Why ‘Fair Market Valuations’ are Inappropirate for Employee-Owned Firms and Partnerships
David Ellerman · 2025
Read Why ‘Fair Market Valuations’ are Inappropirate for Employee-Owned Firms and Partnerships by David Ellerman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-06274.txt.
Introduction
David Ellerman argues that standard fair market valuation gives the wrong answer for employee-owned firms and partnerships. The usual formulas count future profits from hired labor as value belonging to today's shareholders. That bookkeeping fits firms where owners and workers are different people.
In an employee-owned firm, the future worker-members are themselves the ones entitled to future profits at those later times. Those earnings never flow to the current residual claimants, so counting them inflates the firm's price. Ellerman concludes that any valuation assuming the opposite misprices such firms, and the paper frames the point through property rights and the Miller-Modigliani valuation tradition.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | David Ellerman |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-06274
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Why ‘Fair Market Valuations’ are Inappropirate for Employee-Owned Firms and Partnerships David Ellerman Abstract The usual formulas for the fair market valuation of a firm at time t t include the profits accruing to the shares at time t t from the use of wage or salaried labor in the future. But in employee-owned firms or partnerships, the future worker-members or partners are the residual claimants at those future times, so in those cases, the future residuals do not accrue to the current shareholder/residual-claimants. Hence any ‘fair market valuation’ of an employee-owned firm or partnership that assumes those future residuals accrue to the current shareholder/residual-claimants is inappropriate. Keywords: fair market valuations, residual claimants, property rights, personal rights, Miller-Modigliani valuations. 1 Introduction The basic argument of this paper can be easily outlined. The usual formulas for market or so-called ‘fair’ valuations of a firm are equivalent to the formula that breaks into two parts: (1) the present property rights, the net asset value of the firm, plus (2) the present value of the expected future profits. This formula assumes that the rights of the current owners of the firm include the residual or profit claims in the future time periods. But this is not true in a partnership or in an employee-owned firm such as an Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP) (for simplicity, assume a 100% ESOP) or a worker cooperative. In both those cases, the future partners or the future employee-owners are the residual/profit claimants in those future time periods, so the present value of those profits cannot be imputed to the current partners or employee-owners. In other words, the future partners or employee-owners are not the employees of the current ones. In a conventional firm, the claim of future workers on future revenues is capped at their wages or salaries, so the expected amount of future residual profits (revenues minus expenses including employee expenses) can be plausibly assigned to the current owners, at least in terms of expectations. But partnerships, ESOPs, and worker cooperatives are not conventional firms in that respect. The future partners or worker-members are just as much residual claimants as the current partners or worker-members; their claims are not capped at wages or salaries. Hence the residual profits in those future time periods are imputed or assigned to those future residual claimants, not the current partners or worker-members. It is a simple argument. But the predominance of conventional firms leads to the standard valuations being taken as ‘‘objective’’ by professional or certified valuators. Their professional status as certified business valuators would be jeopardized by any major deviation from the standard ‘objective’ formulas. 1 1 1 One is reminded of Upton Sinclair’s famous quip: “It is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends upon his not understanding it,” Moreover, the full arguments depend on some of the mathematics of financial economics, e.g., by the Nobel laureates Merton Miller and Franco Modigliani [ 15 ] , that go far beyond the cookbook formulas taught to business valuators. Our treatment in the body of the paper will only use simple mathematics or heuristics with the Miller-Modigliani methods treated in the Appendix. 2 Fair market valuation of an asset The relevant points can be made using a simple model. Production assets like a machine or building have passive or active uses. In the passive usage, the asset is rented out for (we assume) some going market rental rate. In competitive markets, the cost of the asset would be the discounted present value of rentals (net of maintenance costs) plus the salvage value. In the active use of the asset, the asset is combined with a set of complementary production services (various inputs and labor) into a going-concern firm and then the owner of the asset would value the asset at the discounted present value of the future net returns plus the salvage value. 2.1 The passive use of the asset Consider a capital asset with a market cost of C which yields the annual stream of capital services K,...,K for n years (for simplicity, assume no depreciation) and then has a salvage value of S . The capital services can be rented or leased out for R per year and the interest rate is assumed to be r (e.g., 0.10 for 10\% ). Hence the discounted present value of the services rendered by the asset on the rental market is: \sum_{k=1}^{n}\frac{RK}{(1+r)^{k}}+\frac{S}{(1+r)^{n}}=RKa(n,r)+\frac{S}{(1+r)^{n}} where a\left(n,r\right) is called the present value of an ordinary annuity of one [ 10 , p. 52] : a\left(n,r\right)=\frac{1}{\left(1+r\right)}+\frac{1}{\left(1+r\right)^{2}}+...+\frac{1}{\left(1+r\right)^{n}} . Then competitive arbitrage between the buy and lease markets will enforce the equation: C=RKa(n,r)+\frac{S}{(1+r)^{n}} . 2.2 The active use of the asset In the active case, a supplementary set of inputs is purchased at the variable cost VC and L units of labor are hired at the wage rate of W per year, and outputs Q are produced which sell for unit price P . Then the economic (i.e., pure) profits obtained at the end of each year are: \pi=PQ-RK-VC-WL (where RK is the implicit cost of tying up that asset in the going-concern firm). Hence the discounted present value of the economic profits is: V_{0}:=\pi a\left(n,r\right) . The capitalized value of the capital asset is defined as the discounted present value of the income stream “generated” by the capital asset. But we have seen there are two ways to generate an income stream from the asset, the passive and the active ways. In the active case, the cashflow stream generated by the asset is: PQ-VC-WL per year plus the salvage value so the total discounted present value in the active case is: V:=\left(PQ-VC-WL\right)a\left(n,r\right)+\frac{S}{\left(1+r\right)^{n}}=\left(RK+\pi\right)a\left(n,r\right)+\frac{S}{\left(1+r\right)^{n}}=\left(RKa\left(n,r\right)+\frac{S}{\left(1+r\right)^{n}}\right)+\pi a\left(n,r\right)=C+V_{0} . This simple example illustrates the capitalized value of the capital asset formula that is behind the valuation formulas for valuing the shares in a corporation. There, in valuing any specific machine, we discount at the market rate of interest the stream of cash receipts generated by the machine, plus any scrap or terminal value of the machine, and minus the stream of cash outlays for direct labor, materials, repairs, and capital additions. The same approach, of course, can also be applied to the firm as a whole, which may be thought of in this context as simply a large, composite machine. [ 15 , p. 415] Thus we see that Miller and Modigliani use the same (active case) capitalized value of the capital asset, i.e., the “specific machine,” since those net cash receipts are \left(PQ-VC-WL\right) and the terminal value is S all discounted back to present value at the interest rate to give V . That is a standard formula for the capitalized value of a capital asset. As John Maynard Keynes put it: When a man buys an investment or capital-asset, he purchases the right to the series of prospective returns, which he expects to obtain from selling its output, after deducting the running expenses of obtaining that output, during the life of the asset. [ 14 , p. 135] 2.3 Analysis of the standard valuation formulas The same formula is applied to a corporation as a “ large, composite machine.” Then the net value of the “machine” C is replaced by the Net Asset Value