No-signalling-projection-invariant Bell inequalities
Soumyadip Patra, Jitendra Prakash, Aaditya Paudel, Peter Bierhorst · 2025
Read No-signalling-projection-invariant Bell inequalities by Soumyadip Patra, Jitendra Prakash, Aaditya Paudel, Peter Bierhorst (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-06624.txt.
Introduction
Soumyadip Patra and colleagues show that every Bell inequality hides a standard version untouched by a standard data cleanup. Bell tests probe whether nature admits local realistic descriptions, and raw data often carries faint signalling that analysts project away onto the no-signalling set before judging results. Whether that projection distorts the verdict matters for device-independent uses.
For any setup with several parties choosing among binary-outcome measurements, a canonical form of the inequality exists whose violation the projection leaves unchanged. The team derives a general closed formula for the projection, far cheaper to evaluate than older procedures. Non-standard versions of interest for particular uses fit the same generalization.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Soumyadip Patra, Jitendra Prakash, Aaditya Paudel, Peter Bierhorst |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 63 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-06624
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
No-signalling-projection-invariant Bell inequalities Soumyadip Patra, Jitendra Prakash, Aaditya Paudel, Peter Bierhorst Abstract In this paper, we highlight how any Bell inequality for a configuration involving n n parties each performing one of m m binary-outcome measurements has a canonical form that is no-signalling-projection invariant. Specifically, the L 2 L^{2} -projection of weakly signalling data onto the no-signalling polytope leaves the violation of this canonical Bell inequality unchanged. Our methods allow us to derive a general closed formula for the projection and present a substantially more computationally simple procedure for its evaluation. We also show this can be generalised to non-standard projections of potential interest for certain applications. No-signalling projections serve as a preliminary step before undertaking any device-independent application involving Bell experiment data, such as hypothesis testing against local realism, random number generation and entanglement detection. 1 Introduction The theoretical treatment of Bell nonlocality and its implications can be approached through a study of sets of conditional distributions p(\mathbf{a}\lvert\mathbf{x}) of outcomes given measurement settings, which describe the observable behaviour of a Bell experiment in the asymptotic limit of infinitely many rounds. However, data obtained from real Bell experiments result from finitely many trials and have statistical fluctuations, and consequently, an empirical estimate of p(\mathbf{a}\lvert\mathbf{x}) obtained from the data is almost always guaranteed to have weak signalling effects, in the sense of violating the no-signalling conditions which assert that a party’s marginal probability of outcome must be independent of the other party’s choice of measurement setting. Table 1 shows an example of an experimental count data from a two-party, two-setting, two-outcome Bell test demonstrating the kind of weak-signalling effects that can appear in experimental data. In applications of Bell experiments—such as certifiable device-independent quantum randomness [ 1 , 28 ] , quantum key distribution [ 19 , 41 ] , entanglement certification [ 22 ] , and quantification of statistical nonlocality in multipartite scenarios [ 27 ] —it is necessary to obtain a point estimate of the true trial distribution before proceeding with the implementation of the protocol to ensure optimal performance. Deriving the frequency from some preliminary raw count data and using it as a point estimate for a trial distribution without accounting for weak signalling effects can lead to misleading interpretations. For instance, given such an estimate (the empirical distribution) obtained from the unprocessed experimental data, and a Bell inequality describing a facet of the local polytope, one can find a form of the inequality that is satisfied by the behaviour and a form that is violated by it [ 34 ] (see Figure 2.2 therein); this is because the empirical distribution is weakly-signalling, and the no-signalling terms used to re-express the inequality no longer vanish, so the resulting “equivalent” form can flip from satisfaction to violation. Instead of using the empirical frequency derived from the count data as a point estimate of the true trial distribution, one should find its “closest” approximation satisfying the no-signalling conditions before using it in a protocol which involves the