Nearly forgotten results in development of physical cosmology
A. F. Zakharov · 2025
Read Nearly forgotten results in development of physical cosmology by A. F. Zakharov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-06018.txt.
Introduction
Alexander Zakharov recalls nearly forgotten turns in the history of cosmology, the study of the universe as a whole. He starts with Einstein's theory of gravity and his first, static model of the cosmos, soon shown to be unstable. Friedmann then found expanding solutions, and Lemaître reached like results plus the growth law that Hubble found in the sky.
Zakharov stresses how Soviet science long treated Friedmann's models as pure math with no cosmic meaning. He credits Lemaître's primeval atom idea with foreseeing a faint background glow. He also notes a Soviet reading of that glow years before Penzias and Wilson, and Gliner's early vacuum-like matter idea, which came before inflation theory. The essay says the standard history skips real work, above all from Soviet-era names.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | A. F. Zakharov |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-06018
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Nearly forgotten results in development of physical cosmology A. F. Zakharov Abstract NICA is a tool to investigate the early Universe in laboratory. It would be reasonable to recall some critical issues in physical cosmology development. GR was created by A. Einstein in 1915. In 1917 Einstein proposed the first (static) cosmological model. Soon after the A. Eddington proved that the model is unstable therefore it can not be realizable in nature. In 1922 and 1924 A. A. Friedmann found non-stationary solutions for cosmological equations written in the framework of GR. In 1927 G. Lemaître obtained very similar results and, in addition, he derived the Hubble law (E. Hubble obtained this law from observations). Unfortunately, G. Lemaître published his paper in not very popular Belgium journal. In 1931 Lemaître proposed the first version of hot Universe model (he called it hypothesis of the primeval atom). In his book ”The Primeval Atom – An Essay on Cosmogony” Lemaitre predicted even a background radiation as a signature of his model. At the end of 1940s G. Gamow and his students proposed his hot universe model where he explained primordial nucleosythesis of helium at the initial stage of the Universe evolution. One of the properties of Lemaître – Gamow model was a prediction of CMB radiation with a temperature around a few K. It was recalled that the discovery of CMB radiation was done by T. Shmaonov in 1956 and his paper was published in 1957 (several years before Penzias and Wilson). In 1965, 1970 E. B. Gliner proposed vacuum like equation of matter which could correspond to exponential explosion of the Universe which was later called inflation. For decades in USSR, A. A. Friedmann’s cosmologocal non-stationary models were treated as purely mathematical results without cosmological and astronomical applications. On September 16, 1925 passed away untimely and it would be reasonable to remind today his great contribution in physical cosmology since the authors of the book on Friedmann’s life and his scientific activity wrote “Similarly to Copernicus who forced the Earth to move, Friedmann forced the Universe to expand”. PACS: 01.65.+g, 04.20.Cv, 04.20.Fy, 04.20.-q, 95.30.Sf, 98.80.-k, 98.70.Vc 1 Introduction General Relativity (GR) was created after intensive conversations between A. Einstein and D. Hilbert in November 1915 [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . Using his new theory of gravity in November 1915 A. Einstein explained the problem of the anomaly of Mercury’s motion, discovered in the middle of the 19th century by Le Verrier and remained unexplained for several decades, and also considered the problem of deflecting a ray of light in a gravitational field, and it turned out that the angle of deviation in general relativity exceeds the angle of deviation in the Newtonian theory of gravity by two times [ 4 ] (see, English translation in [ 5 ] ). In 1917 A. Einstein found a static cosmological solution assuming that the Universe is homogeneous and isotropic [ 6 ] (see English translation in [ 7 ] ). However, the assumptions adopted in the first cosmological paper were very useful and despite the fact that assumptions about the homogeinity and isotropy of the universe do not look very plausible, such assumptions turn out to be applicable to the theoretical description of astronomical observations and are still used in a large number of works on cosmology and are often called the cosmological principle. To create a static cosmological solution and to compensate gravitational attraction A. Einstein introduced so-called \Lambda- term which corresponds to repulsion. In many textbooks and articles the authors repeated after G. Gamow that ”he [A. Einstein] remarked that the introduction of the cosmological term was the biggest blunder he ever made in his life” [ 8 ] (see also a similar sentence in a popular article [ 9 ] )). However, taking into account Gamow’s personality, in particular, his predilection for jokes and practical jokes, and the different social status of Gamow and Einstein, it seems very strange that Einstein chose Gamow as an interlocutor to whom Einstein would admit to the biggest blunder of his entire life (see also discussions in [ 10 , 11 ] ). More over, in 1998 it was discovered an accelerated expansion of the Universe and in order to explain this phenomenon, it is necessary to introduce a non-zero value of the lambda term (or some generalization of it, which since 1999 has been called dark energy) into the Einstein equations. When discussing Einstein’s static cosmological model, it should be noted that it is hardly applicable to describe the behavior of the universe because as a famous Russian mathematician V. I. Arnold repeated only stable mathematical solutions exist in physical world. Analyzing properties of the static cosmological model in 1930 A. Eddington ”working in conjunction with Mr. G. C. McVittie” proved that the Einstein’s static cosmological solution is unstable [ 12 ] . 2 Start of GR studies in Russia In the early 20th century, despite significant achievements in some areas of physical science development in Russia, world leaders in physics worked in Europe. Young Russians who wanted to acquire scientific skills at the cutting edge came to Europe for training and internship. One of these young people interested in science was a representative of the elite of the Russian empire (his father and grandfather were governors in Russian empire), Vsevolod Konstantinovich Frederiks (13.04.1885 (Warsaw) –- 06.01.1944 (Gorky)). He played a key role in initiating research in Russia in the field of GR [ 13 , 14 ] . In 1903 Vsevolod Frederiks finished gymnasium in Nizhnij Novgorod and decided to go to Switzerland due to its convenient location to visit other European countries. In 1907 he finished Geneva University with specialisation in physics and in 1909 he got PhD degree in physics under supervision professor G. E. Guye (Geneve). Since 1911 Frederiks was an assistant under professor Woldemar Voigt 1 1 1 In 1887 W. Voigt found transformations which were similar to Lorentz ones [ 15 ] . In addition, Voigt described group properties of his transformations as it was noted by H. Minkowski in his famous lecture delivered in 1908 [ 16 ] (see also discussions about a relation between Voigt and Lorentz transformations in [ 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 ] ). at the Theoretical division of Physics Institute at Göttingen. In 1914 the WWI began and Frederiks started to be a civil prisoner since he was a citizen of an enemy country. In 1910s famous mathematician David Hilbert was very interested in physics he was searching for educated physicist to discuss actual physical issues. Frederiks began working as Hilbert’s personal assistant, and Hilbert paid Frederiks a monetary reward from his personal funds. The management of the University of Göttingen did not approve this practice to contact with representative of an ebemt country in University and refused to allow Fredericks to enter the University in response to Hilbert’s appeal. In 1918 Frederiks came back in Russia and for a short period he worked in Institute of Physics and Biophysics in Moscow. In 1919 he moved to Petrograd and was a senior physicist at State Optical Institute, a member of Atomic commission, associate professor in Petrograd State University,