AWARE: Evaluating PriorityFresh Caching for Offline Emergency Warning Systems

Charles Melvin, N. Rich Nguyen · 2025

Read AWARE: Evaluating PriorityFresh Caching for Offline Emergency Warning Systems by Charles Melvin, N. Rich Nguyen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-05022.txt.

Introduction

Charles Melvin and Rich Nguyen test PriorityFresh, a cache rule for offline alert systems, inside their AWARE test setting. When links are weak or cut, an alert device must choose which warnings to keep and show first.

PriorityFresh ranks alerts by how useful they are for action, not just by age or size. Tests in the simulation show gains on that action-first score with no loss in speed or thrift. A split forecasting model only made the test alert streams; it played no part at all in cache or push choices for the live public warnings.

Catalog record

CREATORCharles Melvin, N. Rich Nguyen
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-05022

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

AWARE: Evaluating PriorityFresh Caching for Offline Emergency Warning Systems Charles Melvin, N. Rich Nguyen Abstract PriorityFresh is a semantic, actionability-first caching policy designed for offline emergency warning systems. Within AWARE’s simulation environment, PriorityFresh optimizes which alerts to retain and surface under constrained connectivity. Experiments indicate improved actionability-first performance without harming efficiency. A separate Priority Forecasting (PF) model is used only to synthesize realistic alert sequences for controlled experiments and does not influence caching or push decisions. Keywords Emergency alerts; offline-first; caching; PriorityFresh; Wireless Emergency Alerts (WEA); Emergency Alert System (EAS); disaster communication; TinyLFU; Least Frequently Used (LFU); TTLOnly; simulation 1 Introduction Disaster-time information systems face a simple but consequential question: How can emergency systems most effectively deliver the most critical alerts to people? In AWARE, which encompasses multiple components, “most pressing” refers to alerts that are both high-impact (severity, urgency) and still relevant (freshness). PriorityFresh is evaluated in isolation: it ranks content semantically and maintains top-priority items until they decay below relevance or expire. A separate Priority Forecasting (PF) model is used only upstream to help generate realistic alert scenarios for the simulator; PF and PriorityFresh are operationally independent—the cache policy does not consume PF outputs, and PF does not alter cache or push decisions. 2 Contributions Key contributions (within a simulation-only evaluation): • AWARE simulation environment. A browser-hosted, offline-first simulator with reproducible, seeded environments and persistent run history for analysis—used to evaluate components of the broader AWARE system. • PriorityFresh policy. A semantic, actionability-first eviction score is formalized. • Human-centered metrics. Metrics that align with protective action (actionability-first, timeliness consistency, redundancy) are defined and reported, alongside standard efficiency (hit, delivery, freshness). • Empirical findings and operator guidance. Across cache-size, network-reliability, joint sweeps, and extreme scenarios, PriorityFresh consistently improves actionability without harming efficiency; delivery is dominated by network physics. A winner-matrix view and a context-aware recommendation table summarize policy selection by device capability and network conditions, including cases where PAFTinyLFU is preferred (mission-critical first-surface regularity) and where TTLOnly is preferred (strict freshness SLAs), to avoid policy bias. • Stakeholder-facing implications (preview). The evaluation later details role-specific guidance. In brief: (i) alert originators benefit from standardized CAP severity/urgency coding, thread identifiers, and tighter polygons with concise directives; (ii) telecom/platform providers can expose delivery telemetry, support device-assisted geofencing, and offer rate-limit/dedup primitives; (iii) app operators can match policy to objective (PriorityFresh under constrained caches or unreliable links; PAFTinyLFU when first-surface timing regularity is paramount; TTLOnly for strict freshness SLAs) and configure weights (w_{S},w_{U},w_{F}) and push guardrails R,D,\theta with fail-open treatment for Immediate/Extreme; (iv) local governments and community organizations can localize templates, validate relevance thresholds, and maintain fresh shelter data; (v) end users benefit from clear, low-noise interfaces that surface the most actionable item first and retain guidance for auditability. 