Constraining gravity with the decay rate of cosmological gravitational potential

Xinyi Zhao, Pengjie Zhang, Fuyu Dong · 2025

Read Constraining gravity with the decay rate of cosmological gravitational potential by Xinyi Zhao, Pengjie Zhang, Fuyu Dong (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-04279.txt.

Introduction

Xinyi Zhao, Pengjie Zhang, and Fuyu Dong use the decay rate of the cosmological gravitational potential to test gravity on cosmic scales. That decay is sensitive to gravity yet largely immune to astrophysical mess, offering a clean way to separate dark energy from modified gravity as the driver of cosmic acceleration.

A recent measurement across a wide redshift range, built from survey galaxies and microwave background maps, is applied to four one-parameter extensions of the standard cosmology. The growth index estimate sits close to the general relativity prediction within its uncertainty. Three effective-gravity parameters likewise land near their standard values. No deviation from Einstein gravity is required by this probe.

Catalog record

CREATORXinyi Zhao, Pengjie Zhang, Fuyu Dong
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE17 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-04279

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Constraining gravity with the decay rate of cosmological gravitational potential Xinyi Zhao, Pengjie Zhang, Fuyu Dong Abstract A key task in cosmology is to test the validity of general relativity (GR) at cosmological scales and, therefore, to distinguish between dark energy and modified gravity (MG) as the driver of the late-time cosmic acceleration. The decay rate ( D ​ R DR ) of cosmological gravitational potential, being sensitive to gravity and being immune to various astrophysical uncertainties, enables GR tests independent to other structure growth probes. Recently we have measured D ​ R DR at 0.2 ≤ z ≤ 1.4 0.2\leq z\leq 1.4 , combining the DR9 galaxy catalog from the DESI imaging surveys and Planck cosmic microwave background maps ( 12 ) . Here we use this measurement to test gravity, and restrict the analysis to one-parameter extensions to the standard Λ \Lambda CDM cosmology. We consider four one-parameter MG parameterizations. One is f ⁡ ( a ) = Ω m γ ​ ( a ) f(a)=\Omega_{m}^{\gamma}(a) . The other three adopt the gravitational slip parameter η = 1 \eta=1 and consider variations in the effective gravitational constant G eff / G G_{\rm eff}/G with the parameterization Σ ⁡ ( a ) = Σ Λ ​ Ω Λ ​ ( a ) / Ω Λ \Sigma(a)=\Sigma_{\Lambda}\Omega_{\Lambda}(a)/\Omega_{\Lambda} , Σ ⁡ ( a ) = Σ 1 ​ a \Sigma(a)=\Sigma_{1}a or Σ ⁡ ( a ) = Σ 2 ​ a 2 \Sigma(a)=\Sigma_{2}a^{2} . We find γ = 0.47 − 0.15 + 0.22 \gamma=0.47^{+0.22}_{-0.15} , consistent with the GR prediction γ ≃ 0.55 \gamma\simeq 0.55 . We also find Σ Λ = 0.018 − 0.053 + 0.052 \Sigma_{\Lambda}=0.018^{+0.052}_{-0.053} , Σ 1 = 0.020 − 0.062 + 0.065 \Sigma_{1}=0.020^{+0.065}_{-0.062} , and Σ 2 = 0.027 − 0.069 + 0.067 \Sigma_{2}=0.027^{+0.067}_{-0.069} , fully consistent with the GR case of Σ = 0 \Sigma=0 , regardless of parameterizations of Σ ⁡ ( a ) \Sigma(a) . The constraining power is already competitive, while a factor of 2 further improvement is expected for the upcoming full-sky galaxy surveys. show][email protected] show][email protected] show][email protected] I Introduction A major challenge of modern cosmology is to understand the physics beneath the late-time cosmic acceleration. The main candidate beyond a non-zero cosmological constant \Lambda is a mysterious dark energy (DE) field. A competing possibility is that general relativity (GR) is invalid at cosmological scales and modified gravity (MG) drives the cosmic acceleration ( 8 ; 19 ; 17 ; 14 ) . Some models of the two possibilities can be distinguished by the expansion rate of the universe, but the rest would require the measurement of structure growth rate to break the degeneracy. There are a variety of probes of structure growth rate such as redshift-space distortions (RSD) and weak gravitational lensing ( 18 ; 34 ) . Among these probes, the integrated Sachs-Wolfe (ISW) ( 29 ) effect is unique in that it directly probes the time variation of the cosmological gravitational potential ( \dot{\psi}+\dot{\phi} ). Here we adopt the Newtonian gauge and a flat geometry, d\tau^{2}=(1+2\psi)dt^{2}-(1-2\phi)\delta_{ij}dx^{i}dx^{j}\ . (1) In the linear regime, \dot{\psi}=\dot{\phi}=0 for an \Omega_{m}=1 flat universe in which GR is valid. Given the strong observational evidences that our universe is flat, a non-vanishing ISW effect at large scale implies either the existence of dark energy or MG. Nonetheless, being a signal overwhelmed by the primary CMB, the measurement of the ISW effect is difficult, and can only be measured through CMB-galaxy (or other tracers) cross-correlations ( 9 ; 23 ; 25 ) . Despite the success of this method, the measured quantity is proportional to the galaxy bias, which weakens its constraining power of cosmology. 