Scalar superradiance in the charged black-bounce spacetimes

Zhiming Shuai, Xiangdong Zhang, Gui-Rong Liang · 2025

Read Scalar superradiance in the charged black-bounce spacetimes by Zhiming Shuai, Xiangdong Zhang, Gui-Rong Liang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-04007.txt.

Introduction

Zhiming Shuai, Xiangdong Zhang, and Gui-Rong Liang numerically study superradiance of a charged scalar field around charged black-bounce spacetimes. They cover both scattering setups and black hole bomb models, where a mirror traps amplified waves. A quantum parameter in the geometry shallows the effective potential.

That shallowing weakens superradiant amplification in both settings. Field mass suppresses gains at all frequencies, while black hole and field charge suppress low frequencies yet enhance high ones. In one bomb arrangement a distinct new eigenmode appears at large quantum parameter values, absent in a second arrangement. Heavy-field cases add another eigenfrequency at the same setting, without superradiant amplification.

Catalog record

CREATORZhiming Shuai, Xiangdong Zhang, Gui-Rong Liang
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-04007

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Scalar superradiance in the charged black-bounce spacetimes Zhiming Shuai, Xiangdong Zhang, Gui-Rong Liang Abstract We numerically investigate the superradiant amplification effect of a charged scalar filed in the scattering experiment and the black hole bomb model in a charged black-bounce spacetime. Due to the shallowing effect on the effective potential by the introduced quantum parameter λ {\lambda} , superradiance in both the above cases are verified to be weakened. In a scattering experiment, the quantum parameter and the field mass suppress the amplification in all frequency ranges, while the black hole and field charge influence it differently in high and low frequencies. In a Type I black hole bomb model, where the reflective mirror is placed outside the ergo-region, we find a new distinct eigen-mode for the scalar field evolution in a high λ {\lambda} value, which is however absent in the case of Type II black bomb where the mirror is set inside the ergo-region. Moreover, we investigate the heavy field mass scenario in a Type II black hole bomb and find no amplification effect in this confined configuration. I Introduction The phenomenon of superradiance exhibits wave amplification of fields in a thermodynamic system, with the cost of dissipation in a “viscous medium”. The first example was given by the so called “Klein paradox” Klein:1929aa ; Sauter:1931aa , in which charged bosons get energy enhancement when scattered by a potential barrier where particle-antiparticle pair creations are excited Brito_2020 ; the antiparticles with negative energy were injected into the barrier and particles with positive energy joint into the original particle beam and reflected. Energy conservation is kept and necessary during the process. Fermions does not possess such amplification due to the positive definiteness of its energy current density, in the quantum field point of view, it is Pauli exclusion principle that limits numbers of pair productions MANOGUE1988261 to form a macroscopic negative current. In curved spacetime, superradiance can also occur in vacuum Brito_2020 ; especially in black hole (BH) physics, the existence of the event horizon render the BH behave as a “viscous one-way membrane”, such that an intrinsic dissipative region is provided in the form of an ergoregion, where timelike particles can have negative energies with respect to infinite observers. In Penrose thought experiment Penrose:1969pc , particle splitting take place in a similar manner, however in a classical sense, with that of pair creation in Klein paradox, such that energy of BHs is extracted, which happens both in rotation and charged static background. The wave analogue comes parallel in the low-frequency regime, followed by quantitative analysis in pioneering works in Kerr Teukolsky:1974yv ; Press:1972zz and Reissner-Nordström (RN) Denardo:1973pyo spacetimes. The ergoregion is intrinsic in rotating case, but an effective description in charged static case where it includes both information of the curvature and properties of the field, e.g., mass and charge, and may even cover the whole exterior of the black hole Laurent_Di_Menza_2015 . Superradiant instabilities occur in the sense that the process can be carried repeatedly, when a reflective mechanism is provided in a distant region to bounce the amplified wave back again. In the rotation case, the mass of the bosonic field itself serves as a natural mirror to bound