Boundary Discontinuity Designs: Theory and Practice

Matias D. Cattaneo, Rocio Titiunik, Ruiqi (Rae) Yu · 2025

Read Boundary Discontinuity Designs: Theory and Practice by Matias D. Cattaneo, Rocio Titiunik, Ruiqi (Rae) Yu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-06474.txt.

Introduction

Matias Cattaneo, Rocio Titiunik, and Ruiqi Rae Yu review the boundary discontinuity design, a method for estimating cause and effect without an experiment. The design exploits a rule that assigns treatment by a two-part score crossing a boundary curve. It extends the familiar regression discontinuity idea, but the two-dimensional score brings fresh complications.

The authors pull together more than eighty empirical studies that use the design, tracing its path from early uses to current practice. They also survey active theory on identification, estimation, and inference built around local polynomial regression. Practical recommendations close the review, aimed at researchers who must handle the two-part threshold carefully.

Catalog record

CREATORMatias D. Cattaneo, Rocio Titiunik, Ruiqi (Rae) Yu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE81 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-06474

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Boundary Discontinuity Designs: Theory and Practice Thanks: This chapter was prepared for the invited session on “Causal Inference and Statistical Decisions” at the 2025 World Congress of the Econometric Society, Seoul (Korea). We thank Alberto Abadie, David Card, Xiaohong Chen, Boris Hanin, Thomas Holmes, Kosuke Imai, Rafael Lalive, Oliver Linton, Xinwei Ma, Francesca Molinari, Jörg Stoye, Jeff Wooldridge, and Joseph Zweimuller for comments and discussions. Financial support from the National Science Foundation through grants SES-2019432, DMS-2210561, and SES-2241575 is gratefully acknowledged. Yu was also partially supported through the Data-Driven Social Science initiative at Princeton University. Matias D. Cattaneo, Rocio Titiunik, Ruiqi (Rae) Yu Abstract We review the literature on boundary discontinuity (BD) designs, a powerful non-experimental research methodology that identifies causal effects by exploiting a thresholding treatment assignment rule based on a bivariate score and a boundary curve. This methodology generalizes standard regression discontinuity designs based on a univariate score and scalar cutoff, and has specific challenges and features related to its multi-dimensional nature. We synthesize the empirical literature by systematically reviewing over 80 80 empirical papers, tracing the method’s application from its formative uses to its implementation in modern research. In addition to the empirical survey, we overview the latest methodological results on identification, estimation and inference for the analysis of BD designs, and offer recommendations for practice. Keywords : regression discontinuity, treatment effects estimation, causal inference. Contents 1 Introduction The Regression Discontinuity (RD) design is one of the leading observational methods for program evaluation and causal inference (see Abadie-Cattaneo_2018_ARE ; Hernan-Robins_2020_Book , for overviews and further references) . In its canonical form, a binary treatment is assigned to units whose value of a score is equal to or above a known cutoff, and not assigned to units whose score is below the cutoff. Under the key assumption that all observable and unobservable pretreatment characteristics vary smoothly around the cutoff, the discontinuous change generated by the hard-thresholding treatment assignment rule based on the univariate score and scalar cutoff can be used to learn about causal treatment effects. Lee-Lemieux_2010_JEL offer an early review with a list of standard RD empirical applications, Cattaneo-Titiunik_2022_ARE give a recent overview of the RD methodological literature, and Cattaneo-Idrobo-Titiunik_2020_CUP ; Cattaneo-Idrobo-Titiunik_2024_CUP provide a practical introduction to modern RD methods and practice. The Boundary Discontinuity (BD) design generalizes the RD design to the case where the score is bivariate, and the treatment is assigned to units according to the location of their score relative to a known boundary that splits its support into two disjoint regions. This setup is sometimes called the Multi-Score RD design ( Papay-Willett-Murnane_2011_JoE ; Reardon-Robinson_2012_JREE ; Wong-Steiner-Cook_2013_JEBS ) , or the Geographic RD design ( Keele-Titiunik_2015_PA ; Keele-Titiunik-Zubizarreta_2015_JRSSA ; Keele-Titiunik_2016_PSRM ; Keele-etal_2017_AIE ; Galiani-McEwan-Quistorff_2017_AIE ; Rischard-Branson-Miratrix-Bornn_2021_JASA ; Diaz-Zubizarreta_2023_AOAS ) . In this chapter, we discuss the empirical strategies most commonly employed for the analysis and interpretation of BD designs, and review the most recent theoretical and methodological results characterizing their econometric properties ( Cattaneo-Titiunik-Yu_2025_BDD-Distance ; Cattaneo-Titiunik-Yu_2025_BDD-Location ; Cattaneo-Titiunik-Yu_2025_BDD-Pooling ) . We introduce the BD design formally in