Quantum Theory Can Decohere from a Causally-Indefinite Post-Quantum Theory

James Hefford, Matt Wilson · 2025

Read Quantum Theory Can Decohere from a Causally-Indefinite Post-Quantum Theory by James Hefford, Matt Wilson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-02772.txt.

Introduction

James Hefford and Matt Wilson explore whether plain quantum theory could emerge from a stranger theory where cause and effect have no fixed order. Their 2025 paper works with quantum boxes, a higher-order framework with a non-signalling way of combining systems. A process called hyper-decoherence is meant to wash out the strangeness and leave standard quantum behavior.

The pair find such a process that meets the hyper-decoherence axioms and does yield standard quantum theory. It sidesteps a known no-go result by loosening two assumptions: limits on signalling to the past, and the uniqueness of purifications. They weigh two readings of the result. Either nature really does smooth an indefinite-causal theory into ours, or the axioms need a closer look, especially around purity.

Catalog record

CREATORJames Hefford, Matt Wilson
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE609 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-02772

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantum Theory Can Decohere from a Causally-Indefinite Post-Quantum Theory James Hefford, Matt Wilson Abstract We find a process satisfying the axioms of hyper-decoherence which produces standard quantum theory from the theory of quantum boxes (higher-order quantum theory with the non-signalling tensor product). This hyper-decoherence map evades the no-go theorem of Lee and Selby Lee and Selby 2018 by relaxing constraints on signalling to the past and the uniqueness of purifications. We discuss some natural opposing conclusions: that the existence of this map might be evidence of a genuine hyper-decoherence process producing causal quantum theory from its causally-indefinite higher-order theory; or that it serves as an indication that the axioms of hyper-decoherence might need careful re-consideration, especially regarding the subtle albeit central role that purity plays. I Introduction One way to understand the emergence of classical theory from quantum theory is via the process of decoherence, in which the limited power or control of observers forbids them direct access to the quantum realm. In the knowledge that quantum theory is not a complete description of our physical world (for instance in its lack of a satisfactory accommodation of gravity), one is naturally led to the question of how quantum theory could emerge from some yet-to-be-defined post-quantum theory, via an analogous process of hyper -decoherence due to constraints on the powers of purely-quantum observers. This idea appears to have been first explicitly discussed in Życzkowski 2008 in relation to deriving quantum theory from minimal and physically reasonable axioms Hardy 2001 , and lies within the broader problem of singling quantum theory out amongst the larger class of Generalised Probabilistic Theories (GPTs) Barrett 2007 , Operational Probabilistic Theories (OPTs) Chiribella et al. 2010 ; Chiribella et al. 2011 or Categorical Probabilistic Theories (CPTs) Gogioso and Scandolo 2018 . The search for such post-quantum theories appears to be cut short by the no-go theorem of Lee and Selby 2018 , which establishes that there can be no such post-quantum theory satisfying both causality and the existence of unique purifications. Naturally, one can question the validity of these assumptions in the hope of bypassing this theorem, and a number of partial toy theories have been suggested which exhibit some notion of hyper-decoherence Życzkowski 2008 ; Dakić et al. 2014 ; Gogioso and Scandolo 2019 ; Hefford and Gogioso 2021a , each one breaking, more or less severely, at least one axiom we would expect of a physically reasonable theory Lee and Selby 2017 or of a physically reasonable hyper-decoherence map, thereby allowing them to side-step the no-go theorem. These toy theories however, do not just break causality or uniqueness of purifications. Quartic Quantum Theory Życzkowski 2008 and density cubes Dakić et al. 2014 suffer from substantial foundational issues including ill-defined processes and joint systems Lee and Selby 2017 . Density hypercubes Gogioso and Scandolo 2019 ; Hefford and Gogioso 2021a on the other hand can be considered a legitimate theory in the sense that it is a CPT Gogioso and Scandolo 2018 with tomography, however, its hyper-decoherence process suffers from being not only non-causal but also non-deterministic