the condensing cloud, while asymptotically-flat charged BHs were shown to be stable against massive charged scalar perturbations HOD2012505 ; HOD20131489 , hence a reflective boundary must be imposed in a toy model, to make a so-called “black hole bomb” PRESS:1972aa . In contrast to the astronomical relevance in the rotating case East_2017 ; Endlich_2017 ; Dolan_2013 ; Jia:2023see ; PhysRevLett.119.041101 ; PhysRevD.76.084001 ; HUANG2019135026 ; Franzin_2021 ; Khodadi_2021 ; Huang_2019 ; Kobayashi_2010 ; LI2023137902 , the increasing investigations on superradiance in charged static system Mascher_2022 ; Benone_2014 ; Benone_2016 ; Zhu_2014 ; Konoplya:2014lha ; Di_Menza_2020 ; PhysRevLett.116.141101 ; Herdeiro:2013pia ; Degollado_2013 makes it more interesting from a conceptual point of view: Its remarkably short instability time scale makes it an ideal testbed for fully nonlinear studies of black hole instabilities within cavities, in Sanchis-Gual:2016aa ; Sanchis-Gual:2016ab , the researchers employ an asymptotically flat, spherically symmetric spacetime with a boundary at a fixed coordinate distance where the charged scalar field adheres to Dirichlet conditions. This framework permits tracking the linearized instability into the nonlinear regime, with substantial evidence indicating a final entropically preferred state where a black hole is surrounded by a charged condensate Dolan:2015aa . Moreover, the occurrence of superradiance in static charged black holes plays a vital role in enabling diverse applications within the gauge/gravity duality framework. Notable examples include the mechanism of spontaneous symmetry breaking in the vicinity of a Reissner-Nordström anti-de Sitter (RN-AdS) black hole Gubser:2008aa , as well as associated developments in holographic superconductor models Hartnoll:2008aa . Research on charged black hole bombs has progressed through both analytical treatment Hod_2013 ; Li:2015ab , and numerical approaches in which the behaviors were examined at the linear field amplitude level in both frequency and time-domain Degollado:2013aa ; Degollado:2014aa ; Dias_2018 . Generalizations were carried for a charged massless scalar field in the spacetime of a charged stringy black hole with mirror-like boundary conditions Li:2015aa ; LI2015520 , and in the context of massive charged scalar fields on a Kerr-Newman background 10.1143/PTP.112.983 , which confirms even in the rotation-dominated regime the instability growth rate depends on the coupling between the field charge and the black hole charge. On the other hand, it is widely believed that quantum gravity effects would remove the curvature singularity of a black hole and result a regular/non-singler black hole Ashtekar:2023cod . However, since a complete theory of quantum gravity is not yet well established, investigations on various non-singular black holes at the phenomenological level were extensively carried. Although these models are usually not any solutions to the vacuum Einstein equation, one can fix the logic by introducing some exotic matter field on the right hand side of the equation. Regular black holes can be traced back to the well known Bardeen black hole Bardeen , Hayward black hole Hayward as well as other notable regular black hole models Frolov ; Ay_n_Beato_1998 ; Fan_2016 ; Ghosh_2021 . The properties of regular black holes were studied with the purpose of revealing the internal structure of black holes and capturing the signals due to the possible quantum gravity effect. In recent years, investigations on the superradiant effect and black hole bomb instability of different types of regular black holes were carried increasingly dolan_charged ; paula_absorption ; Yang_2023 ; Zhan_2024gvi ; Li_zhen ; Franzin , which provided interesting insights in understanding the interplay between fundamental and phenomenological aspects. In this paper, we investigate the superradiant effects in a spherically symmetric charged black-bounce spacetime Franzin_bbrn ; GUO2022115938 , which allows a special class of regular black holes and wormhole solutions in a smooth parameter tuning. The metric could be achieved by a radial coordinate transformation r\to\sqrt{r^{2}+\lambda^{2}} , with \lambda a length scale parameter representing quantum regularization, to deform the classical Reissner-Nordström (RN) metric to the black-bounce-RN geometry Simpson_2019 ; Simpson_vaidya ; Lobo_2020 ; Lobo_2021 ; Mazza_2021 . The introduced parameter is typically associated with the Planck length, which smooths the central singularity while preserving asymptotic RN behavior. The model provides a phenomenological framework to probe how

Read the complete text