An improved reliability factor for quantitative low-energy electron diffraction Publication type: Paper

Alexander M. Imre 1, Lutz Hammer 2, Ulrike Diebold 1, Michele Riva 1, and Michael Schmid 1,∗ · 2025

Read An improved reliability factor for quantitative low-energy electron diffraction Publication type: Paper by Alexander M. Imre 1, Lutz Hammer 2, Ulrike Diebold 1, Michele Riva 1, and Michael Schmid 1,∗ (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-05448.txt.

Introduction

Alexander Imre and co-authors improve the reliability factor used in quantitative low-energy electron diffraction, a method that reads surface structure from how electron beams bounce off a crystal face. The method fits computed beam strengths to measured ones and grades the fit.

The standard Pendry R factor is noisy as a fit target and jumps at small shifts in strength, which can mislead the search for the true surface. Their improved factor aims to smooth those flaws. A steadier grade should make surface calls from diffraction data more firm and less prone to false best fits.

Catalog record

CREATORAlexander M. Imre 1, Lutz Hammer 2, Ulrike Diebold 1, Michele Riva 1, and Michael Schmid 1,∗
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE57 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-05448

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

An improved reliability factor for quantitative low-energy electron diffraction Publication type: Paper Alexander M. Imre 1, Lutz Hammer 2, Ulrike Diebold 1, Michele Riva 1, and Michael Schmid 1,∗ Abstract Quantitative low-energy electron diffraction [LEED I ⁡ ( V ) I(V) or LEED I ⁡ ( E ) I(E) , the evaluation of diffraction intensities I I as a function of the electron energy] is a versatile technique for the study of surface structures. The technique is based on optimizing the agreement between experimental and calculated intensities. Today, the most commonly used measure of agreement is Pendry’s R R factor R P R_{\mathrm{P}} . While R P R_{\mathrm{P}} has many advantages, it also has severe shortcomings, as it is a noisy target function for optimization and very sensitive to small offsets of the intensity. Furthermore, R P = 0 R_{\mathrm{P}}=0 , which is meant to imply perfect agreement between two I ⁡ ( E ) I(E) curves can also be achieved by qualitatively very different curves. We present a modified R R factor R S R_{\mathrm{S}} , which can be used as a direct replacement for R P R_{\mathrm{P}} , but avoids these shortcomings. We also demonstrate that R S R_{\mathrm{S}} is as good as R P R_{\mathrm{P}} or better in steering the optimization to the correct result in the case of imperfections of the experimental data, while another common R R factor, R ZJ R_{\mathrm{ZJ}} (suggested by Zanazzi and Jona) is worse in this respect. 1 Introduction Quantitative low-energy electron diffraction (LEED) analyzes the diffraction intensities I as a function of the electron energy E or equivalently, electron acceleration voltage V . Thus, the technique is also known known as LEED I(V) or LEED I(E) , and the data are commonly referred to as I(V) or I(E) curves. Quantitative LEED is the oldest method for obtaining high-accuracy data in surface crystallography and has the advantage that it uses rather simple instrumentation (LEED optics), which is available in many ultrahigh-vacuum surface science systems [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] . The ViPErLEED project [ 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 ] aims at simplifying the use of this important method, and also includes further method development, as in the current work. LEED I(E) analysis is based on the comparison of the calculated I(E) curves with the experimental ones. The agreement between calculated and experimental I(E) curves is described by a reliability factor ( R factor). Assuming that the structure model is qualitatively correct, variation of the structural parameters (such as atom coordinates and vibration amplitudes) to minimize the R factor leads to the best-fit structure. Many different types of R factors have been proposed and used for LEED I(E) [ 2 ] . The simplest one is essentially an L^{2} norm R_{2}=\frac{1}{\int{I_{\mathrm{exp}}^{2}\mathrm{d}E}}\int{(I_{\mathrm{exp}}-cI_{\mathrm{th}})^{2}\mathrm{d}E} (1) where the subscripts “exp” and “th” refer to the experimental and calculated (theory) data, respectively. The factor c=\int{I_{\mathrm{exp}}\mathrm{d}E}/\int{I_{\mathrm{th}}\mathrm{d}E} takes into account that experiments determine only relative intensities; the ratio between the outgoing electron current of a given diffraction maximum (named diffraction “beam” in LEED studies) and the primary current of the incident electrons is usually not known quantitatively. In most cases, R_{2} is not an ideal metric for LEED I(E) analysis, however. If two I(E) curves are qualitatively very