Ultra-Diffuse, Ultra-Different: Observed vs. Simulated Ultra-Diffuse Galaxies Live in Fundamentally Different Halos 2026 Ultra-Diffuse, Ultra-Different: Observed vs. Simulated Ultra-Diffuse Galaxies Live in Fundamentally Different Halos – References

Jonah S. Gannon, Arianna Di Cintio, Duncan A. Forbes, Guacimara García-Bethencourt, Jean P Brodie, Noam Libeskind, Warrick J. Couch, Johanna Hartke · 2025

Read Ultra-Diffuse, Ultra-Different: Observed vs. Simulated Ultra-Diffuse Galaxies Live in Fundamentally Different Halos 2026 Ultra-Diffuse, Ultra-Different: Observed vs. Simulated Ultra-Diffuse Galaxies Live in Fundamentally Different Halos – References by Jonah S. Gannon, Arianna Di Cintio, Duncan A. Forbes, Guacimara García-Bethencourt, Jean P Brodie, Noam Libeskind, Warrick J. Couch, Johanna Hartke (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-04006.txt.

Introduction

Jonah S Gannon is the lead author among eight authors comparing observed ultra-diffuse galaxies with simulated ones from the NIHAO and HESTIA suites. For each observed galaxy with a spectroscopic dynamical mass, the team pick the simulated halo that best matches that inner mass, then compare stellar and total halo masses.

Matched simulated galaxies carry lower stellar masses than observed, and their halos fall below what the stellar mass-halo mass relation expects. Globular cluster counts instead imply observed systems live in fairly massive halos. Simulations reproduce inner dynamics but not those massive halos, a striking tension. The authors weigh observational and theoretical fixes and favour a fundamental difference in how observed systems formed.

Catalog record

CREATORJonah S. Gannon, Arianna Di Cintio, Duncan A. Forbes, Guacimara García-Bethencourt, Jean P Brodie, Noam Libeskind, Warrick J. Couch, Johanna Hartke
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-04006

