Microscopic model for a granular solid-liquid-like phase transition

Sébastien Aumaître 1,2 , Nicolás Mujica 3 · 2025

Read Microscopic model for a granular solid-liquid-like phase transition by Sébastien Aumaître 1,2 , Nicolás Mujica 3 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-04709.txt.

Introduction

Sébastien Aumaître and his co-author model a granular phase change from the particle level up. Shaken grains in tight spaces can split into solid-like and liquid-like zones. Reports differ on whether that change is sharp or smooth.

In the solid patch, grains move together with the shaking cell, like a collect-and-collide damper. The authors model that patch as one effective particle with zero restitution. Mechanics of that single body then drives the coexistence picture. A microscopic origin story like this helps explain why similar shaken systems show both kinds of transition.

Catalog record

CREATORSébastien Aumaître 1,2 , Nicolás Mujica 3
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE60 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-04709

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Microscopic model for a granular solid-liquid-like phase transition Sébastien Aumaître 1,2 , Nicolás Mujica 3 Abstract Forced granular matter in confined geometries presents phase transitions and coexistence. Depending on the system and forcing parameters, liquid-vapor and liquid-solid co-existing states are possible. For the solid-liquid coexistence that is observed in quasi-two-dimensional vibrated systems, both first- and second-order transitions have been reported. Experiments show that particles in the solid cluster move collectively, synchronized with the cell’s vibration, in a similar way to the collect-and-collide regime observed in granular dampers. Here, we present a model that proposes a microscopic origin of this granular phase transition and co-existence. Imposing synchronicity, we model the solid cluster as an effective particle of zero restitution coefficient. In addition, we use the mechanical equilibrium between the two phases, with an equation of state validated for hard spheres relating the horizontal velocities in each phase. Balancing energy input and dissipation per unit time we obtain a global power equation, which relates the characteristic vertical and horizontal velocities to the microscopic relevant parameters (geometric and dissipation coefficients) as well as to the vibration amplitude and solid cluster’s size. The predictions of the model compare quite well with our experimental results and with the experimental and dynamic simulation results reported elsewhere. I Introduction Granular matter is a prototype of a strongly non-equilibrium system, which can undergo instabilities, pattern formation, phase transitions, coexistence of states, and coarsening RMP96 ; RMP06 ; Baldassarri2015 . A large amount of simple model experiments and simulations have been developed, providing a detailed understanding of basic granular physics, with interest for non-equilibrium statistical mechanics and nonlinear physics. In particular, noncohesive grains that are confined in a vibrated box present liquid-vapor co-existence Argentina2002 ; Khain2002 ; Roeller2011 or liquid-solid state co-existence Olafsen1998 ; Prevost2004 ; Melby2005 ; Clerc2008 ; Castillo2012 ; Castillo2015 , depending on the forcing and dissipative parameters, as well as on the confinement height. Non-equilibrium absorbing phase transitions have also been reported Neel2014 ; Maire2024 . From a macroscopic point of view, both liquid-vapor and solid-liquid granular phase transitions and the coexistence of these states have been understood as consequences of the effective equation of state, which relates the granular pressure to the filling density and the effective temperature. In fact, in both cases, these systems obey a macroscopic van der Waals equation of state Argentina2002 ; Roeller2011 ; Clerc2008 ; Under the appropriate conditions, the compressibility becomes negative and the system is mechanically unstable, the phase separating into a low-density region in mechanical equilibrium with a more dense one. In addition, quite surprisingly, the interface of these noncohesive granular states evidences the existence of an effective surface tension of the order of 1 mN/m, which was measured in simulations by analyzing the Laplace law for the static liquid-vapor interface Clewett2012 and experimentally through capillary-like fluctuations at the solid-liquid interface Luu2013 . Here, we focus on the solid-liquid transition that is observed in