similar, but the relative peak heights differ, R_{2} values can be rather poor. Different relative peak heights between experiment and calculation are very common, however, e.g., because of energy-dependent gain factors in experiment or an inaccurate description of energy-dependent inelastic scattering in the calculations. Furthermore, R_{2} is not very sensitive to the positions of the minima of the I(E) curves. This is undesirable since the minima carry important information and are less susceptible to various imperfections of experimental I(E) curves that strongly influence the maxima (e.g., uneven transmission of the grids, shot noise). A more elaborate R factor was proposed by Zanazzi and Jona [ 13 ] . It is based on the first and second derivatives of the I(E) curves: R_{\mathrm{ZJ}}\propto\int{\frac{|I^{\prime}_{\mathrm{exp}}-cI^{\prime}_{\mathrm{th}}|\times|I^{\prime\prime}_{\mathrm{exp}}-cI^{\prime\prime}_{\mathrm{th}}|}{|I^{\prime}_{\mathrm{exp}}|+\max(|I^{\prime}_{\mathrm{exp}}|)}\mathrm{d}E} (2) The denominator is meant to put increased weight on regions of minima and maxima, where the first derivative I^{\prime} vanishes. 1 1 1 In practice, the denominator in the integral of R_{\mathrm{ZJ}} , |I^{\prime}_{\mathrm{exp}}|+\max(|I^{\prime}_{\mathrm{exp}}|) substantially exceeds its minimum value of \max(|I^{\prime}_{\mathrm{exp}}|) only at the slopes of high peaks and only the influence of these gets reduced by a factor that can reach 1/2 . For weak peaks, |I^{\prime}_{\mathrm{exp}}| is usually much less than \max(|I^{\prime}_{\mathrm{exp}}|) . Therefore, the denominator slightly reduces the weights for high-intensity peaks, but to a far lesser degree than Pendry’s R factor, where the absolute height of a maximum does not affect its influence on the R factor. Like R_{2} , R_{\mathrm{ZJ}} uses an energy-independent scale factor c between experimental and calculated intensities. This makes it sensitive to slow variations with the energy of the experimental or calculated intensity scale factor. A further disadvantage of R_{\mathrm{ZJ}} lies in the fact that it heavily depends on the second derivative I^{\prime\prime} . Experimental I(E) curves inevitably contain some noise, but also the calculated curves often exhibit numerical noise (e.g., due to matrix inversions, if not all matrices are sufficiently well-conditioned to avoid numerical inaccuracies). Since the derivatives are calculated numerically, the second derivative I^{\prime\prime} is more sensitive to noise and small numerical errors than I^{\prime} . Pendry’s R factor R_{\mathrm{P}} avoids these issues since it is based on the logarithmic derivative L=\mathrm{d}\ln I/\mathrm{d}E [ 14 ] . A direct comparison of the L functions of the experimental and theoretical I(E) curves is not feasible because L approaches infinity if I approaches zero. 2 2 2 When expressing L as I^{\prime}/I , both the numerator and the denominator reach zero at a minimum of intensity I=0 . Since I(E) and its derivatives are smooth functions, one will typically have I\propto(E-E_{0})^{2} and I^{\prime}\propto E-E_{0} , with E_{0} being the energy of the minimum. This leads to L\propto(E-E_{0})^{-1} , which diverges at the minimum (for E\to E_{0} ). Therefore, R_{\mathrm{P}} does not use L directly but rather compares the experimental and calculated Y_{\mathrm{P}} functions (named Y_{\mathrm{exp}} and Y_{\mathrm{th}} , respectively): \displaystyle L \displaystyle=\frac{\mathrm{d}\ln I}{\mathrm{d}E}=\frac{I^{\prime}}{I} (3) \displaystyle Y_{\mathrm{P}} \displaystyle=\frac{L^{-1}}{L^{-2}+V_{\mathrm{0i}}^{2}}=\frac{L}{1+V_{\mathrm{0i}}^{2}L^{2}}=\frac{I\times I^{\prime}}{I^{2}+V_{\mathrm{0i}}^{2}I^{\prime 2}} (4) \displaystyle R_{\mathrm{P}} \displaystyle=\frac{\int{(Y_{\mathrm{exp}}-Y_{\mathrm{th}})^{2}\,\mathrm{d}E}}{\int{(Y_{\mathrm{exp}}^{2}+Y_{\mathrm{th}}^{2})\,\mathrm{d}E}} (5) Note that the Y_{\mathrm{P}} function approaches zero for both L\to 0 and L\to\pm\infty . This means that R_{\mathrm{P}} is insensitive to the high (or even infinite) values that the logarithmic derivative L reaches in minima with the intensity approaching 0. V_{\mathrm{0i}} is the imaginary part of the inner potential 3 3 3 LEED I(E) calculations are based on the concept of muffin-tin potentials and replace the atoms by point scatterers; the inner potential is the potential between the scatterers and determines the propagation of the waves in the solid. The imaginary part V_{\mathrm{0i}} of the inner potential leads to an exponential decay and is also known as optical potential [ 1 ] . and describes the inelastic scattering of the electrons. It provides a natural energy scale: Assuming single scattering (kinematic diffraction theory), the peaks of I(E) are Lorentzians with a full width at half maximum of 2|V_{\mathrm{0i}}| [ 14 ] . LEED must be described by multiple scattering (dynamic

Read the complete text