Theoretical and Experimental Limitations of RoCoF Estimation
J. Gutiérrez-Florensa 1 , F. Sanniti 2 , D. Tedeschi 3 , L. Sigrist 4 , Á. Ortega 4 and F. Milano 1 · 2025
Read Theoretical and Experimental Limitations of RoCoF Estimation by J. Gutiérrez-Florensa 1 , F. Sanniti 2 , D. Tedeschi 3 , L. Sigrist 4 , Á. Ortega 4 and F. Milano 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-03249.txt.
Introduction
Power engineers J Gutierrez-Florensa, F Sanniti, D Tedeschi, L Sigrist, A Ortega, and F Milano tackle a timing problem in electric grids. They focus on how fast grid frequency changes after a fault, a measure tied to stored spinning energy and to the size of the shock. Protection gear relies on that measure to shed load or stop unwanted islanding.
Modern grids carry less spinning mass and more converter-based power, so old meters read the change less well. The team offers a sturdier method drawn from geometry and fluid ideas, then checks it against fast real measurements. The method also tells protection gear more about what kind of fault happened. A quicker control scheme built on it can react sooner and more wisely.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | J. Gutiérrez-Florensa 1 , F. Sanniti 2 , D. Tedeschi 3 , L. Sigrist 4 , Á. Ortega 4 and F. Milano 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-03249
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Theoretical and Experimental Limitations of RoCoF Estimation J. Gutiérrez-Florensa 1 , F. Sanniti 2 , D. Tedeschi 3 , L. Sigrist 4 , Á. Ortega 4 and F. Milano 1 Abstract A precise estimation of the rocof ( rocof ) is crucial for secure power system operation. In fact, rocof is strictly related to the amount of the available physical and/or virtual inertia of the system and the severity of the active power unbalance following a disturbance. For this reason, it is widely exploited in different protection systems, e.g. , Anti-Islanding, ufls ( ufls ) and wide-area protection systems. The new paradigm of modern power systems, with a low-inertia and converter-based generation assets, is increasing the transient severity, making the frequency and the rocof estimation more complex and less precise for the actual devices. This work addresses this issue by proposing a numerically robust approach based on concepts inherited from differential geometry and fluid mechanics. The proposed approach is then tested with high-sampling real experimental measurements and used to develop a faster control logic for a rocof -based ufls control scheme. The proposed approach provides information to protections regarding the nature of the contingency which can be used to improve its response. I Introduction I-A Motivation rocof is formally defined as the time derivative of the instantaneous frequency, i.e. the second time derivative of the phase angle of a voltage signal [ 1 ] . In practical applications, it is computed starting from the estimation of the instantaneous frequency, typically provided by a pll ( pll ) or from the fundamental frequency estimated by a pmu ( pmu ). Then, the time derivative is computed with the adoption of some filtering and its value is averaged on a rolling time window for a smoother behavior [ 2 ] . In addition, for protection schemes, an intentional time delay between the detection and actuation can be used to avoid undesirable trips. Extended rolling windows are typically adopted to improve the rocof estimation by reducing noise, unbalances and distortion, at the expense of the promptness of the relay. On the other hand, a shorter time window improves the responsiveness, but oscillations in the rocof estimation, for instance, can lead to undesirable trips. A recent interpretation of the frequency in the framework of the differential geometry (see [ 3 ] ) creates the conditions to approach the actual rocof computation issues from a novel perspective. In particular, contributions in [ 4 ] are especially relevant as they define qss ( qss ) frequency - a novel quantity that captures the slowly-varying fundamental value of frequency - and the time derivative of circulation - a metric that evaluates the physical existence of such frequency. Together, these concepts are here exploited to assess the theoretical and experimental limitations of rocof and introduce a novel approach for its estimation. I-B Literature Review Nowadays, the problem of the rocof estimation in power system applications is still an open challenge. Low-inertia systems exhibit higher values of rocof during transients and, at the same time, its estimation is harder due to the higher distortion of the electrical quantities [ 5 ] . At present, there is no standard approach to compute rocof in power systems. Several techniques have been proposed in the last years [ 6 ] , which can be grouped in two main categories depending on how the frequency is computed: (i) based on instantaneous frequency measurement (provided, e.g. , by a pll or a fir ( fir ) filter [ 7 ] ), and (ii) based on fundamental frequency measurement (exploiting, e.g. , recursive dft ( dft ) techniques [ 8 , 9 ] ). As the pll -based estimation is sensitive to amplitude steps, noise and harmonics, typically the formal estimation of rocof is filtered and then averaged on a rolling time window, introducing latency in the estimation [ 10 ] . dft -based techniques can be faster since they elaborate on a phasor measurement, even if they require by definition a given time window for the estimation [ 9 ] . These methods are also less sensitive to noise and harmonics but their precision deteriorates especially in the first instant after a disturbance, where the signal distortion is higher [ 11 ] . Hence, also in this case a proper averaging window has to be selected, vanishing the promptness of the algorithm [ 12 ] . In recent literature, pmu -based techniques for rocof estimation have arisen among the others, because of their fast reporting rates and responsiveness, and the wide monitoring ability of the pmu architecture [ 13 ] . pmu -based rocof estimation techniques do not employ averaging to limit the uncertainty given by noise, distortion, and unbalances. As a consequence, the IEEE has significantly relaxed the rocof error requirement from 0.01 Hz/s to 0.4 Hz/s [ 14 ] . In practice, this level of uncertainty make the rocof estimation useless for typical applications, since values close to 1 Hz/s can already be considered critical for the stability of the system [ 15 ] . Several synchrophasor-based algorithms have been compared in [ 13 ] and [ 12 ] , where it becomes evident that pmu provide optimal performance in presence of low fluctuations, as typical of inter-area oscillations, but their measurement is hampered during fast transient events. The deployment of rocof -based relays is mainly focused on three applications: (i) island detection for distribution networks [ 16 ] , (ii) protection from lom ( lom ) of embedded generators [ 17 ] and (iii) rocof -based ufls schemes, as part of the power system defense plan of many tso [ 18 ] . rocof -based ufls schemes allow improving their responsiveness by anticipating the decision to shed load [ 19 ] , [ 20 ] . The latter application has gained attention in recent years due to the increased penetration of ibr , which is worsening the effects of power disturbances on frequency stability, as recent blackout events have proven [ 21 , 22 ] . Among several possible topologies of ufls schemes [ 23 ] , traditionally based on frequency measurements, semi-adaptive ufls schemes introduce rocof thresholds to trigger the relays in addition to frequency thresholds. For ufls application, larger absolute rocof values can lead to the following major issues sorted by criticality: • Frequency collapse before the relays have time to trip; • Unintentional tripping due to inaccuracy in the measurement of the frequency and/or rocof ; • Over extensive ls ( ls ) (due to the time delay of activation of the relays). A trade-off should be found between the promptness of the intervention and the prevention of unintentional trips. In practical applications, often large time windows are chosen, ranging from 500 to 1000 ms [ 24 ] . ENTSO-E, e.g. , recommends 500 ms as a rolling time window for adequate rocof monitoring [ 2 ] and recommends also a maximum disconnection time delay [ 18 ] . However, to date, recommended criteria for a suitable definition of threshold values and tripping logic are still missing for rocof -based ufls . I-C Contributions Based on a recent development proposed in [ 4 ] , the paper further