Observed Joy’s law of Bipolar Magnetic Region tilts at the emergence supports the thin flux tube model

Anu Sreedevi, Bidya Binay Karak, Bibhuti Kumar Jha, Rambahadur Gupta, Dipankar Banerjee · 2025

Read Observed Joy’s law of Bipolar Magnetic Region tilts at the emergence supports the thin flux tube model by Anu Sreedevi, Bidya Binay Karak, Bibhuti Kumar Jha, Rambahadur Gupta, Dipankar Banerjee (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-03558.txt.

Introduction

Anu Sreedevi and co-authors test a century-old pattern in how paired sunspot regions tilt on the Sun. Bipolar magnetic regions lean away from the equator by an amount that grows with latitude, a rule called Joy's law. One leading story credits the Coriolis effect twisting a thin magnetic tube as it rises through the Sun's churning outer layer.

If that story holds, the tilt pattern should already appear at first emergence, before surface flows can reshape the region. Fresh emergence data show the law present at birth, backing the thin flux tube picture. Support has been thin until now, so direct emergence evidence carries weight. Solar activity forecasts lean on how these regions tilt, since tilt shapes the next cycle.

Catalog record

CREATORAnu Sreedevi, Bidya Binay Karak, Bibhuti Kumar Jha, Rambahadur Gupta, Dipankar Banerjee
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-03558

