Visualization of High Dynamic Range Solar Imagery and the Radial Histogram Equalizing Filter
C.R. Gilly, S.R. Cranmer · 2025
Read Visualization of High Dynamic Range Solar Imagery and the Radial Histogram Equalizing Filter by C.R. Gilly, S.R. Cranmer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-02798.txt.
Introduction
Chris Gilly and Steven Cranmer present a filter that makes solar images show both the bright disk and the faint outer corona. Standard views of extreme ultraviolet images hide faint off-limb detail, leaving a bright ball in a dark void. Their 2025 paper introduces the Radial Histogram Equalizing Filter, built for the Sun's huge range of brightness.
The filter blends radial graded filters, which respect distance from the Sun's center, with histogram equalization, which spreads contrast where the eye needs it. It runs frame by frame with no tuning and treats disk and off-limb features evenly. A companion function, Upsilon, offers gentle tonal compression when wanted. Benchmarks against older methods, plus examples from several instruments, guide users on when each tool fits.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | C.R. Gilly, S.R. Cranmer |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-02798
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Visualization of High Dynamic Range Solar Imagery and the Radial Histogram Equalizing Filter C.R. Gilly, S.R. Cranmer Abstract keywords Image Processing; Radial Graded Filters; High Dynamic Range; Solar Corona; Coronal Visualization; Space Weather; EUV Imagery {opening} Figure 1. : Comparison of contrast enhancement techniques applied to the SunPy AIA 171 Å sample image. The top-left panel shows the image with basic gamma correction (i.e., without high dynamic range (HDR) enhancement). The top-right and bottom-left panels show results from the Normalizing Radial Graded Filter (NRGF) and Multiscale Gaussian Normalization (MSGN), respectively (we use these for comparison, but note that they were never designed to be used on-disk). The bottom-right panel displays the result of the Radial Histogram Equalizing Filter (RHEF) and Upsilon \Upsilon , which preserves detail across both on-disk and off-limb regions while enhancing the visibility of faint coronal structures. 1 Introduction Visualizing images of the solar corona is a fundamental task in heliophysical research, with direct implications for understanding solar dynamics and forecasting space weather. However, this task presents persistent challenges due to the wide range of radiance levels across many Sun-centered fields of view. In Extreme Ultraviolet (EUV) observations, two distinct forms of dynamic range complexity emerge. First, the steep radial falloff in emission—driven by decreasing plasma density and emissivity with height—causes large-scale coronal structures to fade rapidly with distance from the solar surface. These structures often become difficult to visualize without specialized processing ( Del Zanna and Mason 2018 ) . Second, embedded within these gradients are small-scale, high-frequency features whose contrast is subtle relative to the surrounding background. Although faint, these features are physically meaningful and typically lie above the instrumental noise floor ( Aschwanden 2010 ) . To study both classes of features—especially those extending into the off-limb corona—advanced image processing is essential. Such methods compress the dynamic range to enhance visibility, ideally preserving structural fidelity without discarding small-amplitude transients of interest. A variety of algorithms have been developed to address these challenges. Solar image processing has evolved to include several families of enhancement techniques that fall broadly into three categories: Radial Gradient Filtering (RGF), Histogram Equalization (HE), and Multiscale Methods (MSM)—each offering distinct advantages for interpreting high dynamic range (HDR) solar imagery ( Morgan, Habbal, and Fineschi 2007 ; Morgan and Druckmüller 2014 ) . However, each approach has limitations, and the choice among them depends heavily on the observer’s goals and the structures of interest. As the demand grows for tools capable of detecting low-contrast features and tracking dynamics across a broad range of spatial scales, such filters have become indispensable in both research and operational space weather contexts ( West et al. 2023 ) . We introduce a new hybrid algorithm: the Radial Histogram Equalizing Filter (RHEF). This method specifically targets the shortcomings of existing techniques, offering an efficient, parameter-free solution that enhances both large-scale coronal architecture and fine-scale detail. This article is organized as follows. Section 2 provides a brief overview of solar image preparation and processing, including a