Uncountably many homogeneous real trees with the same valence
Pénélope Azuelos · 2025
Read Uncountably many homogeneous real trees with the same valence by Pénélope Azuelos (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-03722.txt.
Introduction
Penelope Azuelos shows that dropping one word, completeness, multiplies a classic uniqueness result into uncountably many counterexamples. For each branching number, exactly one complete real tree has every point branching that way. Real trees are branching spaces with a single path between any two points, used across geometry and phylogenetics.
When the branching number is at least three, Azuelos builds uncountably many uniform yet incomplete trees sharing that same branching at every point. Uniformity alone therefore cannot pin the tree down. The note is short but sharp: completeness carries the whole weight of the classic theorem. Such boundary cases teach mathematicians exactly which assumptions do the work.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Pénélope Azuelos |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-03722
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Uncountably many homogeneous real trees with the same valence Pénélope Azuelos Abstract For any cardinal κ ≥ 2 \kappa\geq 2 , there is a unique complete real tree whose points all have valence κ \kappa . In this note, we show that, when κ ≥ 3 \kappa\geq 3 , it is necessary to assume completeness. More precisely, we show that there exist uncountably many homogeneous incomplete real trees whose points all have valence κ \kappa . 1 Introduction Real trees are geodesic metric spaces with the property that any pair of points is connected by a unique arc. One of the ways in which these spaces arise is as asymptotic cones of hyperbolic groups. In fact, the asymptotic cone of a non-elementary hyperbolic group is always isometric to the same real tree: the universal real tree with continuum valence [ DP01 ] . The valence of a real tree T at a point x is the cardinality of the set of connected components of T-\{x\} (the directions at x ). It was proven in [ MNO92 , Nik89 ] that, for any cardinal \kappa\geq 2 , there is a unique complete real tree T_{\kappa} , called the universal real tree of valence \kappa , such that every point of T_{\kappa} has valence \kappa . Explicit constructions of these universal real trees where given in [ DP01 ] . While incomplete real trees do not arise as asymptotic cones directly, they do come up in this context. The asymptotic cone of a relatively hyperbolic group is a universal tree-graded space whose pieces are asymptotic cones of peripheral subgroups [ OS11 , Sis13 ] . This tree-graded space admits a canonical projection to a real tree [ DS08 , Section 2.3] , which is homogeneous and, provided the parabolic subgroups are infinite, is incomplete. Furthermore, the asymptotic cones of mapping class groups and other hierarchically hyperbolic groups admit canonical median preserving bi-Lipschitz embeddings into \ell^{1} products of real trees [ BDS11 , CRHK24 ] . Some of the images of these asymptotic cones under the natural projections to the factors are homogeneous incomplete real trees. This class of real trees also arises in work of Chiswell–Müller, who proved that any free non-transitive group action on a real tree can be embedded into a free transitive action on an incomplete real tree [ CM10 ] . Lastly, Berestovskiĭ [ Ber19 ] noticed that a space first defined by Urysohn [ Ury27 ] , and which turns out to be a homogeneous incomplete real tree, was independently studied in [ Ber89 , PS97 ] . We will show that, unlike in the complete setting, valence alone is insufficient to distinguish between homogeneous real trees. More precisely, we will show the following: Theorem 1.1 . Let \kappa\geq 3 be a cardinal. There exists a family \{T_{\kappa}^{[\alpha]}:1\leq\alpha<\omega_{1}\} of incomplete homogenous real trees with valence \kappa and a fixed isometric embedding \psi_{\alpha,\beta}:T_{\kappa}^{[\alpha]}\hookrightarrow T_{\kappa}^{[\beta]} for all \alpha<\beta such that: 1. for any countable ordinals \alpha,\beta , if \alpha\neq\beta then T_{\kappa}^{[\alpha]} is not isometric to T_{\kappa}^{[\beta]} ; 2. if \alpha<\beta<\gamma , then \psi_{\alpha,\gamma}=\psi_{\beta,\gamma}\circ\psi_{\alpha,\beta} ; 3. the direct union \cup_{\alpha<\omega_{1}}T_{\alpha} , taken with respect to \{\psi_{\alpha,\beta}:1\leq\alpha<\beta<\omega_{1}\} , is isometric to the universal real tree with valence \kappa . Proof. We will use the description of the universal real tree T_{\kappa} from [ DP01 ] to define a filtration T_{\kappa}=\cup_{\alpha<\omega_{1}}T_{\kappa}^{[\alpha]} (Definition 3.6 ). In Lemma 3.8 , we prove that each T_{\kappa}^{[\alpha]} is an \mathbb{R} -tree with valence \kappa and, in Lemma 3.10 , we show that T_{\kappa}^{[\alpha]} is homogeneous. Letting \psi_{\alpha,\beta} be the inclusion maps, this proves Items 2 and 3. We prove Item 1 and show that the T_{\kappa}^{[\alpha]} ’s are incomplete in Proposition 4.4 . ∎ Remark 1.2 . 