Establishing a pre-logical setting in a quantum model of psychoanalytic theory

Giulia Battilotti, Rosapia Lauro Grotto · 2025

Read Establishing a pre-logical setting in a quantum model of psychoanalytic theory by Giulia Battilotti, Rosapia Lauro Grotto (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-04708.txt.

Introduction

Giulia Battilotti and her co-author set a pre-logical stage inside a quantum model of psychoanalysis. The origin of mental representations troubles both cognitive and analytic theory. Their formal approach draws on Freud, Matte Blanco, Klein, and Bion.

A spin state, written in first-order logic, is abstracted into a modality acting like a projector. That modality splits into positive, negative, and irreal parts. The irreal part cannot surface and is absorbed by the other two in logic. That absorption yields logical duality, modeling how the mind handles undefined content before clear thought forms.

Catalog record

CREATORGiulia Battilotti, Rosapia Lauro Grotto
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-04708

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Establishing a pre-logical setting in a quantum model of psychoanalytic theory Giulia Battilotti, Rosapia Lauro Grotto Abstract A crucial issue both in cognitive and psychoanalytical theories deals with the origin of mental representations. In order to explore this issue, the paper analyzes a pre-logical setting, by considering a formalized approach to the foundations of psychoanalysis in logic, interpreting and integrating the views by Freud, Matte Blanco, Klein and Bion. The formalized approach derives from a quantum model of spin states. A representation of the spin state of a particle in first order logic is abstracted to get a modality interpretable as an abstract projector. The last can be decomposed into a positive, negative and irreal component. The irreal component cannot emerge and, in logic, is absorbed by the two others, giving rise to logical duality. Due to its treatment of undefiniteness and coherence, the paper is meant to contribute to quantum cognition, in its particular sense of affective quantum cognition. Keywords: Affective quantum cognition, psychoanalytic theory, undefiniteness, representation, negation, modal projector, spin observable, pre-logical setting. 1 Introduction The recent development of formal approaches to psychoanalytic theory seems to provide a way to develop a new model of mental processes. This is based on the central idea that it is possible to describe in formal terms the dynamics of representations endowed with affects, which play a central role both in psychoanalytic theory and in cognitive approaches. In fact, psychoanalysis and contemporary cognitive sciences, the latter including both the classic ‘cold’ approach and the contemporary paradigm of embodied and affective cognition, do indeed share a common focus regarding representation and emotion [ 29 ] . The importance of affects in cognitive processes was first stressed long time ago by Vjgotskji, who said that there is an affect behind every thought. Therefore the aim of our multi-disciplinary research is to investigate about a logical basis to develop formal approaches in cognitive studies and their applications, by building on the foundations of psychoanalytic theory, that is the Freudian theory of psychic representations. Then the paper advances a formalized approach to the theoretical foundations of psychoanalysis in logic. In particular, our proposal can support the links of psychoanalysis and Artificial Intelligence, that are gaining an increasing interest, see [ 34 ] . The paper characterizes a pre-logical setting, interpreting and integrating different theoretical views developed in psychoanalysis. Psychoanalysis deals with particular abstract issues of our mind very important in order to understand human thinking: the issues of coherence vs separation, distinguishability vs indistinguishability, definiteness vs undefiniteness. Indeed, the issues are well present in the construction of our thinking, since they are rooted in its unconscious origin. Our analysis is founded on such abstract issues of thinking, and aims at clarifying them, in logical terms. The natural environment in which our proposal is developed is a quantum model, since the quantum world offers a unique model to treat such kind of issues, as widespreadly witnessed by the literature. Actually, in our model, the point is to grasp the concept of quantum state itself. In the paper we adopt a logical representation of quantum states in first order language [ 3 ] , and its successive abstraction by means of modalities [ 6 , 7 ] . The method comes from basic logic [ 35 ] , and consists of defining the logical constants by putting suitable equations which can import the metalinguistic links into sequents. The equations we put allows for an analysis of the modalities that follows from the algebraic splitting of the spin observable into components given by the Pauli matrices. Overall, the infinite/indefinite vs finite features of the modalities are considered and discussed. In order to establish the correspondence between the quantum model and the psychoanalytic model, we first see the correspondence of the representation of quantum states with Freud’s very idea of representation [ 15 ] , namely Freud’s proposal of how the mind creates its own objects. The existence of such a correspondence allows for the extension of the quantum model to successive developments of Freudian theory, proposed by Freud himself [ 16 , 17 , 18 ] , Klein [ 25 ] , Bion [ 10 , 11 ] , Matte Blanco [ 31 , 32 ] , in which the logical/structural aspects of the mind are in evidence. In particular, we adopt as a basis Matte Blanco’s finding that the structural feature of our thinking as originated by the Unconscious relies in the infinite [ 31 ] . His proposal, for us, has been an assist to our goal: to develop a formalized view of the Structural Unconscious, as characterized in The Interpretation of Dreams [ 16 ] . Moreover, the pre-logic we aim to introduce avails of the successive development of the Freudian Second Topic [ 17 ] , in order to introduce the normative element on which logic itself is founded. The discussion of modalities finds a particular correspondence with the seminal paper Negation , published exactly 100 years ago by Freud [ 18 ] . Then, we consider the theory of Object Relations, as introduced by Klein [ 25 ] and developed by Bion in the so-called epistemic trilogy [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] , to analyze how our mind develops psychic representations and hence structures its knowledge. All the formalism is developed consistently with the quantum model. The present proposal continues the previous papers [ 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] . It can be located in the framework of Affective Quantum Cognition. The field of Quantum Cognition [ 33 ] has increasing applications. Its particular aspect of Affective Quantum Cognition, whose theoretical formal basis can be traced back to the pioneering proposal [ 24 ] , see then [ 27 ] and [ 28 ] , and that finds support on Quantum Theories of Consciousness [ 21 ] , is now applied in A.I., see the review paper [ 37 ] . In particular, one could consider the recent application [ 22 ] , that provides a system for simulating and handling affective interactions among various agencies from an understanding of the relations between quantum algorithms and the fundamental nature of psychology. Indeed, the Structural Unconscious, as conceived by Freudian Theory, is like an agent, that is able to carry positive effectiveness into decision processes. This fact has been independently experimentally tested in psychology time ago, [ 13 ] and [ 1 ] , and it is interesting to ask oneself why and how. By analyzing a pre-logical framework able to mediate between the logic of the Unconscious and rational thinking, our work would like to support, in particular, the introduction of this kind of new agent in formal applications to decision making. 2 Coherence conditions In building our pre-logical setting, we aim to meet the view of logic that F.Enriques proposed more than a century ago, in [ 14 ] . In his words 1 1 1 “Riconosciamo, ad ogni modo, che la Logica può riguardarsi come un insieme di norme, le quali debbono osservarsi, se si vuole la coerenza del pensiero. Ma ciò può anche essere espresso dicendo, che: fra i varii procedimenti mentali, se ne distinguono alcuni,

Read the complete text