Analysis of elastic α \alpha - 12 C scattering with machine learning in the cluster effective field theory

Myeong-Hwan Mun, Jubin Park, Chang Ho Hyun, Shung-Ichi Ando · 2025

Read Analysis of elastic α \alpha - 12 C scattering with machine learning in the cluster effective field theory by Myeong-Hwan Mun, Jubin Park, Chang Ho Hyun, Shung-Ichi Ando (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-06382.txt.

Introduction

Myeong-Hwan Mun and colleagues fit scattering data for alpha particles bouncing off carbon-12 nuclei within cluster effective field theory. The analysis includes resonance states below the breakup threshold into a proton and nitrogen-15. Their amplitude expands in effective range parameters for angular momentum states up to six, giving thirty-seven free parameters in total.

More than eleven thousand measured cross-section points pinned those parameters down. A differential evolution search found the same best fit across independent runs, and a Markov chain Monte Carlo check estimated the uncertainties. The final fit matched the experimental cross sections about as accurately as a standard R-matrix analysis, supporting the method for low-energy nuclear physics tied to stars.

Catalog record

CREATORMyeong-Hwan Mun, Jubin Park, Chang Ho Hyun, Shung-Ichi Ando
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-06382

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Analysis of elastic α \alpha - 12 C scattering with machine learning in the cluster effective field theory Myeong-Hwan Mun, Jubin Park, Chang Ho Hyun, Shung-Ichi Ando Abstract We analyze the elastic α \alpha - 12 C scattering including the contribution of resonance states below the p p - 15 N breakup threshold energy. We use the cluster effective field theory in which scattering amplitude is expanded in terms of the effective range expansion parameters for the angular momentum states from l = 0 l=0 to l = 6 l=6 . The amplitude contains 37 parameters, which are determined by fitting to 11,392 differential cross section data points of the elastic α \alpha - 12 C scattering. To optimize the fitting process, we implement the Differential Evolution (DE) algorithm, which performs a global search over the high-dimensional parameter space and consistently converges to the same minimum χ 2 \chi^{2} value across independent runs, suggesting proximity to the global minimum within the explored domain. In parallel, the Markov chain Monte Carlo method is used to cross-check the DE results and to estimate the parameter uncertainties. The best fit yields χ 2 / N ≃ 6.2 \chi^{2}/N\!\simeq\!6.2 for the elastic scattering data. Using the determined 37 parameters, we calculate the differential cross sections and the phase shifts of the elastic α \alpha - 12 C scattering and compare the results with experimental data and those of an R R -matrix analysis. Our result of the cross section agrees with the experimental data as accurately as an R R -matrix analysis. The results demonstrate that the cluster effective field theory, combined with machine learning based optimization and uncertainty quantification, provides a reliable and systematic framework for application to low-energy phenomena relevant to stellar evolution and nucleosynthesis. I Introduction Effective field theory (EFT) in nuclear physics theory was initiated with the purpose to describe the strong interaction between two nucleons in free space systematically and perturbatively w-pa79 ; w-plb90 . In the EFT energy and momentum in a system or process under consideration are limited to an upper limit, which roughly divides the region above which EFT breaks down. This upper scale is combined with the counting rules that determine the order of Feynman diagrams for a specific process in the power of energy or momentum divided by the upper scale, and it becomes feasible to describe two-nucleon phenomenology at low energies on a field theoretic ground hkvk-rmp20 . Depending on the magnitude of energy and momentum under consideration, scale parameter and counting rules are adjusted to optimize the simplicity and efficiency of the theory. For instance, if one is considering processes in the big bang nucleosynthesis era, relevant energy is below 1 MeV. At this energy scale, even the pion becomes a heavy degree of freedom. Pions are integrated out, and interactions can be described