Why Estimating η ⊕ \eta_{\oplus} is Difficult: A Kepler-Centric Perspective Journal: PASP Facilities: Kepler lightkurve ( Lightkurve Collaboration et al. 2018 ) , matplotlib ( J. D. Hunter 2007 ) , numpy ( C. R. Harris et al. 2020 ) , pandas ( T. P. D. Team 2020 ; Wes McKinney 2010 ) , scipy ( P. Vi

Steve Bryson, Michelle Kunimoto, Ruslan Belikov, Galen J. Bergsten, Sakhee Bhure, William J. Borucki, Douglas A. Caldwell, Aritra Chakrabarty, Rachel B. Fernandes, Matthias Y. He, Jon M. Jenkins, Kristo Ment, Michael R. Meyer, Gijs D. Mulders, Ilaria Pascucci, Peter Plavchan · 2025

Read Why Estimating η ⊕ \eta_{\oplus} is Difficult: A Kepler-Centric Perspective Journal: PASP Facilities: Kepler lightkurve ( Lightkurve Collaboration et al. 2018 ) , matplotlib ( J. D. Hunter 2007 ) , numpy ( C. R. Harris et al. 2020 ) , pandas ( T. P. D. Team 2020 ; Wes McKinney 2010 ) , scipy ( P. Vi by Steve Bryson, Michelle Kunimoto, Ruslan Belikov, Galen J. Bergsten, Sakhee Bhure, William J. Borucki, Douglas A. Caldwell, Aritra Chakrabarty, Rachel B. Fernandes, Matthias Y. He, Jon M. Jenkins, Kristo Ment, Michael R. Meyer, Gijs D. Mulders, Ilaria Pascucci, Peter Plavchan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-05658.txt.

Introduction

Steve Bryson leads a team asking why estimates of Earth-like planets around Sun-like stars disagree so wildly. The quantity at stake counts rocky planets in the habitable zone, where liquid water could exist. The Kepler telescope was built to measure it, yet published values differ by more than a factor of ten.

The team traces the spread to two sources. Studies differ in definitions and input data, and Kepler's own limits force hard inference, since its detection edge sits right in the regime of interest. Extrapolating from easier planets risks large bias. The authors suggest reprocessing Kepler data for cleaner catalogs and look ahead to future telescopes that can measure the rate directly.

Catalog record

CREATORSteve Bryson, Michelle Kunimoto, Ruslan Belikov, Galen J. Bergsten, Sakhee Bhure, William J. Borucki, Douglas A. Caldwell, Aritra Chakrabarty, Rachel B. Fernandes, Matthias Y. He, Jon M. Jenkins, Kristo Ment, Michael R. Meyer, Gijs D. Mulders, Ilaria Pascucci, Peter Plavchan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE92 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-05658