quasi-two-dimensional granular systems Prevost2004 ; Melby2005 ; Clerc2008 ; Castillo2012 ; Castillo2015 . A set of N noncohesive spheres of diameter a is confined in a shallow box, of horizontal dimensions L_{x} and L_{y} , and height L_{z}\equiv h . Typically, L_{x}=L_{y}\equiv L\gg a and h\lesssim 2a , such that the particles only partially overlap. The container is vertically vibrated, sinusoidally. At low driving amplitude the granular system is in an homogeneous fluid state. Counterintuitively, by increasing the forcing amplitude A above a critical amplitude A_{c} , a transition to a more ordered state is observed for a fraction of the particles. Then the system phase separates to solid and liquid states, in mechanical equilibrium (see Fig. 1 ). The solid cluster is formed by a bilayer of particles with a crystal-like lattice that nearly fills the gap. The lattice structure can be either hexagonal or square, depending on h/a and filling density Prevost2004 ; Melby2005 . Although this transition shares similarities with usual phase transitions Prevost2004 ; Castillo2012 ; Castillo2015 , the phase space is quite complex, depending on many parameters, as the driving amplitude and frequency, confinement height, particle filling fraction, and the restitution coefficients Prevost2004 ; Melby2005 ; Castillo2012 ; Castillo2015 ; Vega2008 ; Lobkovsky2009 . Figure 1: Typical image of the solid bi-layered square symmetry crystal in coexistence with the liquid phase ( f=80 Hz, h=1.94a , a=1 mm and A=0.24a ). The color circles indicate the degree of order, quantified through the absolute value of the four-bond orientational parameter, |Q_{4}^{j}| . Only the central sector of size L/2\times L/2 is shown. Figure 2: (a) Schematic representation of two square interlaced layers for which particles of diameter a are packed with a mean free path \lambda . The center of particles in the bottom (top) layer are shown with solid (open) black circles. The 2D projected square lattice has a unit cell length (a+\lambda)/\sqrt{2} , its Voronoi area is \beta=(a+\lambda)^{2}/2 . (b) Schematic representation of a side view of two particles in the lowest layer supporting another particle on the top layer. The distance 2(a+\lambda)/\sqrt{2} is twice the unit cell length of the 2D projected square lattice. In this paper, we present a microscopic model based on experimental observations that explains this transition. Due to internal collisions that efficiently dissipate energy, we assume that the solid phase is in a collect-and-collide regime, as evidenced in the study of granular dampers PoschelPRL . Consequently, as a first approximation, the solid cluster can be considered as single large inelastic particle that is synchronized with the driving, with an effective restitution coefficient r_{\rm eff}=0 . Mechanical equilibrium between the two phases and the injected-dissipated power balance are also considered, allowing us to obtain a set of equations relating the system properties, namely the characteristic horizontal and vertical velocities and the solid cluster size. In order to do so, three parameters have to be fixed: the mean free path in the solid phase, the projected 2D disk diameter and the horizontal to vertical velocity anisotropy coefficient in the liquid phase. The values of all these quantities are imposed using experimental data. The model predictions for the critical driving amplitude and cluster size at the onset are compared to the experimental results, showing a good qualitative and semi-quantitative agreement. II Description of the system We consider a set of N hard spheres of diameter a and mass m . Collisions between particles are modeled by a restitution coefficient r^{\prime} ; between particles and the cell walls it is r . Particles are confined to move in a cell of lateral size L in the horizontal direction and of height h , with h<2a in the vertical direction such that the system is quasi-2D. The 2D number density is \rho_{o}=N/L^{2} and the 2D projected surface filling fraction is \phi_{o}=\rho_{o}\pi(a/2)^{2} . The cell is shaken vertically with the forcing z(t)=A\sin(\omega t) . Thus, the driving velocity and acceleration are v(t)=A\omega\cos(\omega t) and a(t)=-A\omega^{2}\sin(\omega t) , respectively. For all the experimental data presented here f=\omega/2\pi=80 Hz. At low driving, but with \Gamma=A\omega^{2}/g>1 , particles move randomly and collide erratically; the system is in a fluid state. Above a given critical amplitude A_{c} the system phase separates: N_{l} particles still move randomly in a liquid state, whereas

Read the complete text