37 proposed the combination of ISW-galaxy and CMB lensing-galaxy cross-correlations into a measurement of the decay rate ( DR ) of the gravitational potential. 11 made the first DR measurement at 0.2\leq z<0.8 combining DESI imaging surveys and Planck. 12 further extended the measurement to z\leq 1.2 . To constrain cosmology, DR has two advantages. Besides the interested DE and MG parameters, it only depends on the cosmological matter density \Omega_{m} . It does not depend on parameters such as H_{0} , the sound horizon at the drag epoch r_{\rm d} , \sigma_{8} and n_{s} . The other advantage is that, its response to DE parameters is much stronger than quantities such as H(z) and D_{M}(z) ( 11 ) . Therefore despite the relatively low S/N \sim 3 , DR improved over the SDSS dark energy constraint by 30\% and the Pantheon dark energy constraint by 40\% ( 11 ) . Being a structure growth probe, the constraining power of DR on MG is expected to be more impressive. Therefore in this work we explore its constraints on MG. The paper is organized as follows. § II introduces DR and the data sets. § III presents the MG models adopted in our analysis and the parameter constraints from DR . We discuss and conclude in § IV . Galaxy redshift N_{g} DR 0.2<z^{P}<0.4(z_{m}\simeq 0.31) 0.65\times 10^{6} 0.047^{+0.066}_{-0.057} 0.4<z^{P}<0.6(z_{m}\simeq 0.51) 1.32\times 10^{6} 0.114^{+0.072}_{-0.063} 0.6<z^{P}<0.8(z_{m}\simeq 0.70) 2.47\times 10^{6} 0.068^{+0.087}_{-0.060} 0.8<z^{P}<1.0(z_{m}\simeq 0.91) 4.85\times 10^{6} 0.105^{+0.087}_{-0.084} 1.0<z^{P}<1.2(z_{m}\simeq 1.09) 3.87\times 10^{6} 0.165^{+0.099}_{-0.103} 1.2<z^{P}<1.4(z_{m}\simeq 1.28) 1.33\times 10^{6} 0.086^{+0.081}_{-0.081} Table 1: The measured DR ( 12 ) . The galaxy samples are selected from DESI imaging survey DR9. II The Decay Rate ( DR ) measurement The concept of DR is straightforward. The ISW effect \propto\dot{\psi}+\dot{\phi} , while weak lensing \propto\nabla^{2}(\psi+\phi) . Therefore combining the ISW-galaxy cross-correlation and the weak lensing-galaxy cross-correlation, we are able to measure the following combination ( 37 ) , DR(z)=\left(-\frac{d{\rm ln}D_{\psi+\phi}}{d{\rm ln}a}\right)\left(\frac{aH(z)/c}{W_{L}(z)}\right)\ . (2) Here W_{L}(z)=[1-\chi(z)/\chi(z_{s})]/\chi(z) is the lensing kernel, and \chi(z) is the comoving radial distance to redshift z . z_{s} is the source redshift. In the case of CMB lensing, z_{s}\simeq 1100 . D_{\psi+\phi} is the linear growth factor of the (Weyl) potential. From the definition, DR is independent of galaxy bias, the matter clustering amplitude and slope, and the Hubble constant H_{0} . Hence DR is significantly more sensitive to the nature of dark energy and gravity than other probes, in case of identical measurement precision ( 11 ) . DR measured using DESI imaging surveys DR9 and Planck is listed in Table 1 ( 12 ) . In order to construct a volume-limited sample, galaxies are further selected from the DECaLS+DES region with z-band absolute magnitude brighter than -22. To mitigate imaging systematics in \delta_{g} , each galaxy is assigned with a weight derived from a machine learning method ( 35 ) . Furthermore, the magnification bias was mitigated using various methods. The total significance of the DR measurements is 3.1\sigma . Due to the built-in sensitivity of DR to gravity, we will show that even a 3\sigma measurement delivers competitive constraints on MG. Figure 1: Constraint on the \gamma parameter using DR . The shaded areas indicate the 68\% confidence region. \gamma=0.47_{-0.15}^{+0.22} , consistent with the GR value of \gamma\simeq 0.55 . III Constraints on Modified Gravity To test MG, we restrict our analysis to one-parameter extension to the flat \Lambda CDM cosmology. Within this setup, DR depends only on \Omega_{m} , other than the gravity parameters. \Omega_{m} has been measured to high precision using probes of the expansion

Read the complete text