Security Analysis of Agentic AI Communication Protocols: A Comparative Evaluation
Yedidel Louck , Ariel Stulman , Amit Dvir · 2025
Read Security Analysis of Agentic AI Communication Protocols: A Comparative Evaluation by Yedidel Louck , Ariel Stulman , Amit Dvir (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-03841.txt.
Introduction
Yedidel Louck, Ariel Stulman, and Amit Dvir carry out a security analysis of the protocols AI agent systems use. They test the official CORAL system and a high-fidelity ACP system directly, and judge the A2A protocol from published work, using a fourteen-point checklist of flaws.
Checks cover authentication, authorization, integrity, confidentiality, and availability. CORAL showed strong design in message checks and session isolation, yet critical flaws at its gateway let login and access checks fail. ACP's flexible design, above all its optional signature checks, opened high-impact trust and privacy gaps. A hybrid that pairs CORAL's design with mandatory per-message integrity checks is recommended as the safer path forward.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yedidel Louck , Ariel Stulman , Amit Dvir |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 108 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-03841
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Security Analysis of Agentic AI Communication Protocols: A Comparative Evaluation Yedidel Louck , Ariel Stulman , Amit Dvir Abstract Multi-agent systems (MAS) powered by artificial intelligence (AI) are increasingly foundational to complex, distributed workflows. Yet, the security of their underlying communication protocols remains critically under-examined. This paper presents the first empirical, comparative security analysis of the official CORAL implementation and a high-fidelity, SDK-based ACP implementation, benchmarked against a literature-based evaluation of A2A. Using a 14 point vulnerability taxonomy, we systematically assess their defenses across authentication, authorization, integrity, confidentiality, and availability. Our results reveal a pronounced security dichotomy: CORAL exhibits a robust architectural design, particularly in its transport-layer message validation and session isolation, but suffers from critical implementation-level vulnerabilities, including authentication and authorization failures at its SSE gateway. Conversely, ACP’s architectural flexibility, most notably its optional JWS enforcement, translates into high-impact integrity and confidentiality flaws. We contextualize these findings within current industry trends, highlighting that existing protocols remain insufficiently secure. As a path forward, we recommend a hybrid approach that combines CORAL’s integrated architecture with ACP’s mandatory per-message integrity guarantees, laying the groundwork for resilient, next-generation agent communications. 1 Introduction The emergence of agentic Artificial Intelligence (AI) systems, particularly those powered by large language models (LLMs), has significantly transformed the landscape of software autonomy [ 1 ] . These intelligent agents, capable of reasoning, planning, delegating, and executing complex workflows, now form the backbone of applications ranging from supply chain coordination to personalized financial assistance. As the scale and complexity of multi-agent ecosystems increase, so too do the requirements for secure, interoperable communication protocols. Communication between autonomous agents introduces unique security challenges. Unlike traditional client-server architectures, agent-based systems must manage peer-to-peer trust, dynamic task delegation, and sensitive data sharing across heterogeneous actors. In such environments, the risk of credential leakage, overprivileged access, prompt injection, and unverified execution grows exponentially [ 2 , 3 ] . Standard security frameworks such as OAuth 2.0 and TLS, while foundational, do not provide sufficient granularity or contextual awareness for these interactions, especially in cases where agents dynamically compose tasks involving payments, identity verification, or confidential documents [ 4 , 5 ] . To address these gaps, several agent communication protocols have been developed, each offering a different perspective on interoperability, trust management, and delegation control [ 6 ] . Google’s Agent-to-Agent (A2A) protocol [ 7 ] introduces a declarative model for service discovery. The Agent Communication Protocol (ACP) [ 8 ] embraces flexibility with a registry-based model. The CORAL [ 9 ] framework, in contrast, proposes a hybrid architecture integrating on-chain smart contracts for payments with off-chain communication. • Google’s Agent-to-Agent (A2A) protocol [ 7 ] introduces a declarative model for service discovery. • The Agent Communication Protocol (ACP) [ 8 ] embraces flexibility with a registry-based model. • The CORAL [ 9 ] framework, in contrast, proposes a hybrid architecture integrating on-chain smart contracts for payments with off-chain communication. While these protocols present promising architectures, their security properties are discussed in the literature but rarely subjected to comparative empirical testing [ 2 ] . This