High Reynolds number trends of centerline mean velocity and normal stress in pipe flow
Hassan Nagib 1, Lorenzo Lazzarini 2, Gabriele Bellani 2 and Alessandro Talamelli 2 · 2025
Read High Reynolds number trends of centerline mean velocity and normal stress in pipe flow by Hassan Nagib 1, Lorenzo Lazzarini 2, Gabriele Bellani 2 and Alessandro Talamelli 2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-06547.txt.
Introduction
Hassan Nagib and colleagues report precise readings of turbulent pipe flow at unusually high Reynolds numbers. The CICLoPE facility in Italy delivers fully developed pipe flow with outstanding spatial resolution and steady conditions. Pitot probes measured mean centerline velocity while hot wires captured turbulence strength and normal stress over the last two years.
Comparisons with earlier experiments and computer models suggest truly high-Reynolds behavior only sets in past a friction Reynolds number of ten thousand. The centerline von Kármán constant settled firmly at a value the authors report with high confidence. Streamwise intensity and normal stress leveled off past twenty-five thousand, and velocity spectra showed a long, clean inertial range.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hassan Nagib 1, Lorenzo Lazzarini 2, Gabriele Bellani 2 and Alessandro Talamelli 2 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 15 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-06547
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
High Reynolds number trends of centerline mean velocity and normal stress in pipe flow Hassan Nagib 1, Lorenzo Lazzarini 2, Gabriele Bellani 2 and Alessandro Talamelli 2 Abstract The CICLoPE facility at the University of Bologna in Forli, Italy, is a unique facility that provides fully developed pipe flow up to Reynolds numbers of about R e τ Re_{\tau} of 50,000 with exceptional spatial resolution and stable operating conditions. Measurements obtained over the last two years, on the centerline of the pipe in the fully developed test section, with Pitot probes for the mean velocity in the stream ( ± 0.2 % \pm 0.2\% precision) and hot wires for the intensity of turbulence in the streamwise and the normal stress ( ± 5 % \pm~5\% precision) are reported here and compared to other experimental results and some recent direct numerical simulation (DNS) data. The comparisons reveal that high Reynolds number conditions are only reached when R e τ Re_{\tau} is at least larger than 10,000 10,000 . The centerline von Kàrmàn constant, κ C L \kappa_{CL} for pipe flow is confirmed with high confidence to be 0.44 0.44 . Unlike previously reported measurements on the pipe centerline of the streamwise turbulence intensity and normal stress reported in the literature with various conflicting trends, both quantities are found in CICLoPE to reach a level trend beyond R e τ Re_{\tau} around 25,000 25,000 with values of approximately 2.9 % 2.9\% and 0.85 0.85 , respectively. Normalized streamwise velocity spectra on the centerline, with high resolution over seven decades of energy, exhibit a clear and extended − 5 / 3 -5/3 inertial range. Skewness and kurtosis of streamwise velocity are found to be independent of Reynolds number even down to R e τ = 5,000 Re_{\tau}=5,000 and equal to − 0.5 -0.5 and 3.5 3.5 , respectively. 1 Introduction The fully developed pipe flow provides several advantages to study turbulence due to its homogeneous boundary conditions and the relative ease to measure the pressure gradient along the pipe and extract the wall shear stress from it. Although the Superpipe facility at Princeton University allows Reynolds number conditions with Re_{\tau}(=u_{\tau}R/\nu ) about ten times higher than in the CICLoPE facility of the University of Bologna, the spatial resolution accessible in the pipe at CICLoPE is almost an order of magnitude better for similar instrumentation. One of the simplest but most informative measurements made in a turbulent pipe flow are the centerline data for various quantities as a function of Re_{\tau} . However, data from various facilities in a number of countries with air and water flow in pipes of various sizes using different types of sensors are far from agreeing. Our aim here is to establish when the conditions representative of high Reynolds number are reached and what are the correct values and trends for several of the streamwise mean and turbulence quantities. 