Oscillation Analysis and Damping Control for a Proposed North American AC-DC Macrogrid

Kaustav Chatterjee, Sameer Nekkalapu, Antos Varghese, Marcelo Elizondo, Quan Nguyen, Xiaoyuan Fan · 2025

Read Oscillation Analysis and Damping Control for a Proposed North American AC-DC Macrogrid by Kaustav Chatterjee, Sameer Nekkalapu, Antos Varghese, Marcelo Elizondo, Quan Nguyen, Xiaoyuan Fan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-03017.txt.

Introduction

Kaustav Chatterjee and five colleagues study a proposed power macrogrid linking North America's eastern and western grids through a multi-terminal DC network. Earlier studies praised the plan for sharing capacity and propping up frequency, but the risk of slow, poorly damped swings between regions went unexamined. Their 2025 paper builds a custom dynamic model of the DC link and joins it to industry-grade models of both big grids.

Oscillation analysis showed how the link shifts the natural swing modes of each side, and flagged modes with too little damping. The team then designed extra controllers for the DC stations, using wide-area feedback to adjust power set points and calm the swings. Tests under planned conditions and fault scenarios showed the controllers worked as designed.

Catalog record

CREATORKaustav Chatterjee, Sameer Nekkalapu, Antos Varghese, Marcelo Elizondo, Quan Nguyen, Xiaoyuan Fan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE34 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-03017