violation of Bell inequalities. This is because in principle, the target behaviour in a Bell experiment obeys the no-signalling constraints. Indeed, implementations that enforce space-like separations of each party’s measurement choice from the other party’s recorded outcome (closing the locality loophole) preclude superluminal communication, and quantum mechanics respects special relativity and therefore meets the no-signalling requirements. Note that without space-like separations, apparent violations of no-signalling can also arise from experimental sub-optimalities, e.g., slow drifts across sequential fixed-setting blocks, or imperfect randomisation [ 39 , 6 , 33 , 15 , 40 ] . In such cases, the observed signalling is best interpreted as a deviation from an ideal, drift-free experiment one aims to estimate; the signalling-contaminated empirical distribution is an unphysical estimate of this underlying no-signalling behaviour. Table 1: Count data from [ 8 ] for a (2,2,2) configuration Bell experiment, a bipartite Bell test where each party has a choice between two dichotomic measurements. Each entry N(ab\lvert xy) represents the number of trials yielding outcomes a and b given measurement settings x and y . It can be checked that the empirical distribution exhibits weak-signalling effects. For instance, the sum of the entries marked † divided by their row sum, (N(00\lvert 00)+N(01\lvert 00))/\sum_{a,b}N(ab\lvert 00)\approx 4.012\times 10^{-3} , does not equal the sum of the entries marked ‡ divided by their row sum, (N(00\lvert 01)+N(01\lvert 01))/\sum_{a,b}N(ab\lvert 01)\approx 3.983\times 10^{-3} . In other words, the marginal probability of outcome a=0 for party \mathsf{A} varies with the choice of input y of party \mathsf{B} . Ideally, this marginal should be independent of the choice of setting y for \mathsf{B} , as required by the no-signalling condition. ab 00 01 10 11 xy 00 3166 † 1851 † 2043 1243520 01 3637 ‡ 1338 ‡ 13544 1230633 10 3992 13752 1226 1230686 11 357 17648 16841 1215766 Two possible methods to achieve a no-signalling approximation to weakly signalling empirical data are based on the procedure of (a) maximum-likelihood (ML) and (b) L^{2} -projection onto the smallest-dimensional affine subspace containing the no-signalling polytope. Given a count dataset, in the ML procedure, one obtains the empirical frequency from the raw data, and then maximises its likelihood with respect to a trial distribution whose corresponding settings-conditional outcome distribution is restricted to satisfy the normalisation and the no-signalling conditions. This preprocessing has been used in the prediction-based ratio approach to hypothesis testing, for instance, in [ 27 , 8 , 47 , 43 , 44 ] , and in device-independent randomness generation via the probability estimation framework [ 45 , 14 , 26 , 42 , 46 ] . While the ML estimator is a statistically natural choice for removing finite statistics fluctuations like those in Table 1 , it typically lacks a closed-form; in practice one solves an iterative convex program enforcing linear equalities (no-signalling and normalisation) and non-negativity inequalities, which will grow in complexity with the Bell scenario as the number of parties, settings, and outcomes increases. Furthermore, the naturality of the ML procedure is much less clear for removing signalling artifacts caused by experimental sub-optimalities such as slow drifts over the course of an experiment in which fixed measurement settings are implemented for a large block of repeated trials, with different measurement settings for different blocks of trials. An estimation procedure akin to averaging across blocks is more appropriate in this case; projection-based denoising can be used to temper this form of weak signalling (though this should not substitute for mitigating experiment-specific causes, if possible). This paper focuses on the L^{2} -projection method which yields the nearest no-signalling approximation of an empirical frequency vector \mathbf{f}\coloneqq\{f(\mathbf{a}\lvert\mathbf{x})\} , according to the Euclidean metric, by orthogonally projecting it onto \mathcal{A} , the affine hull of the no-signalling set \mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{NS}} of behaviours, previously explored in [ 5 , 16 ] . A procedure for performing this affine projection is to first project \mathbf{f} onto the kernel of the equality-constraint matrix A_{\mathrm{eq}} for the linear system A_{\mathrm{eq}}\mathbf{p}=\mathbf{b} encoding the equality conditions of no-signalling and normalisation, followed by a translation by a vector belonging to \mathcal{P}_{\mathrm{NS}} . We prove in Section 2.4 (Proposition 1 ) with an elementary argument that in the (n,m,2) Bell scenario an L^{2} -projection of an empirical frequency onto