Mie-tronics supermodes and symmetry breaking in nonlocal metasurfaces
Thanh Xuan Hoang, Ayan Nussupbekov, Jie Ji, Daniel Leykam, Jaime Gómez Rivas, Yuri Kivshar · 2025
Read Mie-tronics supermodes and symmetry breaking in nonlocal metasurfaces by Thanh Xuan Hoang, Ayan Nussupbekov, Jie Ji, Daniel Leykam, Jaime Gómez Rivas, Yuri Kivshar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-03560.txt.
Introduction
Thanh Xuan Hoang and colleagues overturn a common belief that breaking symmetry always weakens light trapping in patterned surfaces. In metasurfaces, perfect symmetry can protect states with huge quality factors, and breaking it usually leaks light away. Their finite arrays of Mie resonators behave the other way around.
Breaking symmetry strengthens sideways coupling paths that were dormant before, and quality factors rise instead of falling. Diffractive bands and collective supermodes turn out to spring from the same resonances yet differ in nature. Finite size itself redistributes radiation channels, reversing trends that endless-lattice theory predicts. Designers of real, finite optical chips gain a counterintuitive lever: careful asymmetry as a route to stronger confinement.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Thanh Xuan Hoang, Ayan Nussupbekov, Jie Ji, Daniel Leykam, Jaime Gómez Rivas, Yuri Kivshar |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-03560
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Mie-tronics supermodes and symmetry breaking in nonlocal metasurfaces Preprint: APS/123-QED Thanh Xuan Hoang, Ayan Nussupbekov, Jie Ji, Daniel Leykam, Jaime Gómez Rivas, Yuri Kivshar Abstract It is usually believed that symmetry breaking in photonic systems leads to weaker optical confinement, such as in the case of metasurfaces when bound states in the continuum are replaced by quasi-bound states with lower quality factors ( Q Q factors). Here we show that symmetry breaking can instead enhance light trapping by strengthening in-plane nonlocal coupling pathways. We consider finite-size arrays of optical resonators supporting Mie resonances (a Mie-tronics platform) and employ diffraction and multiple-scattering analyses. We demonstrate that diffractive bands and Mie-tronics supermodes originate from the same underlying Mie resonances but differ fundamentally in their physical nature. Finite arrays exhibit Q Q -factor enhancement driven by redistributed radiation channels, and reversing the trends predicted by infinite-lattice theories. We reveal that controlled symmetry breaking opens new electromagnetic coupling channels, enabling polarization conversion in nonlocal metasurfaces. These novel findings establish a unified wave-physics platform linking both scattering and diffraction theories. Also, they outline the design principles for multifunctional metasurfaces that exploit nonlocality for advanced light manipulation, computation, and emission control. I Introduction The field of optical metasurfaces is rapidly evolving from fundamental science to practical technologies, enabling compact platforms for imaging, sensing, energy harvesting, and information processing 9 . Conventional metasurfaces comprise weakly interacting subwavelength elements, allowing a local description. Yet, recent analyses of their limits show that surpassing these constraints demands nonlocal design 10 ; 65 ; 72 . When inter-element coupling becomes strong, collective optical excitations emerge, giving rise to nonlocal metasurfaces governed by coherent, system-scale modes. Because these modes are typically excited by plane waves, they can often be interpreted through diffraction theory, earning the name diffractive nonlocal metasurfaces 58 . Understanding such systems benefits from revisiting the classical diffraction theories that first distinguished local from nonlocal behavior. In his 1907 “Dynamical Theory of Gratings”, Rayleigh extended Fresnel’s scalar treatment of reflection and diffraction to periodic metallic surfaces. He explicitly noted that Fresnel’s local approximation fails when the grating period approaches the wavelength, observing that the recesses “act as resonators” 61 . Rayleigh thus recognized, decades ahead of modern electromagnetic modeling, that resonance fundamentally alters diffraction and that a “more strictly dynamical theory” is required. Ugo Fano later provided this framework 18 , introducing coupling among diffracted and evanescent orders to describe how these “Rayleigh cavities” form quasi-stationary surface waves that interfere with the continuum, giving rise to asymmetric Fano lineshapes. The Rayleigh–Fano formalism laid the foundation for modern numerical solvers such as the rigorous coupled-wave analysis (RCWA) or Fourier modal method 48 , which are employed here to calculate nonlocal diffraction bands in ideal, infinitely periodic metasurfaces. The design of nonlocal metasurfaces often begins with idealized infinite arrays of resonators, where symmetry breaking within the unit cell serves as a versatile