Interscale energy transfer in turbulent channels

Joy Chen 1 and Ricardo García-Mayoral 1 · 2025

Read Interscale energy transfer in turbulent channels by Joy Chen 1 and Ricardo García-Mayoral 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-05428.txt.

Introduction

Joy Chen and a co-author trace how energy moves across scales in turbulent flow inside a channel. The cascade comes from nonlinear terms in the Navier-Stokes equations, whose interactions must meet triadic rules that link three wave parts at once.

The authors split transfer between streamwise and spanwise scales, a split shaped by the channel's unlike directions. Each triadic act is mapped on its own, with its momentum and energy flow, then ranked. The map shows which links do the heavy lifting to keep channel turbulence alive, a detail that models of wall flow need.

Catalog record

CREATORJoy Chen 1 and Ricardo García-Mayoral 1
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-05428

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Interscale energy transfer in turbulent channels Joy Chen 1 and Ricardo García-Mayoral 1 Abstract We investigate the energy cascade in wall-bounded turbulence by analysing the interscale transfer between streamwise and spanwise length scales in periodic channels. This transfer originates from the nonlinear interactions in the advective term of the Navier–Stokes equations, which satisfy the classical triadic compatibility relations. Each triadic interaction is examined individually, and its corresponding nonlinear momentum and energy transfer are mapped to assess its relative importance in sustaining turbulence. Motivated by the anisotropy of the flow, we interpret each contribution ∂ i ( u i ​ u j ) \partial_{i}(u_{i}u_{j}) to the advection term as carrying distinct physical information , and therefore analyse them separately. Time-averaged maps of the energy transfer across all length scales and wall-normal positions for a channel flow at R ​ e τ ≈ 180 Re_{\tau}\approx 180 are used to explore the mechanisms underlying the cascade process. As a proof of concept, reduced-order simulations are performed by retaining only the interactions identified as responsible for significant energy transfer based on our framework. Turbulent dynamics are successfully reproduced when 30% or more of the total interactions are included, while noticeable deviations emerge in the near-wall region when this proportion is further reduced. 1 Introduction The turbulent energy cascade is central to our understanding of turbulence. In turbulent flows, energy is typically injected at large lengthscales and transferred through inter-scale interactions to smaller scales, ultimately being dissipated at viscous scales. In periodic channels, we can leverage the spatial periodicity of the flow to consider the governing equations in their streamwise- ( x ) and spanwise- ( z ) Fourier form. The inter-scale transfer is then inherently in the non-linear terms, as linear operators, though responsible for critical turbulent processes ( 18 ) , preserve wavenumber. In the Navier-Stokes equations, the non-linear term responsible for this transfer is the advection term, \nabla\cdot(\bm{uu}) , which enables the triadic wavenumber interactions: a catalyst velocity component with wavenumber \bm{k}_{c} advects a donor velocity component with wavenumber \bm{k}_{d} to transfer momentum and energy to a recipient mode with wavenumber \bm{k}_{r}=\bm{k}_{c}+\bm{k}_{d} . The cascade proceeds through a hierarchy of such triadic interactions, as illustrated in Figure 1 , where different lengthscales can participate in the overall transfer with all three roles simultaneously, i.e. wavelength k_{3} serves as the recipient for interaction I but is also the catalyst for interaction III , etc. The proposed framework emphasises the two-into-one directionality in each triadic interaction, i.e. catalyst and donor combining to cause an effect in a recipient, but makes no a priori distinction between interactions contributing to the direct cascade, energy transfer from large to small scales, and those contributing to the inverse cascade or backscatter. Figure 1 : Sketch of interscale interactions , adapted from 6 . Interaction I involves a recipient mode \bm{k}_{3} receiving energy from an interaction between mode \bm{k}_{1} and \bm{k}_{2} ; \bm{k}_{3} in turn interacts with \bm{k}_{6} in interaction III to transfer energy into \bm{k}_{7} , and so on to viscosity . The evolution of turbulent kinetic energy through inter-scale triadic interactions has been the subject of extensive research ( 8 , 9 , 22 ) . Previous studies have mapped triadic interactions in wall-bounded turbulence in various different forms. These include: maps of the bispectrum and biphase of streamwise wave triads ( 5 ) ; spanwise triadic