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Observed Joy’s law of Bipolar Magnetic Region tilts at the emergence supports the thin flux tube model Anu Sreedevi, Bidya Binay Karak, Bibhuti Kumar Jha, Rambahadur Gupta, Dipankar Banerjee Abstract Bipolar sunspots, or more generally, Bipolar Magnetic Regions (BMRs), are the dynamic magnetic regions that appear on the solar surface and are central to solar activity. One striking feature of these regions is that they are often tilted with respect to the equator, and this tilt increases with the latitude of appearance, popularly known as Joy’s law. Although this law has been examined for over a century through various observations, its physical origin is still not established. An attractive theory that has been put forward behind Joy’s law is the Coriolis force acting on the rising flux tube in the convection zone, which has been studied using the thin flux tube model. However, observational support for this theory is limited. If the Coriolis force is the cause of the tilt, then we expect BMRs to hold Joy’s law at their initial emergence on the surface. By automatically identifying the BMRs over the last two solar cycles from high-resolution magnetic observations, we robustly capture their initial emergence signatures on the surface. We find that from their appearance, BMRs exhibit tilts consistent with Joy’s law. This early tilt signature of BMRs suggests that the tilt is developed underneath the photosphere, driven by the Coriolis force and helical convection, as predicted by the thin flux tube model. Considerable scatter around Joy’s law observed during the emergence phase, which reduces in the post-emergence phase, reflects the interaction of the vigorous turbulent convection with the rising flux tubes in the near-surface layer. show][email protected] show][email protected] I Introduction One of the most striking features of the Sun’s visible surface is the appearance of dark spots, famously known as sunspots. Advances in solar observations revealed that sunspots host intense magnetic fields, with adjacent spots possessing opposite polarities ( 10 ) . This led to the broader term, Bipolar Magnetic Regions (BMRs), to describe them. Given their central role in driving solar activity, understanding the variabilities in solar cycles has long been a focus of research ( 22 ) . Although years of studies show that surface BMRs are expressions of a smoothly operating solar dynamo underneath ( 20 ; 4 ) , their specific characteristics, such as emergence and orientation, remain active areas of investigation and debate ( 7 ; 42 ) . A distinctive property of the emerging BMRs is that the line connecting their opposite magnetic polarities forms an apparent tilt angle with respect to the equator. Statistically, BMRs emerging at higher latitudes tend to exhibit larger tilt angles, popularly known as Joy’s law ( 9 ; 44 ; 34 ; 39 ; 43 ; 27 ; 30 ) . The systematic tilt of BMRs is vital for generating the poloidal field for the next cycle and sustaining the solar dynamo ( 3 ) . Therefore, understanding how BMRs acquire their tilt is essential to understanding the solar cycle and its prediction in this technologically driven society ( 29 ) . Simulations complemented by observations support that BMRs originate from magnetically buoyant toroidal flux rising from the deep convection zone ( 28 ; 42 ) . In this scenario, the thin flux tube model ( 35 ; 25 ) offers a compelling explanation for the generation of tilt. This model assumes that the BMRs are formed through the rise of bundles of magnetic fields of the so-called \Omega -shaped loops through the convection zone. As a loop ascends, diverging flows from the apex experience the Coriolis force, imparting a tilt to the BMR ( 5 ; 6 ; 2 ) . In addition, helical convection, on average, tends to drive tilts to the rising loops in the correct direction ( 46 ) . The thin flux tube model has been central to many simulation studies and has been widely used to investigate various aspects of the solar dynamo and activity ( 7 ; 4 ) . Beyond the Sun, the model provides insight into the magnetic activity of rapidly rotating stars ( 15 ; 16 ) , where the Coriolis force dominates the magnetic buoyancy to form polar spots ( 32 ) . Despite the extensive implication of the thin flux tube model, its observational support is limited ( 7 ) . The thin flux tube model predicts: (i) a reduction of BMR tilt with the increase of the toroidal magnetic field as the strong-field flux tubes rise rapidly and the Coriolis force gets less time to tilt and (ii) the increase of tilt with increase of flux due to increasing effects of the drag and Coriolis forces. More explicitly, 6 predicted that the tilt \gamma\propto\sin\lambda B_{0}^{-5/4}\Phi^{1/4} (where \lambda is the latitude, B_{0} is the initial magnetic field of the flux tube and \Phi is the flux inside the rising flux tube). While B_{0} has little or no bearing on the observed photospheric field, \Phi is related to the measured flux in BMR which has a wide variation in magnitude (more than 3 orders). Hence, we expect a measurable change in the tilt with the magnetic flux. However, simulations considering the effect of convection show that this dependency is not robust ( 45 ) . Probably this is why, in observations, no systematic trend is observed; some groups ( 23 ; 39 ) find no statistically significant variation in tilt with the BMR flux, while other groups ( 41 ; 17 ; 37 ) find an increase of tilt with the flux followed by a reduction at high flux values. Thus, we need to check an alternative robust prediction of the thin flux tube model, and that is, Joy’s law tilts at the emergence. The model predicts that BMRs should emerge with a systematic tilt given by Joy’s law, as during the journey of flux tubes inside the convection zone itself the Coriolis force induces tilt. However, in contrast to this prediction, previous observations ( 14 ; 23 ; 33 ) find that BMRs emerge with nearly zero tilt and acquire the tilt predicted by Joy’s law only during the post-emergent phase, leading to the conclusion that the tilt is produced in the surface layer rather than below the surface.Identifying the tilt at emergence remains a challenging problem, as surface turbulence can distort the initial orientation and, as a result, the characteristic Joy’s law signature may not be evident at the early stage of BMR evolution. We track BMRs in the high-resolution magnetogram data over the last two solar cycles, starting from the time when they begin to show signatures in the line-of-sight magnetic field, and find that BMRs display tilt according to Joy’s law. II Results To investigate BMR tilt at the time of emergence, we built on the catalog produced by the Automatic Tracking Algorithm for Bipolar Magnetic Regions ( 36 , AutoTAB;) . This algorithm identifies and tracks BMRs throughout their nearside evolution using line-of-sight (LOS) magnetograms from the Michelson Doppler Imager (MDI) onboard Solar and Heliospheric Observatory (SOHO) and the Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (HMI) onboard Solar Dynamic Observatory (SDO). The resulting catalog contains 11,987 unique BMRs spanning September 1996 to December

Read the complete text