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Ultra-Diffuse, Ultra-Different: Observed vs. Simulated Ultra-Diffuse Galaxies Live in Fundamentally Different Halos 2026 Ultra-Diffuse, Ultra-Different: Observed vs. Simulated Ultra-Diffuse Galaxies Live in Fundamentally Different Halos – References Jonah S. Gannon, Arianna Di Cintio, Duncan A. Forbes, Guacimara García-Bethencourt, Jean P Brodie, Noam Libeskind, Warrick J. Couch, Johanna Hartke Abstract In this work, we compare galaxies from the NIHAO and HESTIA simulation suites to ultra-diffuse galaxies (UDGs) with spectroscopically measured dynamical masses. For each observed UDG, we identify the simulated dark matter halo that best matches its dynamical mass. In general, observed UDGs are matched to simulated galaxies with lower stellar masses than they are observed to have. These simulated galaxies also have halo masses much less than would be expected given the observed UDG’s stellar mass and the stellar mass – halo mass relationship. We use the recently established relation between globular cluster (GC) number and halo mass, which has been shown to be applicable to UDGs, to better constrain their observed halo masses. This method indicates that observed UDGs reside in relatively massive dark matter halos. This creates a striking discrepancy: the simulated UDGs are matched to the dynamical masses of observed ones, but not their total halo masses. In other words, simulations can produce UDGs in halos with the correct inner dynamics, but not with the massive halos implied by GC counts. We explore several possible explanations for this tension, from both the observational and theoretical sides. We propose that the most likely resolution is that observed UDGs may have fundamentally different dark matter halo profiles than those produced in NIHAO and HESTIA. This highlights the need for a simulation that self-consistently produces galaxies of a stellar mass of ∼ 10 8 ​ M ⊙ \sim 10^{8}M_{\odot} in dark matter halos that exhibit the full range of large dark matter cores to cuspy NFW-like halos. 1 Introduction UDGs are characterised by low surface brightness and large size. In particular, 92 assigned a working definition of central g band \mu \geq 24 mag. arcsec -2 and effective radius R e \geq 1.5 kpc. This corresponds to dwarf galaxy-like stellar masses. These selection criteria are continuous, rather than discrete, from known galaxies with slightly higher surface brightness and smaller sizes. Galaxies that nudge up against the UDG criteria have been referred to as NUDGes ( 30 ) . There is no doubt that there are many different evolutionary pathways for a galaxy to occupy the parameter space assigned to UDGs (see e.g., 27 ; 9 ). Perhaps more interesting is when the properties of UDGs are extreme when compared to dwarf galaxies of a similar stellar mass. These properties include their globular cluster (GC) systems and their halo masses. Several studies have found high GC numbers (or system mass) to stellar mass ratios ( 90 ; 56 ; 28 ; 19 ; 74 ) . Halo masses are very difficult to measure directly, with only one UDG, DF44, having a halo mass estimate available based on its radially-extended kinematics. In this case a massive halo, for its stellar mass, was indicated. However, as with most mass modelling, the halo mass is subject to caveats on the shape of the mass profile and orbital anisotropy ( 93 ; 97 ) . 30 derived the halo mass for UDGs with more than 20 GCs using two different methods. The first method used the empirical scaling between GC count and halo mass ( 7 ) . The second method estimated the total halo mass based on the enclosed dynamical mass derived from measured velocity dispersions. The latter method required an assumption of a mass profile. Here they explored both an NFW cusp ( 68 ) and a core (e.g., 72 ). The core was further assumed to be ‘maximal’ and equal to 2.75 times the observed half-light radius following 72 . The relation between halo concentration and halo mass of 23 was also followed. 30 concluded that halo masses derived from cored mass profiles were in better agreement with GC-inferred halo masses than cusp profiles. The halo masses inferred for these GC-rich UDGs were over-massive compared to standard stellar mass–halo relations (SMHRs), suggesting that such galaxies had failed to form stars in the expected amount. These ‘failed galaxies’ appear to challenge standard models of galaxy formation. We note however that the initial idea of ‘Failed L_{*} galaxies’ ( 92 ) has been largely rejected, as the halo masses of the galaxies do not reach into the L_{*} regime, despite being larger than is standard for a dwarf ( 81 ; 36 ) . Dwarf galaxies of a similar stellar mass with high halo masses have also been dubbed ‘baryon deficient’ ( 58 ) . The approach of 30 required various assumptions to infer the halo masses, including the unknown size of the core and the halo concentration parameter. An alternative approach is to use UDG models generated from cosmological simulations. This has the advantage that the galaxy properties are ‘built-in’ based on the physics included in the simulations. Comparisons to these simulations can then help test the model of the physics included. Galaxies matching the UDG criteria have naturally arisen in various simulations (e.g., NIHAO; 20 ; 46 ; 11 ; 10 , HESTIA; 69 , FIRE; 13 , the Illustris Suite; 12 ; 76 ; 22 ; 4 ; 3 , Romulus; 87 ; 102 and MAGNETICUM; Gannon et al. Submitted, to name a few). These simulations span the full range of environments from the low-density field to massive, dense galaxy clusters. Indeed, many simulations have been found to reproduce the dynamical masses of UDGs, which has been presented as evidence that they are producing realistic UDGs ( 20 ; 13 ) . Further research has been conducted contrasting simulations and the full range of UDG properties, for example, galaxy sizes and HI content ( 20 ) , and their radial distribution within the Local Group ( 69 ) . However, these studies are typically conducted at the population level, rather than through direct galaxy-by-galaxy comparisons between simulations and observations. Moreover, only recently has it become possible to perform detailed studies involving resolved observational quantities, such as stellar populations and metallicity gradients (e.g., 47 ; 27 ; 10 ; 94 ). Figure 1: Dynamical mass enclosed within a radius vs that radius. Red points are observed UDGs with markers corresponding to their being in a field (triangle), group (squares) or cluster (circles) environment. On the left we compare the observed dynamical masses to mass profiles from the NIHAO simulation, and on the right we compare the observed dynamical masses to mass profiles obtained from the HESTIA simulation. For both simulations, their mass profiles are colour-coded by their total halo mass, and we do not limit the plotted halos to just those that contain UDGs. For both simulations, we exclude any gas mass when plotting, as the observed UDGs are largely gas-free. UDGs are matched to the halo that best matches their observed dynamical mass for comparison in Figure 2 . It is of note that while many UDG dynamical masses prefer massive halos ( >10^{11}~M_{\odot} ), none reside in halos as massive as the Milky Way ( \sim 10^{12}~M_{\odot} ). In this

Read the complete text