wave interactions involved in turbulent energy transfer ( 4 ) ; spanwise and streamwise triadic wave interactions involved in turbulent energy transfer ( 16 ) ; spanwise and streamwise wave dyad interactions into the principal resolvent mode ( 2 ) ; causal maps of inter-scale flux of information between signals of different wavelength ( 17 ) ; interscale triadic causality maps ( 6 ) ; or the overall transfer from a donor mode to a recipient mode ( 7 ) . Inter-scale transfer has also been analysed in the spatial domain through the use of structure functions and the Kármán–Howarth–Monin–Hill equation ( 3 , 23 ) , and in the context of resolvent analysis when trying to characterise the non-linear, forcing term ( 24 , 20 , 21 ) . 15 considered the interscale energy transfer in minimal channels, with streak breakdown and vortex regeneration viewed as instances of forward and reverse energy cascade. 6 drew a distinction between the nine individual contributions to the advective term in the Navier-Stokes equations, \partial_{i}(u_{i}u_{j}) . They argue d that, due to the anisotropy of wall turbulence, each of these contributions could be interpreted as representing a distinct physical mechanism. They proposed a framework to map separately each of these contributions for each triadic-compatible set of modes. We extend their preliminary exploration by generating maps that represent flow dynamics throughout the channel. We identify the key interactions responsible for significant energy transfer and, as a proof of concept, perform reduced-order simulations in which only these interactions are retained in the nonlinear advective term. This allows us to assess whether turbulent flow dynamics can be reproduced, thereby verifying the significance of the selected modes. As a benchmark, we use a channel of size L_{x}=2\pi , L_{z}=\pi , L_{y}=2 at low friction Reynolds number, Re {}_{\tau}\approx 180 , leaving the consideration of larger and more complex flows for future work. The ultimate objectives of the proposed framework are threefold. First, to gain insights into the flow physics through the identification of the most significant nonlinear interactions. Second, to provide a roadmap for developing reduced-order models in which only a small number of key interactions are retained, thus reducing the computational cost of simulations and proposing new approach to turbulence modelling . Third, to identify potential ‘bottleneck’ regions in the interscale transfer maps that may play a critical role in the energy cascade. If such regions exist, they could be strategically targeted for optimal disruption of turbulence in flow - control applications. The paper is organised as follows. §2 describes the methods used to map the inter-scale transfer in an x - z -periodic channel and the details of the reduced order simulations. §3.1 examines the maps of the inter-scale energy transfer to two different scales, and §3.2 compares the from the reduced order simulation to those of full DNSs. §4 summarises and concludes the paper. 2 Methods 2.1 Nonlinear energy transfer maps The Navier-Stokes and continuity equations in Fourier space for any given recipient mode \bm{k}_{r} can be obtained by applying a streamwise ( x )–spanwise ( z ) Fourier transform to the equations in physical space, \begin{split}\frac{\partial\bm{\hat{u}}}{\partial t}(\bm{k}_{r},y,t)+\!\!\!\!\!\sum_{\bm{k}_{c}+\bm{k}_{d}=\bm{k}_{r}}\hat{\nabla}\cdot(\bm{\hat{u}}(\bm{k}_{c},y,t)\bm{\hat{u}}(\bm{k}_{d},y,t))=-\hat{\nabla}\hat{p}(\bm{k}_{r},y,t)+\nu\hat{\nabla}^{2}\bm{\hat{u}}(\bm{k}_{r},y,t),\end{split} (1) \hat{\nabla}\cdot\bm{\hat{u}}(\bm{k}_{r},y,t)=0, (2) where \bm{u}=[u,v,w]^{T} is the velocity vector, \nu is the kinematic viscosity and p kinematic pressure. Fourier-transformed quantities are denoted with \hat{(\cdot)} and \hat{\nabla}=[\mathrm{i}k_{x}\;{\partial}/{\partial y}\;\mathrm{i}k_{z}]^{T} is the Fourier transform of the del operator . The linear operators {\partial}/{\partial t} , \nabla and \nabla^{2} , along with the linear part of the advection \hat{\nabla}\cdot(\bm{\hat{u}}(\bm{k}_{r})\bm{\hat{U}})+\hat{\nabla}\cdot(\bm{\hat{U}}\bm{\hat{u}}(\bm{k}_{r})) , where \bm{U} represents the mean flow ( \bm{k}_{d} or \bm{k}_{c}=0 ), are Fourier transformed trivially . However, the non-linear part of the advection ( \bm{\hat{n}} ) becomes a convolution in the wavenumber domain, coupling velocity modes through triadic interactions, where \begin{split}\bm{\hat{n}}(\bm{k}_{r})&=\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}\bm{k}_{c}+\bm{k}_{d}=\bm{k}_{r}\\ \bm{k}_{c},\bm{k}_{d}\neq 0\end{subarray}}-\hat{\nabla}(\bm{\hat{u}}(\bm{k}_{c})\bm{\hat{u}}(\bm{k}_{d})).\end{split} (3) Each non-linear term for the recipient mode \bm{k}_{r} is made up of all possible combinations of

Read the complete text