in the contact form. This theory is called pionless EFT crs-npa99 ; k-npb97 . It showed accurate description of two-nucleon systems prc2005 ; prc2007 ; plb2008 and interactions with external electromagnetic and weak probes prc2006 ; prc2010 ; prc2011 ; prc2013 ; jkps2016 ; prc2017 ; prc2020 . The idea of pionless EFT is extended to the systematic expansion of nuclear energy density functional to describe the infinite nuclear matter and finite nuclei, and the attempt resulted in the birth of KIDS (Korea-IBS-Daegu-SKKU) density functional kids1 ; kids2 ; kids3 ; kids4 ; kids5 . Works with KIDS functional have been showing successful applications to diverse nuclear many-body problems such as nuclear structure st1 ; st2 ; st3 ; st4 ; st5 , lepton-nucleus scattering ln1 ; ln2 ; ln3 ; ln4 ; ln5 and nuclear astrophysics astro1 ; astro2 ; astro3 ; astro4 ; astro5 . Works applying the EFT and its extensions, including the KIDS functional, to astrophysical phenomena become more and more popular nowadays. In the stellar evolution and synthesis of heavy elements, the radiative capture of \alpha particle by 12 C, 12 C( \alpha,\gamma ) 16 O plays an essential role. The process primarily happens in the core helium burning stage of the stellar evolution. Temperature at this stage is well below 1 MeV, a scale much smaller than the pion mass, so interactions that drive the capture process can be described in terms of the pionless theory by treating \alpha , 12 C and 16 O as point particles. This theory is named a cluster EFT. Application of the cluster EFT to elastic \alpha - 12 C scattering showed that by adjusting the effective range expansion (ERE) parameters in the theory to the phase shifts of elastic \alpha - 12 C scattering, one can reproduce the experimental data accurately in the angular momentum states from l=0 to l=6 sa-epja16 ; sa-prc18 ; sa-prc20 ; sa-prc22 ; sa-prc23 . The success proves that the cluster EFT could be a candidate for a theory applicable to the study of stellar evolution and nucleosynthesis of light nuclei. While the \alpha - 12 C capture process is so important in nuclear astrophysics, there is a critical difficulty in understanding the process. The capture process happens most actively at Gamow energy E_{G}\simeq 0.3 MeV within stars. Because the Coulomb barrier is much higher than E_{G} , it is extremely difficult to measure the capture cross section (or equivalently S factor) at E_{G} experimentally. For precise understanding of stellar evolution and synthesis of elements, it is inevitable to rely on theoretical estimation of the capture cross section. However, the status of the theory is still ambiguous that recent estimations suffer from uncertainties about 20–30 %, e.g. S_{E1}(E_{G})=80\pm 18 keV b by Tang et al. tang and 100\pm 28 keV b by Oulebsir et al. oulebsir . To reduce the gap, a new method may have to be attempted and advanced constraints on the uncertainty are demanded. In this work, we adopt the cluster EFT to analyze the elastic scattering of \alpha particle and 12 C. Undetermined constants of the theory corresponding to ERE parameters for the angular momentum from l=0 to l=6 are fitted to the elastic \alpha - 12 C scattering cross section data in the energy range 2.6–6.7 MeV and 32 angle values in the range 24.0–165.9 ∘ tetal-prc09 . Total number of data amounts to 11,392. To handle the large number of data efficiently and to obtain optimized results for the fitted parameters, we apply two different machine learning approaches. First, we adopt the differential evolution (DE) algorithm to determine the ERE parameters of the theory. It is known that DE is a method optimized to find global minimum over a large number of parameter space. Once the parameters are determined from the DE calculation, we use the values of DE as a starting point of the Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) calculation. There are two purposes to run the MCMC algorithm: the first is a cross check of the results obtained by the DE calculation, and the second is to estimate the uncertainties of the parameters. Estimation of the uncertainty is particularly important in the extrapolation of the theory to astrophysical energy scales. It is claimed that to have a quantitative description of the helium burning process, the capture cross section at E_{G} should be

Read the complete text