Hefford and Gogioso 2021a . In the elusive search for a satisfactory post-quantum theory, a more principled approach could be to examine toy models of aspects of quantum gravity, which we expect to be a theory more fundamental than traditional quantum theory. Notably, an influential proposal of Hardy 2007 , that theories which unify quantum theory with gravity ought also to exhibit non-fixed causal structures, appears to draw a striking parallel with the non-causal conclusion of the no-go of Lee and Selby 2018 . This in turn begs the question, could quantum theory with indefinite causal order be that elusive post-quantum theory which hyper-decoheres to traditional quantum theory? . In this letter we argue the affirmative, by finding a map satisfying the axioms of hyper-decoherence from the theory of quantum boxes \mathsf{QBox} into standard quantum theory, where \mathsf{QBox} is the most natural fragment of higher-order quantum theory for modelling indefinite causal order. On the one hand, the transition from higher to lower order has a natural interpretation in terms of the reduction in power of observers. S f S \phi \xrightarrow{\mathtt{hypdec}} Figure 1: Hyper-decoherence of causal quantum theory from causally-indefinite higher-order quantum theory. On the other hand, if one finds this map to be too far outside of what might be expected for a map that resembles decoherence, we consider the alternative conclusion, that the axioms of hyper-decoherence might be incomplete, or at least, in need of refinement. II Process Theories We will develop the results of this paper in the setting of process theories also known as symmetric monoidal categories (SMCs) Coecke and Kissinger 2017 . A process theory \mathcal{C} consists of a collection of systems or objects which we denote in capital H,K etc. and a collection of processes or morphisms for instance f:H\xrightarrow{}K . These processes can be composed in sequence gf and in parallel by tensor product g\otimes f with these two compositions compatible in the expected way. Each system H comes with an identity process 1_{H} with the property 1_{K}f=f=f1_{H} and it is possible to invertibly swap the order of systems in a tensor product \sigma_{H,K}:H\otimes K\xrightarrow{}K\otimes H . There is a trivial system I with the property that H\otimes I\cong H for every system H . Example 1 (Pure Quantum Theory) . There is a process theory \mathsf{FHilb} whose systems are the finite dimensional Hilbert spaces H and whose processes are the linear maps. The parallel composition is the usual tensor product. Example 2 (Mixed Quantum Theory) . There is a process theory \mathsf{CP} whose systems are the finite dimensional C^{*} -algebras and whose processes are the completely positive maps. The tensor product is the standard one. There is a sub-process theory \mathsf{CPTP} of only the completely positive trace preserving maps. Example 3 (Classical Theory) . There is a process theory \mathsf{Mat}_{\mathbb{R}^{+}} whose systems are the natural numbers n\in\mathbb{N} and whose processes m\xrightarrow{}n are the m\times n matrices with entries from \mathbb{R}^{+} . Sequential composition of matrices is given by matrix multiplication and parallel composition by Kronecker product. There is a sub-process theory \mathsf{Stoch} of only the stochastic matrices. Definition 1 . Given a process theory \mathcal{C} there is another process theory D(\mathcal{C}) whose systems are formal tensor products of pairs \otimes_{i=1}^{n}[H_{i},H_{i}] where each H_{i} is a system of \mathcal{C} . A process f:\otimes_{i}[H_{i},H_{i}]\xrightarrow{}\otimes_{j}[K_{j},K_{j}] is a process f:\otimes_{i}(H_{i}\otimes H_{i})\xrightarrow{}\otimes_{j}(K_{j}\otimes K_{j}) of \mathcal{C} . Composition, identities and the tensor are inherited from \mathcal{C} , with [I,I] as the trivial system. We interpret a process f:\otimes_{i}[H_{i},H_{i}]\xrightarrow{}\otimes_{j}[K_{j},K_{j}] in D(\mathcal{C}) as a higher-order map taking a family a processes \{H_{i}\xrightarrow{}H_{i}\}_{i} to a family \{K_{j}\xrightarrow{}K_{j}\}_{j} . In this way D(\mathcal{C}) forms the backbone of a process theory of higher-order maps over \mathcal{C} , though one which does not account for which higher-order maps are causally valid. In the next section we will show how to equip D(\mathcal{C}) with a notion of causality in order to restrict its maps to only those that are causally valid. III Multi-Environment Structures Causality in process theories can be captured by equipping them with an environment structure Coecke et al. 2018 ; Coecke 2016 . Definition 2 . An environment structure for

Read the complete text