Vortex-Controlled Quasiparticle Multiplication and Self-Growth Dynamics in Superconducting Resonators
Joong M. Park 1 , Martin Mootz 1 , Richard H. J. Kim 1 , Zhixiang Chong 1,2 , Samuel Haeuser 1,2 , Randall K. Chan 1,2 , Liang Luo 1 , Dominic P. Goronzy 3 , Mark C. Hersam 3,4,5 , Ilias E. Perakis 6 , Akshay A Murthy 7 , Alexander Romanenko 7 , Anna Grassellino 7 , and Jigang Wang 1,2 · 2025
Read Vortex-Controlled Quasiparticle Multiplication and Self-Growth Dynamics in Superconducting Resonators by Joong M. Park 1 , Martin Mootz 1 , Richard H. J. Kim 1 , Zhixiang Chong 1,2 , Samuel Haeuser 1,2 , Randall K. Chan 1,2 , Liang Luo 1 , Dominic P. Goronzy 3 , Mark C. Hersam 3,4,5 , Ilias E. Perakis 6 , Akshay A Murthy 7 , Alexander Romanenko 7 , Anna Grassellino 7 , and Jigang Wang 1,2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-03853.txt.
Introduction
Joong M Park is the lead author among fourteen authors reporting direct evidence that vortices in superconductors can multiply quasiparticles, the broken-pair excitations that spoil quantum states in transmon qubits. A fast quasiparticle relaxing inside a vortex core can break more Cooper pairs, because the excitation gap there is reduced and confinement is stronger.
Using femtosecond magneto-reflection spectroscopy at low excitation levels, the team watched quasiparticle numbers keep rising before the usual phonon bottleneck. The growth depended strongly on magnetic-field-tuned vortex density and vanished at higher fluence. Estimated density rose by about thirty-four percent at the highest vortex densities studied. The finding names a concrete poisoning route circuit designers must manage.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Joong M. Park 1 , Martin Mootz 1 , Richard H. J. Kim 1 , Zhixiang Chong 1,2 , Samuel Haeuser 1,2 , Randall K. Chan 1,2 , Liang Luo 1 , Dominic P. Goronzy 3 , Mark C. Hersam 3,4,5 , Ilias E. Perakis 6 , Akshay A Murthy 7 , Alexander Romanenko 7 , Anna Grassellino 7 , and Jigang Wang 1,2 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-03853
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Vortex-Controlled Quasiparticle Multiplication and Self-Growth Dynamics in Superconducting Resonators Joong M. Park 1 , Martin Mootz 1 , Richard H. J. Kim 1 , Zhixiang Chong 1,2 , Samuel Haeuser 1,2 , Randall K. Chan 1,2 , Liang Luo 1 , Dominic P. Goronzy 3 , Mark C. Hersam 3,4,5 , Ilias E. Perakis 6 , Akshay A Murthy 7 , Alexander Romanenko 7 , Anna Grassellino 7 , and Jigang Wang 1,2 Abstract Even in the quantum limit, non-equilibrium quasiparticle (QP) populations induce QP poisoning that irreversibly relaxes the quantum state and significantly degrades the coherence of transmon qubits. A particularly detrimental yet previously unexplored mechanism arises from QP multiplication facilitated by vortex trapping in superconducting quantum circuits, where a high-energy QP relaxes by breaking additional Cooper pairs and amplifying the QP population due to the locally reduced excitation gap and enhanced quantum confinement within the vortex core. Here we directly resolve this elusive QP multiplication process by revealing vortex-controlled QP self-generation in a highly nonequilibrium regime preceding the phonon bottleneck of QP relaxation. At sufficiently low fluence, femtosecond-resolved magneto-reflection spectroscopy directly reveals a continuously increasing QP population that is strongly dependent on magnetic-field-tuned vortex density and absent at higher excitation fluences. Quantitative analysis of the emergent QP pre-bottleneck dynamics further reveals that, although the phonon population saturates within ≃ \simeq 10 ps, both free and trapped QPs continue to grow in a self-sustained manner–hallmarks of the long-anticipated QP-vortex interactions in nonequilibrium superconductivity. We estimate a substantial increase of ∼ \sim 34% in QP density at vortex densities of ∼ \sim 100 magnetic flux quanta per μ m 2 \mathrm{\mu m^{2}} . Our findings establish a powerful spectroscopic tool for uncovering QP multiplication and reveal vortex-assisted QP relaxation as a critical materials bottleneck whose mitigation will be essential for resolving QP poisoning and enhancing coherence in superconducting qubits. I Introduction Carrier multiplication constitutes a unifying mechanism across diverse quantum materials, encompassing multiple-exciton generation in quantum dots, impact ionization in semiconductors, and carrier-carrier multiplication in photovoltaic absorbers 25 ; 5 . The superconducting analogue–QP multiplication–represents a strongly nonequilibrium relaxation channel detrimental to maintaining coherence, wherein a single high-energy QP decays by breaking additional Cooper pairs and generating multiple lower-energy QPs that collectively amplify the QP population even at the millikelvin temperatures relevant to qubit operation. QP multiplication is expected to be particularly efficient near vortex cores, where the locally suppressed superconducting gap and strong quantum confinement create a unique nanoscale environment that amplifies electronic interactions and promotes QP generation without involving hot phonons. To date, however, no experiment has directly resolved vortex-dependent QP multiplication and its self-sustained