tool for tailoring the dispersion and radiation properties of diffractive bands 56 ; 59 ; 73 ; 6 . Engineering such diffractive bands has recently fueled advances in analog optical computing and wave-based information processing 23 ; 43 ; 40 ; 47 . In practical implementations, however, metasurfaces are finite—a feature that has drawn growing attention 25 ; 37 ; 12 ; 75 . While compactness makes them appealing for integration, it simultaneously invalidates the assumption of infinite periodicity inherent to diffraction theory. As the array size decreases, translational symmetry is broken and the momentum conservation underlying the Fourier modal method no longer holds. The resulting collective resonances become discrete and strongly dependent on a global geometry of the structure. In this finite regime, multiple scattering and modal hybridization provide a more accurate physical description 44 ; 30 . At the microscopic level, the collective effects originate from interactions among Mie modes—the localized resonances of individual dielectric or metallic elements—which constitute the building blocks of Mie-tronics 63 . Beyond governing the response of isolated particles 46 ; 5 , the coupling of Mie modes across arrays yield bonding and anti-bonding supermodes. These supermodes can enhance device performance and enable entirely new metadevice concepts 42 ; 4 ; 24 ; 51 . In this work, we study systematically how symmetry breaking can affect both diffractive and Mie-tronics supermodes. Together with the accompanying Letter 32 , we show that, contrary to expectations based on infinite-array diffraction bands, symmetry breaking in finite metasurfaces can enhance in-plane multiple scattering and thereby increase the quality factor ( Q ) of certain nonlocal modes. We further demonstrate that coupling among Mie modes produces additional bonding and anti-bonding supermodes beyond the Fourier-mode couplings of classical diffraction theory, expanding the functional landscape of nonlocal metasurfaces. Notably, while anti-bonding supermodes remain robust in the presence of a quartz substrate, bonding supermodes are suppressed. Finally, we show that distinct unit-cell geometries can support identical Mie-resonant supermodes, underscoring the robustness and design versatility of the Mie-tronics framework for both diffractive and finite-size nonlocal metasurfaces. II Fundamentals of Mie-tronics II.1 Historical origins of Mie-tronics The intellectual roots of Mie-tronics trace back to the 19th-century work of Clebsch, who sought a rigorously wave-based framework for optical devices at a time when lens and mirror design was dominated by geometrical principles 50 . Employing both plane-wave and point-like sources, he introduced an early form of the multipole expansion to solve boundary conditions—an idea that became a cornerstone of scattering theory. Although Clebsch ultimately declared his effort a failure, his pioneering use of multipole expansions endured 16 . What once seemed unattainable is now well established: the laws of reflection and refraction follow directly from wave physics 8 , specifically from the scattering coefficients obtained at a spherical interface 26 ; 27 . In this sense, Clebsch’s attempt to reinterpret bulky optical elements in wave terms resonates with today’s drive to realize ultrathin metasurfaces that harness wave phenomena to replace conventional optics. Clebsch’s ideas influenced Lorenz, who first derived the exact solution for plane-wave scattering by a sphere. This result, however, later became more widely associated with Mie, whose systematic multipole analysis laid the analytical foundation of modern scattering theory 71 . Unlike Lorenz, Mie was primarily inspired by Rayleigh, who had independently investigated acoustic and optical scattering problems similar to those considered by Clebsch. Notably, Mie introduced the now-standard term “Rayleigh scattering” to distinguish the point-particle regime from his treatment of larger spheres 54 . Over the following century, these contributions coalesced into the framework of generalized Lorenz–Mie theory, emphasizing the dual importance of intrinsic scatterer modes and the multipole content of excitation sources 21 . Advances in nanoscience have since extended scattering analysis to particles of arbitrary shape 38 , enabling entirely new classes of photonic devices 17 . This convergence of multipole physics and nanophotonics defines the emerging paradigm of Mie-tronics 70 ; 39 —a framework that unifies classical scattering theory with modern metasurface design. II.2 Diffraction and scattering The early development of scattering theory was closely intertwined with the study of diffraction. In the 19th century, Clebsch, Lorenz, and Rayleigh often described light–particle interactions in the language of diffraction 67 . Before Maxwell’s electromagnetic formulation, when the Huygens–Fresnel principle dominated, the terms “diffraction” and “scattering” were used almost interchangeably. With the