Section 2 , and then outline our review of the empirical literature in Economics, Political Science, Education, and other disciplines. Table 5 reports over 80 empirical papers, which form the basis for the organization of this chapter. We find that the overwhelming majority of papers collapse the bivariate score into a univariate distance score measuring the shortest distance to the treatment assignment boundary, and then report a single average treatment effect estimated by pooling all the observations that are close to the boundary, regardless of their specific location. In contrast, only a handful of empirical papers investigate heterogeneity by localizing to specific regions or points along the boundary, despite the potential importance of this rich information for policy evaluation and decision-making. Following our review of the empirical literature, in Section 3 we discuss pooling-based methods. We begin by discussing the seminal work of Card-Krueger_1994_AER , who appear to be the first to employ the BD design conceptually, although they did not localize to the assignment boundary for estimation purposes. We then discuss holmes1998effect and black1999better , who appear to be the first two papers to employ localization to the assignment boundary explicitly as their main empirical strategy. Subsequent empirical work has recognized the importance of localization to the boundary, but has considered different empirical strategies for treatment effect estimation via local flexible regression methods. One of the most influential papers is dell2010persistent , who incorporated a polynomial expansion of the bivariate location score as part of the local regression specification. More recently, an alternative empirical approach views the estimation based on distance to the boundary as a pooled univariate RD design, and thus estimates treatment effects using a local regression including a polynomial expansion of the univariate distance score. Recent examples include ito2020willingness and dehdari2022origins . Many empirical papers also include boundary-segment fixed effects in their local regression specifications, and some include interactions with the treatment indicator and/or between the polynomial expansions of the univariate distance score and the bivariate location score. Furthermore, for simplicity, or because distinct treatments occur in different regions of the boundary, some papers reduce the BD design to boundary-segment-specific univariate RD designs—see ou2010leave , LondonoVelezRodriguezSanchez_2020_AEJ and salti2022impact . Putting all together, Section 3 discusses eight distinct pooled local regression specifications commonly found in empirical work. Building on our review of empirical strategies used for pooled estimation in BD designs, in Section 3.1 we also overview the main methodological results in Cattaneo-Titiunik-Yu_2025_BDD-Pooling for pooling-based estimation and inference. These methods are viewed as univariate RD designs based on the shortest distance to the assignment boundary, and hence are related to identification, estimation, and inference over a specific one-dimensional submanifold curve on the plane, defined by the assignment boundary. Recognizing this mathematical structure, Cattaneo-Titiunik-Yu_2025_BDD-Pooling establish their formal results leveraging concepts from geometric measure theory ( federer2014geometric ) . After reviewing these ideas, we briefly discuss how estimation and inference can be conducted using the state-of-the-art methods from the RD design literature ( Calonico-Cattaneo-Titiunik_2014_ECMA ; Calonico-Cattaneo-Farrell-Titiunik_2019_RESTAT ; Calonico-Cattaneo-Farrell_2020_ECTJ ) . Some of this work is conceptually related to a recent paper by chen2025semiparametric , who study estimation and inference for integral functionals on submanifolds when using nonparametric sieve estimation. Section 4 discusses heterogeneity analysis and subsequent aggregation of causal treatment effects along the boundary. Although the boundary average treatment effect parameter emerging from pooling-based methods discussed in Section 3 is often of interest, and provides a useful aggregate measure of average treatment effects, the richness of the two-dimensional assignment in BD designs offer the opportunity to explore heterogeneous treatment effects along the assignment boundary. In geographic applications, this heterogeneity is directly linked to the geographic location of the units, providing useful information about how treatment effects vary in space; in non-geographic settings, the heterogeneity is directly linked to features of the units that are captured by the bivariate score variable, and hence the interpretation is necessarily application-specific. Thus, Section 4 begins by introducing the boundary average treatment effect curve, which captures the average treatment effect for each point along the assignment boundary. We also discuss how other aggregate causal effects can be recovered from that building block parameter, such as the weighted boundary average treatment

Read the complete text