3 Related work 3.1 Emergency alert systems Modern public warning in the U.S. centers on FEMA’s Integrated Public Alert and Warning System (IPAWS), which brokers alerts from authorized originators to distribution channels including Wireless Emergency Alerts (WEA), the broadcast Emergency Alert System (EAS), and NOAA Weather Radio [ 16 ] . IPAWS exchanges alert content using the Common Alerting Protocol (CAP) v1.2, enabling structured, multi-channel delivery and machine-readable metadata [ 1 ] . Since 2018, successive FCC rulemakings have tightened WEA performance requirements: device-based geotargeting must match the target area with no more than approximately 0.1 mile overshoot beyond the polygon, and providers must meet transmission speed and logging requirements [ 2 , 3 ] . Empirically, independent assessments demonstrate strong but nonuniform reach and latency. RAND/HSOAC’s national survey of the Oct. 4, 2023 nationwide test characterizes receipt, opt-in, and demographic patterns [ 4 ] , while McBride et al. measured median delivery latencies on the order of seconds and largely accurate geofences in ShakeAlert-supported trials [ 5 ] . These results motivate client-side resilience—e.g., prefetching, caching, and offline fallback—to hedge against residual gaps from congestion, RF shadowing, or localized outages. 3.2 Offline-first applications Offline-first design patterns let safety-critical apps remain usable under partial connectivity. Local-first software research demonstrates how conflict-free replicated data types and opportunistic synchronization preserve functionality when connectivity is intermittent, providing a foundation for resilient client caches and collaborative state [ 6 ] . In emergency contexts, these findings motivate prefetch of hazard layers, durable storage of prior alerts for auditability, and continuity of core functions during network degradation. 3.3 Caching strategies for emergency systems Network-side caching can reduce tail latency and backhaul dependence during incident-driven traffic spikes. Surveys of mobile edge computing (MEC) detail cache placement and cooperation at the edge to improve hit rates and responsiveness for time-sensitive content [ 7 ] . In Information-/Named-Data Networking (ICN/NDN), systematic surveys cover in-network caching strategies tuned to popularity, mobility, and energy constraints, including IoT deployments that resemble disrupted, ad hoc post-disaster networks [ 8 ] . Recent techniques explore learning-based placement (e.g., bandit/RL hybrids) and hybrid popularity/centrality policies to sustain performance under mobility and intermittent links [ 9 , 28 ] . Beyond hit ratio, "freshness" is a first-order requirement for real-time guidance; system-level treatments frame adaptive TTLs, invalidation, and priority refresh as design knobs that trade staleness against load and reach [ 10 ] . AWARE adopts these lessons with priority-aware eviction and prefetch keyed to hazard severity, temporal sensitivity, and proximity. 3.4 How PriorityFresh relates to prior caching Classical eviction and admission policies primarily optimize for recency/frequency and sometimes object cost/size: LRU/LFU (and spectra like LRFU) and adaptive policies like ARC improve reuse without explicit content semantics; cost-aware policies such as GreedyDual-Size (GDS) incorporate retrieval cost and size into a single eviction score [ 25 , 26 ] . More recent work separates admission from eviction, e.g., TinyLFU filters low-utility items before they pollute the cache [ 11 ] . Parallel threads study freshness and timeliness trade-offs, treating staleness as a controllable resource (e.g., adaptive TTLs, refresh prioritization) for real-time content [ 10 ] . In disrupted or delay-tolerant settings, prioritization has been explored at the message level: DTN protocols like RAPID maximize delivery utility under bandwidth/contact constraints using urgency/deadline-like objectives, with drop/replication policies driven by per-message utility rather than access history [ 27 ] . ICN/NDN literature also includes popularity- or class-based priorities, but typically lacks end-user hazard semantics. PriorityFresh differs in three ways: • Semantic, actionability-first scoring: eviction priority is a weighted, exponentially decayed function of hazard severity, temporal urgency, and freshness—variables tied to protective action rather than access counts or byte cost. Spatial proximity and deduplication are handled by geofencing and push admission/dedup rules, not the core score. • Fixed, transparent weights (no learned boost): unlike learning-based cache policies, PriorityFresh does not consume ML signals; weights are operator-tunable and held fixed for all experiments. • Push coordination under device constraints (optional): when enabled, push admission is treated as a rule-based guard with rate limit and dedup; in reported experiments pushes were disabled. Together, these aspects target the emergency-warning objective directly—maximizing timely presentation of the single most actionable item for a user in place—rather than generic byte-hit or request-hit metrics. 3.5 Location-based emergency services Recent FCC rulemakings now expect polygonal targeting with device-assisted geofencing in WEA, minimizing over-alerting while maintaining high coverage inside the alert area [ 2 , 3 ] . Empirical geofencing studies quantify

Read the complete text