study fills this gap by providing a detailed, multidimensional security analysis and empirical testing. We establish a 14-point vulnerability taxonomy (Section 6 ), derived from literature and threat modeling. Our findings reveal a critical ”architecture versus implementation” dichotomy. We demonstrate that CORAL, while possessing a robust architecture for integrating payments and securing data integrity via transport-layer validation, is critically vulnerable in its current public implementation due to fundamental authentication and authorization failures at its SSE gateway. Conversely, our tests confirm that ACP’s architectural flexibility is, in itself, a vulnerability, leading to predictable integrity failures and data exfiltration in non-strict configurations. Ultimately, this paper contributes both a comprehensive security taxonomy and the first empirical benchmark of these competing protocols. We conclude (Section 11 ) not by recommending one protocol, but by proposing a hybrid model that synthesizes CORAL’s architectural strengths with the mandatory, granular integrity checks of ACP, offering a concrete path forward for resilient, AI-native communications. 2 Background Multi-agent systems (MAS) leveraging artificial intelligence (AI) are increasingly adopted in domains requiring distributed decision-making, automated coordination, and collaborative reasoning. In such environments, autonomous agents often represent distinct stakeholders or functional modules, exchanging structured messages through predefined interaction protocols. Representative use cases include autonomous orchestration, financial transaction systems, healthcare diagnostics, supply chain optimization, and cybersecurity defense. A robust communication protocol in these contexts must ensure more than reliable message delivery, it must preserve semantic integrity, context continuity, role negotiation, and, critically, security guarantees. Since AI agents frequently process or act upon sensitive data, vulnerabilities in their communication layers can compromise entire workflows. Therefore, secure agent protocols must provide protection against adversarial entities, unintended leakage, manipulation, and systemic compromise. Below we summarize the principal categories of threats relevant to communication among AI-driven agents. These categories synthesize findings from distributed systems, adversarial AI research, and classical network security. • Prompt Injection: An adversary may inject malicious instructions into prompts or message payloads, coercing agents to disclose confidential data or alter intended behavior. This class of attacks is extensively discussed in recent studies [ 10 , 3 ] . • Data Leakage / Exfiltration: Agents may inadvertently reveal private or proprietary content during multi-turn exchanges, especially when sensitive context persists across dialogue rounds [ 11 ] . • Data Poisoning: Malicious actors can inject corrupted training or contextual data, influencing downstream models to behave incorrectly or embed hidden triggers. Data poisoning has been empirically shown to scale across distributed and shared-context environments [ 12 ] . • Adversarial / Malicious Agents: A compromised or impersonated agent may introduce false commands, disrupt negotiation, or propagate malicious payloads across the system. • Replay Attacks: Attackers may capture, delay, or replay previously valid messages, leading to repeated actions, synchronization errors, or unintended state transitions. • Man-in-the-Middle (MITM): Intercepting or modifying agent communication allows attackers to compromise message integrity or confidentiality, particularly in non-authenticated transport setups. • Authorization and Access Control Failures: Weak or missing policy enforcement may grant unauthorized agents elevated privileges or execution rights beyond their designated scope [ 13 ] . Because AI agents operate in dynamic, evolving contexts, these threats may emerge jointly in complex ways. For example, prompt injection may exploit a poisoned policy to escalate privileges, or a MITM attacker might subtly alter negotiation messages to induce controlled leakage [ 14 ] . A detailed taxonomy and empirical validation of these vulnerabilities spanning authentication, authorization, integrity, confidentiality, and availability are presented later in Section 6 . Here, we summarize the key conceptual threat categories as established in the literature. 3 Related Work While earlier work primarily addressed single-agent robustness or model safety, recent research increasingly targets the security of agent-to-agent interactions. Studies on prompt manipulation and jailbreak attacks demonstrate how structured agents can still be coerced into leaking confidential information under adversarial input [ 15 , 10 ] . Complementary research investigates data leakage through prolonged contextual retention and model output side channels [ 16 ] . In the context of adversarial coordination, multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) studies reveal that malicious participants can collude to subvert cooperation or distort shared policies. To counter such threats, new frameworks have proposed secure orchestration mechanisms