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Oscillation Analysis and Damping Control for a Proposed North American AC-DC Macrogrid Thanks: This work is funded by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Electricity Advanced Grid Modelling (AGM) Program. Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) is operated by Battelle for the DOE under Contract DOE-AC05-76RL01830. Kaustav Chatterjee, Sameer Nekkalapu, Antos Varghese, Marcelo Elizondo, Quan Nguyen, Xiaoyuan Fan Abstract In recent years, several studies—conducted by both industry and U.S. Department of Energy (DOE)-funded initiatives—have proposed linking North America’s Eastern and Western Interconnections (EI and WI) through a multiterminal DC (MTDC) macrogrid. These studies have explored the advantages and opportunities of the proposed configuration from the perspectives of capacity sharing and frequency support. However, the potential challenges of small-signal stability arising from this interconnection have not been thoroughly examined. To address this gap, detailed model-based simulation studies are performed in this paper to assess the risks of poorly damped inter-area oscillations in the proposed macrogrid. A custom-built dynamic model of the MTDC system is developed and integrated with industry-grade models of the EI and WI, incorporating high levels of inverter-based energy resources. Through model-based oscillation analysis, potential shifts in inter-area modes—for both EI and WI, resulting from the MTDC integration are characterized, and modes with inadequate damping are identified. Furthermore, to mitigate the risks of unstable oscillations, supplementary damping controllers are designed for the MTDC system, leveraging wide-area feedback to modulate active power set points at selected converter stations. A frequency scanning approach is employed for data-driven model linearization and controller synthesis. The damping performance is evaluated under the designed operating conditions and selected contingency scenarios. I Introduction Ensuring flexibility is becoming increasingly crucial as power systems face greater variability in demand and load patterns [ 9 , 21 ] . In this context, High Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) transmission offers a compelling solution, enabling the connection of asynchronous AC systems and facilitating enhanced capacity sharing across interconnections [ 9 ] . While most HVDC projects in the United States (US) and globally are currently limited to back-to-back or point-to-point links, there is growing interest in exploring multiterminal DC (MTDC) configurations [ 11 , 29 ] . In the past decade, several MTDC projects using Voltage Source Converter (VSC) technology have been deployed in China and parts of Europe [ 11 ] . MTDC grids provide significant advantages over traditional two-terminal DC links, including increased redundancy and resilience to single-point failures, improved control over power distribution on AC networks, reduced reserve capacity requirements, and lower lifetime costs [ 8 , 29 , 3 ] . This interest is mirrored in the US, as evidenced by the Midcontinent Independent System Operator’s (MISO’s) proposal for a continent-scale MTDC macrogrid linking the Eastern and Western Interconnections (EI and WI) [ 22 ] . The 2014 MISO transmission expansion plan featured comprehensive techno-economic studies of the proposed macrogrid, investigating potential DC network topologies and connection points with the EI and WI [ 22 ] . Similar analyses for a continent-scale DC macrogrid have also been presented by the Interconnections Seam Study funded by the US Department of Energy (DOE) [ 25 , 1 ] . These studies overwhelmingly indicate high benefit-to-cost ratios in favor of a pan-US macrogrid, demonstrating increased transmission capacity, improved frequency response, and enhanced generation utilization across regions [ 21 , 25 , 1 ] . That said, with an MTDC macrogrid network interconnecting the EI and WI systems, the operators will face the usual challenges of ensuring stability, particularly those related to poorly-damped inter-area oscillations within each AC interconnection. Power injection from the DC network into the AC (or otherwise) and subsequent rerouting of flows within an AC grid because of DC overlays may modify the system’s eigenvalues and reshape the existing oscillation modes [ 7 ] . As the EI and WI grids evolve with new generation assets and transmission infrastructure such as these MTDC connections, it is essential to reassess system stability. It is worth investigating if there are risks from undamped/poorly-damped oscillations in EI or WI because of these system modifications [ 23 , 5 , 2 ] . And if so, it also calls for identifying potential mitigation strategies targeting those. Prior research examining the effects of increasing inverter penetration on system oscillation modes has primarily focused on the EI [ 33 , 5 ] and the WI [ 14 , 2 , 6 ] as separate entities. These studies have largely concentrated on the proliferation of inverter-based resources (IBRs) on the generation side, and have predominantly considered grid-following inverters while overlooking the potential influence of grid-forming technologies. Notably, there has been a lack of investigation into how inverter-based transmission systems, particularly HVDC, affect inter-area oscillation modes when linking the EI and WI. Although MISO’s macrogrid initiative [ 22 ] and several DOE-funded studies [ 21 , 25 , 1 ] have comprehensively addressed capacity sharing and macrogrid planning, they have not adequately examined small-signal stability concerns, including the emergence of poorly damped inter-area oscillations. To advance this body of work, the present paper presents a detailed case study of the proposed EI-WI-MTDC interconnection, focusing on the potential adverse impacts on system oscillation dynamics and their mitigation through the strategic design of supplementary damping controllers (SDCs). The SDCs, through fast modulation of active power injections at the MTDC converters, can dampen unstable oscillation modes in interconnected AC systems [ 13 ] . A broad range of damping control strategies exists in the literature, from basic linear control designs [ 8 ] to \mathcal{H}_{\infty} and Linear Matrix Inequality (LMI)-based robust controls [ 3 ] , as well as energy function-based methods and others [ 13 ] . A comprehensive survey of these approaches can be found in [ 13 ] . In this work, a dynamic model of the macrogrid is developed, integrating high-fidelity EI and WI models—sourced from their respective industrial working groups—with a custom MTDC model created at the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL). The base models of the EI and WI systems are modified to incorporate high percentages of grid-forming inverter-based generation resources. For oscillation analysis, modal estimation techniques are applied to ringdown data extracted from time-domain disturbance simulations on the system model. The analysis reveals the prospective shifts in the oscillation modes from the base case and flags poorly damaged modes that have the potential to destabilize the system. For damping the critical modes, supplementary damping controllers (SDCs) are designed, which modulate power references at selected MTDC converter stations, utilizing wide-area frequency feedback. The frequency scanning technique [ 17 ] is employed to estimate a linear model of the system for SDC design. This offline probing method derives a transfer function from measurement data, effectively bypassing the challenges typically associated with model-based linearization in large-scale power systems. The proposed MTDC-SDC framework complements existing HVDC damping controllers in the EI and WI, such as those on the Pacific DC Intertie [ 26 ] , which were originally designed for legacy inter-area modes without accounting for the macrogrid configuration. Fig. 1: (a) Single-line diagram of MTDC macrogrid showing the scheduled power exchanges between the EI and WI systems, (b) control block diagram for the EI, WI, and MTDC-SDC interaction, and (c) schematic of the SDC

Read the complete text