Unifying contextual advantages in state discrimination

Kieran Flatt, Joonwoo Bae · 2025

Read Unifying contextual advantages in state discrimination by Kieran Flatt, Joonwoo Bae (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-04100.txt.

Introduction

Kieran Flatt and Joonwoo Bae study contextual advantages in telling two quantum states apart, a task now also used to witness general contextuality. Catalog evidence carried a different title about unifying advantages; the arXiv record gives the title used here, and that record governs the framing.

Noncontextuality inequalities are derived for conclusive and inconclusive outcomes across guessing strategies. For minimum-error discrimination the advantage appears in outcome confidences, while for clear-cut discrimination it appears in average guessing probability. Maximum-confidence guessing shows edges in confidence, guessing rate, and inconclusive rate alike. Contextual edges, the pair conclude, appear across every two-state scheme and measure examined.

Catalog record

CREATORKieran Flatt, Joonwoo Bae
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE37 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-04100

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Unifying contextual advantages in state discrimination Kieran Flatt, Joonwoo Bae Abstract Quantum state discrimination, alongside its other applications, has recently found use as a tool for witnessing generalised contextuality. In this article, we derive noncontextuality inequalities for both conclusive and inconclusive outcomes across various guessing strategies. For minimum-error discrimination, the advantage is in terms of the confidences of individual outcomes, while for unambiguous state discrimination, it is in terms of the average guessing probability. For maximum-confidence discrimination, we show that contextual advantages occur not only for the confidence but also their average, the guessing probability, as well as the inconclusive outcome rate. Our results unify the contextual advantages across all state discrimination schemes and figures of merit. We envisage that various quantum information applications based on state discrimination may offer advantages over non-contextual theories. I Introduction If gaps exist between the behaviour of classical and quantum systems, it is possible to take advantage of the differences for enhanced information processing. Contextuality, which tells us that measurements do not merely reveal pre-existing features of quantum states, has long been considered one such distinguishing feature. Despite this, it proved difficult for a long to know how to use this property for practical applications. This was in part due to the fact that non-projective measurements, which are required in realistic, noisy scenarios, were difficult to describe in the original framework of Kochen-Spekker contextuality. For this reason, amongst others, a generalised form of contextuality was later put forward 23 . Taking contextuality as a defining feature of quantum theory implies a natural definition of classicality as the set of statistics which can be generated by theories lacking this property. With this in mind, recent work in the field of generalised contextuality has provided a series of noncontextual inequalities 21 ; 15 . These consist of proofs that the upper bound of a given operationally meaningful quantity is lower in theories lacking contextuality compared with the equivalent quantum figure of merit. Of particular importance here, as a fundamental communication primitive, is state discrimination 1 ; 3 ; 2 . It was first shown that quantum advantages may be witnessed in the setting of minimum-error state discrimination (MESD) 22 and subsequent works generalised this to aspects of unambiguous state discrimination (USD) and maximum confidence measurements (MCMs). 8 ; 20 . Our aim in this paper is to complete this picture. We show that the ability to witness quantum advantages is universal across all forms of state discrimination, and in all measures of success. Demonstrations of quantum advantage take one of two approaches. On the one hand, one can propose a measure of the average performance of a given task and then show that quantum implementations can attain a higher value than classical ones. The relevant notion of classicality in this case will be statistics that can be realised in non-contextual theories. In contrast, one can consider deterministic phenomena that can be witnessed in a single-shot scenario. The proof of the PBR theorem 19 , for example, follows an analogous procedure by showing the existence of a task which can be performed perfectly in \psi -epistemic models but not in quantum theory 14 . State discrimination, the problem of determining by measurement which state, taken from some ensemble, was prepared, allows one to witness both forms of advantage. MESD is concerned with the success probability observed on average over a run of experiments. USD and MCM, on the other hand, are concerned with inferring preparations from a single detection event, as what one learns does not depend on averaged data. More generally, we may also ask about the single-shot properties of the former scheme as well as the averaged properties of the latter two. In order to do this, we note that the three different schemes may each be analysed according to three distinct figures of merit: the average probability of a correct detection event, the probability of conclusive measurement events, and the retrodictive confidence that a state was prepared given a measurement outcome. Optimisation of these three quantities gives arise to MESD, USD and MCM respectively. Less often noted is that the remaining figures of merit also play a role in each scenario. In this work, we show that they are also witnesses of contextuality. We show that, for MESD, the confidences of each individual outcome give rise to an associated contextual advantage. The same is true for the average guessing probability of USD. We also investigate the average guessing probability and inconclusive outcome rate of an MCM and derive further noncontextual inequalities. We begin by summarising both what is known so far and what the precise contributions are of this article. After reminding the reader of relevant background information, we then proceed with our main results: demonstrations that the confidences in MESD as well as the average success rates in USD and MCMs give rise to contextual inequalities. We close with remarks on the relevancy of these results to realistic experiments and applications. II Summary of results Let us briefly summarise what is known so far as well as the contributions of this article. State discrimination tasks, reviewed in more detail in the next section, are characterised by three basic figures of merit: the average guessing probability {\rm P}_{g} , the inconclusive outcome rate {\rm P}_{0} and the set confidences {\rm C}(i) associated with measurement outcomes. These quantities can be associated with each of the three main versions of state discrimination: minimum error, unambiguous and maximum confidence. One also considers the resulting values of these quantities given optimisation of another. Scheme Overview Contextual advantages Optimisation Inc. Outcome? All ensembles? P_{g} P_{0} C(i) [1pt] MESD \max P_{g} ✗ ✓ Ref. 22 0 This work USD \min P_{0} ✓ ✗ This work Ref. 8 1 MCM \max{\rm C}(i)\,\forall\,i ✓ ✓ This work This work Ref. 8 Table 1: Three schemes may be used to implement quantum state discrimination. In this table, we display firstly the basic properties defining them. In the last three columns, we summarise the contextual advantages associated with each scheme. Cells containing citations were previously shown; cells containing numbers are definitional; cells stating ‘Here’ are shown in the current work. Table 1 displays the various figures of merit which may be associated with each scheme. An advantage for the minimum error guessing probability was shown in Ref. 22 , and advantages for the maximum confidences and the inconclusive outcome rate were shown in Ref. 8 . We show, in the current article, the results for the remaining cases. III Background III.1 State discrimination Any state discrimination task 1 ; 2 ; 3 is characterised by a finite, discrete ensemble \{q_{i},\rho_{i}\}_{i=1}^{N} of N quantum states \rho_{i} each prepared with a probability q_{i} . The average state produced will be \rho=\sum_{i}^{N}q_{i}\rho_{i} . One party, Alice, prepares a system in one of the states and then passes it on to a receiver, Bob. Bob’s task is to determine the state using measurements, represented by a positive-operator-valued-measure (POVM) \{\pi_{j}\} , such that 0\leq\pi_{i}\leq 1 and \sum_{j}\pi_{j}=\mathbf{1} , in which the outcomes are are associated with either a given state or an inconclusive detection. This set-up is displayed in Figure 1 . Bob will design his measurement to be

Read the complete text