discussion of their downstream implications for visualization in Section 2.1 . Section 2.2 reviews three major families of HDR compression techniques. Section 3 presents two new tools: the RHEF and the Upsilon redistribution function ( \Upsilon ). In Section 4 , we benchmark these tools against established methods and demonstrate their performance across representative features. We conclude in Section 5 with a summary of key findings and directions for future work. Appendix A showcases the application of RHEF to a range of solar instruments. Appendix B introduces a new FIDO Client for downloading reduced-resolution AIA imagery from the synoptic series (1024x1024 at a 2-minute cadence), and Appendix C gives a brief python RHEF usage example. 2 Image Processing Primer Raw telescope data must undergo essential pre-processing before it becomes suitable for scientific analysis. Using the Solar Dynamics Observatory’s Atmospheric Imaging Assembly (SDO/AIA; Lemen et al. 2012 ) as a representative example, we outline common image corrections in solar physics, noting that specific procedures vary between instruments. For those new to this workflow, Python-based tools such as SunPy ( Barnes et al. 2020 ) provide a solid foundation for data handling. More detailed descriptions of standard image reduction steps are available in Aschwanden 2010 , Boerner et al. 2012 , and Pössel 2020 . 2.1 Implications of Filtering While calibrated images are essential for quantitative science, they are often suboptimal for direct visualization. The solar corona presents an extreme dynamic range that challenges standard display techniques, with bright on-disk emission and faint off-limb structures coexisting in the same frame. As a result, nonlinear filtering algorithms are commonly used to compress this range, enhancing visual clarity and feature detectability. However, these filters—such as those listed in Table 1 —modify pixel values in nonlinear, spatially varying ways. Because they do not apply uniform scaling, filtered intensities lose their original linear relationship to physical units. This compromises the quantitative accuracy of the image, rendering it unsuitable for analyses that rely on calibrated radiance—such as plume/interplume contrast, emission measure, or temperature and density diagnostics ( Boerner et al. 2012 , e.g.,) . Name Abbrev Reference Radial Graded Filters (RGF) Normalizing Radial Graded Filter *NRGF Morgan, Habbal, and Woo 2006 AIA_RFILTER - McCauley, Cranmer, and Engell (2010) AIA_OFFLIMB - McCauley, Cranmer, and Engell (2010) Fourier Norm. Radial Graded Filter *FNRGF Druckmüllerová, Morgan, and Habbal 2011 Simple Radial Gradient Filter SIRGRAF Patel et al. 2022 SWAP Filter SWAP Seaton et al. 2023 Histogram Equalization (HE) Adaptive Histogram Equalization AHE Pizer et al. 1987 Contrast-Limited Adaptive HE CLAHE Pisano et al. 1998 Adaptive Circular HP Filter ACHF Druckmüller, Rušin, and Minarovjech 2006 Noise Adaptive Fuzzy Equalization NAFE Druckmüller 2013 NAFE (Variable Neighborhood) NAFEVN Druckmüller, Habbal, and Morgan 2014 Radial Histogram Equalizing Filter *RHEF Gilly 2022 and this paper Multiscale Methods (MSM) Wavelet Transform WT Stenborg and Cobelli 2003 Multi-Scale Gaussian Norm *MSGN Morgan and Druckmüller 2014 Radial Local Multiscale Filter RLMF Qiang et al. 2020 Wavelet Optimized Whitening *WOW Auchère et al. 2023b Table 1. : A non-exhaustive overview of filtering methods across several families. Methods marked with an asterisk (*) are available in the SunPy-affiliated package sunkit-image . Note that some hybrid methods may span multiple categories. Despite this loss of photometric fidelity, filtered images remain valuable for scientific workflows that rely on morphology rather than calibrated intensity. These include segmentation, edge detection, and feature tracking used to identify structures such as plumes, loops, sunspots, and coronal holes. As observational cadence and spatial resolution improve, the ability to reveal faint, dynamic features becomes increasingly critical. Filtering can also enhance physical interpretation in motion-tracking workflows. For instance, identifying solar wind outflows enables acceleration profile derivation that constrains coronal heating models ( Miralles et al. 2001 ; Telloni, Giordano, and Antonucci 2019 ; Cranmer 2020 ) . Careful spatial filtering can also help identify and track small density enhancements that trace larger-scale outflows and inflows ( Sheeley, Jr. et al. 1997 ; DeForest, Howard, and McComas 2014 ; López-Portela et al. 2018 ) Similarly, dynamic range compression improves visibility of flare morphologies, wavefronts, and CME propagation, aiding in the linkage between inner and outer corona observations ( Vourlidas and Howard 2006 ; Gilly 2022 ) . While nonlinear filters alter absolute