Effects of density stratification on Rossby waves in deep atmospheres

Catherine C. Blume, Bradley Hindman · 2025

Read Effects of density stratification on Rossby waves in deep atmospheres by Catherine C. Blume, Bradley Hindman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-03832.txt.

Introduction

Catherine C Blume and Bradley W Hindman calculate how Rossby waves behave deep inside the Sun, where their radial shapes have stayed unknown. Earlier theory either treated the system as nearly flat or assumed a fully radiative or fully convective interior, neither of which fits the real Sun.

Working with Lagrangian pressure changes in a standard solar model, the pair derive cleaner wave equations without the singularities older work hit. The solar interior holds two wave cavities, one in the radiative zone and one in the convection zone. Radiative-zone modes keep nearly constant vorticity through the convection zone, raising the chance they might be seen at the surface.

Catalog record

CREATORCatherine C. Blume, Bradley Hindman
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-03832

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Effects of density stratification on Rossby waves in deep atmospheres Catherine C. Blume, Bradley Hindman Abstract Though Rossby waves have been observed on the Sun, their radial eigenfunctions remain a mystery. The prior theoretical work either considers quasi-2D systems, which do not apply to the solar interior, or only considers fully radiative or fully convective atmospheres. This project calculates the radial eigenfunctions for Rossby waves in a deep atmosphere for a general stratification. Here, we use the β \beta -plane approximation to derive a vertical equation in terms of the Lagrangian pressure fluctuation δ ​ P \delta P , and we then calculate radial eigenfunctions for Rossby waves in a standard solar model, Model S. We find that working in the Lagrangian pressure fluctuation results in cleaner wave equations that lack internal singularities that have been encountered in prior work. The resulting radial wave equation makes it abundantly clear that there are two wave cavities in the solar interior, one in the radiative interior and another in the convection zone. Surprisingly, our calculated radial vorticity eigenfunctions for the radiative interior modes are nearly constant throughout the convection zone, raising the possibility that they may be observable at the solar surface. I Introduction Rossby waves (also known as planetary waves or r modes) are large-scale toroidal oscillations for which the restoring force is the Coriolis force. Though these waves have long been recognized as a dynamically important transport mechanism in Earth’s atmosphere and oceans ( Rossby 1939 ; Haurwitz 1940 ) , they were only recently observed on the solar surface ( Löptien et al. 2018 ; Liang et al. 2019 ; Proxauf et al. 2020 ; Alshehhi et al. 2019 ; Hanasoge & Mandal 2019 ; Hanson et al. 2020 ; Gizon et al. 2021 ; Hathaway & Upton 2021 ; Waidele & Zhao 2023 ; Hanson & Hanasoge 2024 , e.g.,) . An ongoing hope is that these modes will prove to be an excellent seismic diagnostic of properties of the solar interior that are currently poorly constrained (such as the convection zone’s superadiabatic gradient). Before Rossby waves can be exploited in such a way, we need to understand how they propagate radially through different kinds of fluid environments. Much of the theory behind Rossby waves was developed in geophysical contexts—where one can assume that the thickness of the atmosphere or ocean in question is small compared to the size of the Earth—allowing for calculations to be done in two dimensions or in a quasi-2D system, such as the shallow-water system ( Pedlosky 1987 ; Vallis 2017 , e.g.,) . The most common implementation of the shallow-water system uses an approximation in Cartesian coordinates called the \beta -plane and assumes the gravitational force is constant across the entire domain. Additionally, these calculations tend to assume a stable, non-convective atmosphere. The Sun is neither a thin spherical shell of gas nor is the entirety of its interior convectively stable; so, any attempt to analyze the radial behavior of Rossby waves in a solar environment must first extend the present paradigm to more relevant stratifications. The helio- and astero-seismology communities have historically taken a very different approach to understand so-called “ r modes” as they appear in stars. The field has traditionally relied on spheroidal oscillations (i.e., the p modes and g modes), which involve radial motions ( Cox 1983 , e.g.,) . In fact, without the presence of the Coriolis force, there are no toroidal oscillations with purely horizontal motion. With the addition of rotation, toroidal modes appear in a form that resembles the Rossby waves noted by the geophysics community ( Ledoux 1949 ; Papaloizou & Pringle 1978 ) . Attempts to calculate the radial behavior of Rossby waves via this method immediately run into the problem that for low-frequency toroidal oscillations, there is coupling between the spheroidal and toroidal modes that results in an infinite series. To solve this problem, these calculations use asymptotic expansions relative to a small parameter proportional to the rotation frequency, which requires slow rotation, to derive expressions for the radial behavior of these r modes ( Provost et al. 1981 ; Wolff & Blizard 1986 ; Damiani et al. 2020 ) . The previous calculations of the radial variation of Rossby waves from both of these communities have prominently featured equations where the buoyancy frequency appears in terms of its reciprocal, 1/N^{2} , and derivatives of its reciprocal. (The Ledoux discriminant A is often used instead, which is related to the buoyancy frequency as N^{2}=gA/r .) Because the square of the buoyancy frequency transitions from positive in the radiative interior to negative in the convection zone, this produces an internal singularity in the domain that must be handled when analyzing the entire solar interior. Calculations from the geophysics community often only treat stable atmospheres, which neatly avoids this problem ( Pedlosky 1987 ; Vallis 2017 , e.g.,) . In the stellar physics community, Provost et al. 1981 do not attempt to treat realistic stratifications, opting to consider either fully convective or fully radiative stars, while Damiani et al. 2020 focus specifically on polytropic atmospheres to model the convection zone only, and Albekioni et al. 2023 focus on stable stratifications only. Our most significant deviation from these previous calculations is to use the Lagrangian pressure fluctuation \delta P as our working variable, rather than the Lagrangian displacement \bm{\xi} ( Provost et al. 1981 ; Wolff & Blizard 1986 ; Damiani et al. 2020 , e.g.,) , latitudinal velocity v_{y} ( Albekioni et al. 2023 , e.g.,) , or the Eulerian pressure fluctuation P_{1} ( Pedlosky 1987 , e.g.,) . The Lagrangian pressure fluctuation has been a convenient variable to work with in previous helioseismology calculations ( Christensen-Dalsgaard 2002 ; Gough 1993 , e.g.,) and often results in cleaner mathematics ( Hindman & Jain 2022 ; Hindman & Julien 2024 , see) . We find that this method results in a greatly simplified vertical wave equation without internal singularities, even when the buoyancy frequency N^{2} (or the Ledoux discriminant) changes sign. Given that Rossby waves in their simplest form are a purely toroidal phenomenon, we are inspired by the shallow water system from the geophysics community, and we assume that the waves are very low frequency such that the vertical force balance is hydrostatic. Further, we use the standard \beta -plane approximation to calculate the vertical behavior in terms of the Lagrangian pressure fluctuation \delta P (Section II ). We then numerically calculate radial eigenfunctions and corresponding eigenfrequencies for a standard model of the Sun’s radial stratification, Model S ( Christensen-Dalsgaard et al. 1996a ) . We find two distinct families of modes, one that resides in the convection zone and the other in the radiative interior (Sections III and IV ). Finally, we explore the implications of our calculations on the observability of the r modes whose cavity lies within the radiative interior (Section V ), as well on interpretations of the modes that have been previously observed. II Governing Equations We use the standard \beta -plane approximation with the origin of the local Cartesian coordinate system located at an arbitrary latitude \theta and radius R . The coordinate unit vectors, \hat{x} , \hat{y}

Read the complete text