2 Facility The CICLoPE facility consists of a closed-loop “wind tunnel” with a circular test section 111.5-m . The facility is located within one of the two 130-m underground tunnels in the former Industrie Caproni, one of the leading aircraft manufacturers in Italy from 1930 to 1943, located in Predappio. These tunnels were excavated beneath the mountains before World War II to allow aircraft assembly during bombing raids. The closed-loop design ensures stable flow conditions with low turbulence levels. It includes a heat exchanger to maintain temperature control within a range of \pm 0.1 degree C and a flow conditioning system comprising honeycomb structures, four screens, a settling chamber, and a convergence with a contraction ratio of 4 is the maximum achievable within the dimensional constraints of the site. Figure 1 provides a drawing of the facility, depicting its key components. Figure 1 : Engineering drawing of CICLoPE facility and photograph of hot-wire probe in test section. The primary component of the flow loop, responsible for 60\% of the total pressure losses, is a constant cross-sectional round pipe with an inner diameter of 900 mm. A photograph of the inside of the test section with a hot-wire probe supported by a traversing mechanism with its sensor on the centerline is part of Figure 1. The pipe measures 111.5 m in length , resulting in an L/D ratio of approximately 123. It is constructed from twenty-two 5 m long carbon-fiber sections, followed by a final “test section” of 1.5 m length. All elements were produced using filament-winding technology that results in a surface roughness of k_{rms}<0.2~\mu m; i. e., a typical k^{+}<0.02 and a diameter tolerance of 900\pm 0.2 mm. Each section of the pipe is equipped with four axially spaced static pressure ports and four equally distributed access ports of 150 mm in diameter. The aluminum access ports are machined to sit flush with the inner surface of the pipe. The test section connects to the return circuit located one floor below through a circular-to-rectangular shape converter and a series of diffusers and corners with turning vanes. The fan system is located downstream of a cooling heat exchanger and is designed to provide a pressure increase of 6500 Pa at a volume flow rate of 38~m^{3}/s , corresponding to a maximum velocity of 60 m/s in the test section. It consists of two counter-rotating axial fans mounted in series. Each axial fan has two propellers on a shared motor, powered by a dedicated inverter. The diameter of the fan is 1.8 m, with a total length of 4.2 m, and the maximum power consumption of the system is 340 kW. For noise reduction, straight cylindrical sections 20 m upstream and downstream of the fans are lined with sound-absorbing material. Temperature and humidity are controlled separately for the main tunnel and the laboratory housing the smaller 1.5 m section, using two external air conditioning systems. Both the airflow of the wind tunnel and the fan motors are liquid cooled via a refrigerating circuit connected to an evaporative tower outside the facility. Figure 2 : Normalized centerline mean velocity, U_{CL}^{+}=U_{CL}/u_{\tau} , from CICLoPE by Mascotelli [ 1 ] and Lazzarini [ 2 ] , compared to other data in Superpipe by McKeon et al. [ 3 ] , and to DNS results of Pirozzoli [ 4 ] . 3 Instrumentation The mean velocity on the centerline was measured using a Pitot probe as detailed by Nagib et al. [ 5 ] , and the air temperature was continuously monitored, adjusted and recorded to maintain the conditions stated in the above section on the facility. Several pressure transducers were used to optimize the accuracy of the measurements and included Setra (1k Pa), MKS and Baratron (10, 100 and 1000 Torr) transducers. The Pitot Probe signal was low-pass filtered to prevent aliasing and acquired at 10 kHZ for 30 seconds. The static pressure along the pipe was also measured with these transducers coupled to a Scannivalve or directly with an Initium scanner. The wall shear stress was measured using both the pressure gradient along the fully developed section of the pipe, see Fiorini [ 6 ] , Mascotelli [ 1 ] , and also using Oil Film Interferometry (OFI) in the test section, as detailed by Lazzarini [ 2