out prior to their final Dewar test, a step which was not routinely included during FRIB cryomodule production. III Plasma development stages Plasma processing is done with the cavities at room temperature. Our end goal is to develop the capability for plasma processing of FRIB cryomodules in the tunnel. We used a step-wise approach Zhang et al. 2022 ; Hartung et al. 2022 ; Hartung et al. 2023 . Major challenges for FRIB cavities are (i) the fundamental power coupler (FPC) mismatch at room temperature, (ii) the absence of higher-order mode (HOM) couplers, and (iii) the limited view of the cavity interior through access ports. These raise concerns about ignition of plasma in the FPC rather than in the cavity, which would risk damage to the FPC or cavity. The use of a higher-order mode is helpful in reducing mismatch and mitigating the risk of coupler ignition. HOMs have been found useful for the LCLS-II Giaccone et al. 2022 and CEBAF Powers et al. 2024a ; Powers et al. 2024b cavities, both of which have more FPC mismatch at room temperature than the SNS cavities. The plasma ignition threshold RF field increases in an approximately linear manner with RF frequency Tutt et al. 2023 , so the RF power required for plasma ignition using HOMs may be larger than that needed for the fundamental mode, even though the matching is improved. Most of the development work was done using a neon-oxygen plasma at \sim 100 mTorr. First plasma trials were done with the fundamental mode, using custom-length input couplers to provide near-unity coupling at room temperature, Zhang et al. 2022 . Subsequently, three FRIB QWRs were plasma-processed using the FPC and the TEM 5\lambda/4 mode Hartung et al. 2022 . However, in follow-up measurements, we determined that the plasma was in the coupler region rather than in the cavity, even though a reduction in cavity field emission (FE) was seen after coupler plasma processing Hartung et al. 2023 ; X-ray measurements at an accelerating gradient ( E_{a} ) of 10 MV/m

Read the complete text