1. The real tree discussed in [ Ber19 ] is T_{2^{\aleph_{0}}}^{[1]} . 2. If one only considers real trees which admit a free transitive action, then valence does distinguish between real trees of finite valence [ Azu25 , Theorem C] . This is no longer true for continuum valence trees, and I do not know if it holds for intermediate cardinals. 2 Cantor–Bendixson rank We will make use of a topological invariant called the Cantor–Bendixson rank to distinguish between different real trees with the same valence. Let us recall its definition. Let Y be a Polish space (i.e. separable and completely metrisable). The Cantor–Bendixson theorem (see e.g. [ Kec95 ] ) states that there is a unique decomposition of Y as a disjoint union \mathcal{K}(Y)\sqcup C , where \mathcal{K}(Y) is perfect (i.e. closed with no isolated points) and C is countable. Any non-empty perfect Polish space contains a Cantor set, so the perfect subspace \mathcal{K}(Y) is empty if and only if Y is countable. The Cantor–Bendixson derivatives of Y are defined by transfinite recursion. Set Y^{(0)}\coloneqq Y . If \alpha is an ordinal for which Y^{(\alpha)} is defined, then Y^{(\alpha+1)} is the set of non-isolated points of Y^{(\alpha)} . If \beta is a limit ordinal such that Y^{(\alpha)} is defined for all \alpha<\beta , then Y^{(\beta)}\coloneqq\cap_{\alpha<\beta}Y^{(\alpha)} . The Cantor–Bendixson theorem implies that there is a countable ordinal \alpha such that Y^{(\alpha+1)}=Y^{(\alpha)} (i.e. Y^{(\alpha)}=\mathcal{K}(Y) ). The minimal such \alpha is called the Cantor–Bendixson rank of Y and is denoted \mathrm{rk}_{\mathrm{CB}}(Y) . Remark 2.1 . If Y is a countable compact metrisable space then its Cantor–Bendixson rank must be a successor ordinal. 3 Finding the real trees Let \kappa\geq 3 be a cardinal. We first recall the construction of the complete universal real tree with valence \kappa from [ DP01 ] : Definition 3.1 (Labels) . Let C_{\kappa} be a set such that |C_{\kappa}|=\kappa if \kappa is infinite and |C_{\kappa}|=\kappa-1 if \kappa is finite. Fix an element 0\in C_{\kappa} . Definition 3.2 . Let T_{\kappa} be the set of functions f:(-\infty,\rho_{f})\rightarrow C_{\kappa} , where \rho_{f}\in\mathbb{R} , such that: 1. There exists s\leq\rho_{f} such that f(t)=0 for all t<s . 2. f is piecewise constant from the right : i.e. for all t\in(-\infty,\rho_{f}) , there exists \varepsilon>0 such that f|_{[t,t+\varepsilon]} is constant. Given f\in T_{\kappa} , let \tau_{f} be the maximum of all s\leq\rho_{f} such that f(t)=0 for all t<s . Definition 3.3 (Partial order) . Define an order \preceq on T_{\kappa} where f\preceq g if f=g|_{(-\infty,\rho_{f})} . We will write f\prec g if in addition f\neq g . Given f,g\in T_{\kappa} , let s\coloneqq\sup\{t\leq\min\{\rho_{f},\rho_{g}\}:f|_{(-\infty,t)}=g|_{(-\infty,t)}\} and define f\wedge g:(-\infty,s)\rightarrow C_{\kappa} by f\wedge g(t)=f(t)=g(t) for all t<s . Remark 3.4 . The relation \preceq is reflexive, transitive and antisymmetric. Moreover, if f,g\in T_{\kappa} , then f\wedge g is the greatest lower bound for \{f,g\} . Definition 3.5 (Metric) . Define d:T_{\kappa}\times T_{\kappa}\rightarrow\mathbb{R} by d(f,g)\coloneqq\rho_{f}+\rho_{g}-2\rho_{f\wedge g} for all f,g\in T_{\kappa} . By [ DP01 , Theorem 1.1.3] (T_{\kappa},d) is the universal \mathbb{R} -tree with valence \kappa . Definition 3.6 (Complexity) . Given f\in T_{\kappa} , let P_{f}\coloneqq\overline{\{t<\rho_{f}:f|_{[t-\varepsilon,t]}\text{ is not constant for any }\varepsilon>0\}}. The complexity of f , denoted \comp(f) , is the Cantor–Bendixson rank of P_{f} . For each countable ordinal \alpha , define T_{\kappa}^{[\alpha]}\coloneqq\{f\in T_{\kappa}:\comp(f)\leq\alpha\}. Remark 3.7 . Given f\in T_{\kappa} , the fact that f is piecewise constant from the right ensures that the set P_{f} is well-ordered with respect to the usual order on \mathbb{R} . This implies that P_{f}