dynamics. The central challenge is achieving experimental access to the femtosecond-resolved QP trapping, relaxation, and phonon-coupling dynamics that govern nonequilibrium superconducting vortex states. Understanding these processes is vital for mitigating QP poisoning and thereby advancing coherence in superconducting circuits 4 ; 28 . Under nonequilibrium conditions, the conventional understanding of light-induced QP kinetics in superconductors 38 ; 9 ; 26 ; 36 and microelectronic devices 33 has focused primarily on their interactions with hot phonons. As illustrated in Fig. 1(a), a key process is the phonon bottleneck effect, where QP recombination into Cooper pairs generates high-energy phonons that, in turn, break additional Cooper pairs. This feedback loop delays net recombination and sustains nonequilibrium QP populations over extended timescales. The Rothwarf–Taylor (R-T) model has captured this phonon bottleneck regime of nonequilibrium QP dynamics and hot phonons in superconductors 23 ; 22 ; 8 . Yet, the pre-bottleneck regime –preceding the onset of the quasi-equilibrium state–remains far less understood. This early regime is characterized by highly nonthermal QP distributions 37 , quantum coherence 11 ; 17 ; 31 ; 35 , and transient many-body dynamics 9 that can critically influence the subsequent relaxation pathways 13 ; 14 . In particular, direct interactions between QPs and vortices can trigger QP multiplication even without changes in the phonon population, underscoring the need to advance both experiment and theory on vortex-state dynamics beyond the conventional hot-phonon framework of superconducting nonequilibrium kinetics. Figure 1: (a) Schematic illustration of quasiparticle (QP) generation and recombination processes in the nonequilibrium superconducting (SC) state without vortices. Here, q denotes the QP density and p denotes the phonon density; q_{T} and p_{T} indicate their respective thermal equilibrium values. (b) Schematic illustration of quasiparticle trapping by a single magnetic vortex in the SC state. The dynamics are governed by the detailed balance among trapped QPs ( q_{t} ), free QPs ( q_{f} ), and phonon population ( p ) (main text). Here, \Gamma denotes the vortex-induced QP trapping rate, while \eta represents the QP detrapping rate. (c) Magnetic force microscopy (MFM) image of vortices in a Nb thin film under \pm 3 mT magnetic fields. Each spot corresponds to a single magnetic vortex. Scale bar is 1 \mu m. A particularly compelling, yet under-explored, aspect of the QP dynamics arises in the mixed state of type-II superconductors, where magnetic flux penetrates the material as quantized vortices. As illustrated in Fig. 1(b), each vortex comprises of a normal state core–a region where the SC gap vanishes–embedded in a surrounding SC matrix. These cores serve as nanoscale traps for QPs and host low-energy bound states, acting effectively as artificial quantum dots supporting discrete energy levels within the SC gap 29 ; 19 . This produces a highly inhomogeneous landscape for energy relaxation, QP localization, and dynamical regeneration. However, the hallmark signatures of vortex-mediated QP dynamics have so far remained unobserved, primarily because of the lack of measurement access to femtosecond-scale, highly nonequilibrium and nonthermal QP responses in vortex states of superconducting systems. Concurrently, in superconducting quantum devices, two-level systems (TLSs) and their fluctuation dominate microwave dissipation at sub-kelvin temperatures and MHz frequencies 30 ; 24 , whereas QP-induced losses, i. e., qubit poisoning , emerge as the principal decoherence mechanism above 1 K 2 and can proceed to 100s of GHz and THz frequency 38 ; 9 . These losses, largely insensitive to microwave drive power, have also been observed at lower temperatures through background-radiation-induced QP poisoning 32 ; 34 ; 7 ; 18 revealing an additional dissipation pathway in superconducting qubits 6 ; 10 . However, the microscopic origins of nonequilibrium QP generation, and in particular the contribution of magnetic-vortex trapping and de-trapping dynamics, remain to be explored 27 ; 1 ; 3 . Although powerful techniques are available to visualize vortex configurations in real space 15 and microwave frequency 1 ; 3 , achieving the resolution required to probe QP-vortex interactions on femtosecond timescales and THz frequency dynamics is crucial for revealing how vortex states influence nonequilibrium QP generation and dynamics. In this work, we identify and characterize a vortex-dominated, pre-bottleneck regime that hosts an unexpected mechanism of QP multiplication and self-sustained growth under low excitation. Using femtosecond-resolved, low-fluence magneto-pump–probe spectroscopy on superconducting niobium (Nb) resonators under tunable magnetic fields, we resolve ultrafast, magnetic field-dependent QP relaxation dynamics mediated by QP trapping and Cooper-pair breaking within vortex cores. This nonthermal regime sustains a prolonged nonequilibrium state, in which QP multiplication persists even long after the phonon population saturates, revealing a previously unrecognized magnetic-dependent loss channel in superconducting resonators. At higher excitation fluences, this regime