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Why Estimating η ⊕ \eta_{\oplus} is Difficult: A Kepler-Centric Perspective Journal: PASP Facilities: Kepler lightkurve ( Lightkurve Collaboration et al. 2018 ) , matplotlib ( J. D. Hunter 2007 ) , numpy ( C. R. Harris et al. 2020 ) , pandas ( T. P. D. Team 2020 ; Wes McKinney 2010 ) , scipy ( P. Virtanen et al. 2020 ) Steve Bryson, Michelle Kunimoto, Ruslan Belikov, Galen J. Bergsten, Sakhee Bhure, William J. Borucki, Douglas A. Caldwell, Aritra Chakrabarty, Rachel B. Fernandes, Matthias Y. He, Jon M. Jenkins, Kristo Ment, Michael R. Meyer, Gijs D. Mulders, Ilaria Pascucci, Peter Plavchan Abstract η ⊕ \eta_{\oplus} , the occurrence rate of rocky habitable zone exoplanets orbiting Sun-like stars, is of great interest to both the astronomical community and the general public. The Kepler space telescope has made it possible to estimate η ⊕ \eta_{\oplus} , but estimates by different groups vary by more than an order of magnitude. We identify several causes for this range of estimates. We first review why, despite being designed to estimate η ⊕ \eta_{\oplus} , Kepler’s observations are not sufficient for a high-confidence estimate, due to Kepler’s detection limit coinciding with the η ⊕ \eta_{\oplus} regime. This results in a need to infer η ⊕ \eta_{\oplus} , for example extrapolating from a regime of non-habitable zone, non-rocky exoplanets. We examine two broad classes of causes that can account for the large discrepancy in η ⊕ \eta_{\oplus} found in the literature: a) differences in definitions and input data between studies, and b) fundamental limits in Kepler data that lead to large uncertainties and poor accuracy. We highlight the risk of large biases when using extrapolation to describe small exoplanet populations in the habitable zone. We discuss how η ⊕ \eta_{\oplus} estimates based on Kepler data can be improved, such as reprocessing Kepler data for more complete, higher-reliability detections and better exoplanet catalog characterization. We briefly survey upcoming space telescopes capable of measuring η ⊕ \eta_{\oplus} , and how they can be used to supplement Kepler data. I Introduction The Kepler mission ( W. J. Borucki et al. 2010 ; D. G. Koch et al. 2010 ; W. J. Borucki 2016 ) was designed to estimate \eta_{\oplus} - defined by the mission as the occurrence of habitable-zone rocky exoplanets around Sun-like stars. Understanding \eta_{\oplus} is of great interest to the exoplanet community and the general public, and is an important input to mission design for instruments designed to detect and characterize habitable-zone exoplanets such as the Habitable Worlds Observatory ( L. Feinberg et al. 2024 ; C. C. Stark et al. 2024 ) . Kepler’s strategy to estimate \eta_{\oplus} was to continuously observe > 150,000 Solar-like main-sequence dwarf stars (primarily spectral types F, G, and K) for at least four years, with a highly sensitive photometer in Solar orbit, identifying exoplanets through the detection of transits. Launched in March 2009, Kepler’s continuous period of observation was from May 2009 to August 2013, when it was interrupted by the loss of ability to maintain stable pointing at the original star field. The Kepler telescope was then repurposed as the K2 mission ( S. B. Howell et al. 2014 ) to observe ecliptic fields for \sim 90 days at a time, delivering many wonderful and diverse science results. In this work, we focus on the long-stare observations of the same stars from 2009 to 2013, hereafter referred to as Kepler’s prime mission. The data collected from the prime mission was processed by the Kepler Science Operation Center pipeline ( J. M. Jenkins 2002 ; J. M. Jenkins et al. 2010 ; J. M. Jenkins & et al. 2020 ) , resulting in several data releases, many of which included exoplanet candidate catalogs. The final Kepler data release 25 (DR25) ( S. E. Thompson et al. 2018 ) included a uniformly created exoplanet candidate catalog with several products that can be used to measure the catalog’s completeness and reliability, enabling bias-corrected calculations of intrinsic exoplanet occurrence rates from the Kepler sample. A sampling of values of \eta_{\oplus} from Kepler data is shown in Figure 1 , exhibiting the large range that have been published in the literature. In this work, we attempt to identify common difficulties underlying the computation of \eta_{\oplus} , and discuss whether or not the range of values in Figure 1 can be resolved without more observational data. We do not advocate that any method for estimating \eta_{\oplus} is better than any other, nor do we present our “best estimate” of \eta_{\oplus} . We do not consider issues of confirmation or statistical validation, because the confirmation/validation process is not sufficiently well characterized to support demographic studies (see the discussion in § III.2 ). Beyond generally considering false positives, we do not address astrophysical issues – such as stellar and planetary multiplicity – and how they impact \eta_{\oplus} estimates. This work is not a review of the \eta_{\oplus} in general – in particular we do not comprehensively discuss \eta_{\oplus} measurements in the literature. Rather, we seek to raise awareness of issues with Kepler data that will be encountered in any attempt to estimate \eta_{\oplus} from that data. For a broader review of \eta_{\oplus} beyond issues with Kepler data, see R. B. Fernandes et al. 2025a . I.1 What is \eta_{\oplus} ? In this work we adopt the broad sense of \eta_{\oplus} as the number of exoplanets per star that may be potentially habitable for life as we know it. This choice is motivated by the goal of the Habitable Worlds Observatory (HWO) to detect biosignatures around “Earth-sized” exoplanets. We assume that life as we know it requires Earth-like conditions: a rocky world with an atmosphere, and the presence of liquid water. In this section we briefly survey the conceptual issues with turning this characterization of \eta_{\oplus} into data useful for \eta_{\oplus} estimates, and present a more detailed discussion in § IV . Relating these criteria to Kepler observables such as exoplanet size and orbital period is challenging. A consensus has emerged that the rocky exoplanet radius upper limit is about 1.64\pm 0.05R_{\oplus} ( L. A. Rogers 2015 ; S. Müller et al. 2024 ) , though, for example, C. C. Stark et al. 2024 adapts 1.4R_{\oplus} and J. F. Otegi et al. 2020 suggests that some exoplanets with radii up to 2.5R_{\oplus} may be rocky. The lower limit on the size of a rocky exoplanet in the habitable zone that can retain an atmosphere is less well constrained, partly because there are currently no exoplanets with a radius less than 1R_{\oplus} with observed atmospheres. This lower radius limit likely depends on the stellar instellation on the exoplanet. C. C. Stark et al. 2024 adopts the minimum radius of 0.8(a/\mathrm{EEID})^{-0.5}R_{\oplus} , where a is the exoplanet’s semi-major axis in AU and EEID is the distance in AU at which the exoplanet would have the same instellation flux as the Earth. Similarly, the relationship between the habitable zone and orbital period is ambiguous for a collection of stars. The habitable zone of a specific star can be well-characterized in terms of that star’s effective temperature as a range of instellation fluxes ( R. K. Kopparapu et al. 2013 ) ,

Read the complete text