Nonadiabatic corrections to electric quadrupole transition rates in H 2
Krzysztof Pachucki a and Michał Siłkowski b · 2025
Read Nonadiabatic corrections to electric quadrupole transition rates in H 2 by Krzysztof Pachucki a and Michał Siłkowski b (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-02716.txt.
Introduction
Krzysztof Pachucki and Michal Silkowski refine predicted transition rates in the hydrogen molecule. Their 2025 paper handles electric quadrupole transitions, a faint kind of light emission and absorption. Simple theory treats the two nuclei as fixed, but real molecules wobble, and that motion adds corrections called nonadiabatic effects.
The authors derive formulas for those corrections, built around a curve that tracks the molecule's quadrupole moment as the nuclei move apart. The curve parallels the classic one Wolniewicz derived for the fixed-nuclei case. Their numbers shift rates in the fundamental band by amounts from 0.4 percent to 12 percent, depending on how fast the molecule spins. Precise spectra of hydrogen, in labs and in space, depend on such fine details.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Krzysztof Pachucki a and Michał Siłkowski b |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 48 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-02716
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Nonadiabatic corrections to electric quadrupole transition rates in H 2 Krzysztof Pachucki a and Michał Siłkowski b Abstract We derive formulas and perform calculations of nonadiabatic corrections to rates of electric quadrupole transitions in the hydrogen molecule. These corrections can be represented in terms of a single curve D ( 1 ) ( R ) D^{(1)}(R) , similarly to the Born-Oppenheimer one, D ( 0 ) ( R ) D^{(0)}(R) , derived originally by Wolniewicz. Numerical results change E2 transition rates for the fundamental band by as much as 0.4 - 12% depending on rotational quantum numbers. † † articletype: Research Article † † affiliation: a Faculty of Physics, University of Warsaw, Pasteura 5, 02-093 Warsaw, Poland b Faculty of Chemistry, Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań, Uniwersytetu Poznańskiego 8, 61-614 Poznań, Poland 1 Introduction Most of the calculations of molecular properties are performed in the Born-Oppenheimer (BO) approximation. When higher precision is needed, e.g., for accurately measured transition energies in H 2 [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] , one includes adiabatic and nonadiabatic corrections. These corrections can be calculated systematically within the so-called nonadiabatic perturbation theory (NAPT) [ 5 , 6 ] . Using NAPT, one can calculate not only corrections to rovibrational energies, but also to many other physical properties [ 7 ] , like the nuclear magnetic shielding. This allowed for the most accurate determination of deuteron and triton magnetic moments [ 8 ] . In this work, we derive a formula for the leading nonadiabatic correction to rates of electric quadrupole transitions in H 2 . This nonadiabatic correction can be represented in terms of a single function D^{(1)}(R), which can be added to the BO quadrupole moment function D^{(0)}(R) , calculated by Wolniewicz in Ref. [ 9 ] , recalculated by Komasa [ 10 ] using ECG functions, and significantly improved here using an enhanced version of H2SOLV code [ 11 ] , which employs the Kołos-Wolniewicz (KW) functions. Apart from many applications in astrophysics, these accurate rates can be used in the primary thermometry for temperatures as low as 10 K [ 4 , 12 , 13 ] . 2 Nonadiabatic perturbation theory Following Ref. [ 7 ] , let us start from a nonrelativistic Hamiltonian for a neutral diatomic molecule H=\sum_{a}\frac{\vec{p}_{a}^{\;2}}{2\,m}+\frac{\vec{p}_{A}^{\;2}}{2\,m_{A}}+\frac{\vec{p}_{B}^{\;2}}{2\,m_{B}}+V, (1) where the summation index a enumerates all electrons, and A and B refer to nuclei. To derive formulae for nonadiabatic effects, one must fix the reference frame. We start with the laboratory frame \{\vec{r}_{A},\,\vec{r}_{B},\,\vec{r}_{a}\} , and subsequently change variables to \{\vec{R},\,\vec{R}_{G},\,\vec{x}_{a}\} according to \displaystyle\vec{r}_{A}= \displaystyle\ \vec{R}_{G}+\epsilon_{B}\,\vec{R}, (2) \displaystyle\vec{r}_{B}= \displaystyle\ \vec{R}_{G}-\epsilon_{A}\,\vec{R}, (3) \displaystyle\vec{r}_{a}= \displaystyle\ \vec{R}_{G}+\vec{x}_{a}, (4) with the relative position of nuclei \vec{R}=\vec{r}_{A}-\vec{r}_{B} , and the origin of the new frame, \vec{R}_{G}=\epsilon_{A}\,\vec{r}_{A}+\epsilon_{B}\,\vec{r}_{B} , where \epsilon_{A}+\epsilon_{B}=1 , chosen anywhere on the internuclear axis. The conjugate momenta are related by \displaystyle{\vec{p}}_{A}= \displaystyle\ \epsilon_{A}\,\vec{P}_{G}+{\vec{P}}-\epsilon_{A}\,\sum_{a}\vec{q}_{a}, (5) \displaystyle{\vec{p}}_{B}= \displaystyle\ \epsilon_{B}\,\vec{P}_{G}-{\vec{P}}-\epsilon_{B}\,\sum_{a}\vec{q}_{a}, (6) \displaystyle{\vec{p}}_{a}= \displaystyle\ \vec{q}_{a}, (7) where \vec{P}=-i\,\vec{\nabla}_{R} and \vec{q}_{a}=-i\,\vec{\nabla}_{x_{a}} . The nonrelativistic wave function with vanishing total momentum does not depend on \vec{R}_{G} , so \phi=\phi(\vec{x}_{a},\,\vec{R}) . We now choose the center of the reference frame at the nuclear mass center, \displaystyle\epsilon_{A}= \displaystyle\ \frac{m_{A}}{m_{A}+m_{B}}, \displaystyle\quad\epsilon_{B}= \displaystyle\ \frac{m_{B}}{m_{A}+m_{B}}\,, (8) and split the Hamiltonian into the electronic and nuclear parts, \displaystyle H= \displaystyle\ H_{\rm el}+H_{\rm n}, (9) \displaystyle H_{\rm el}= \displaystyle\ \sum_{a}\frac{\vec{q}_{a}^{\;2}}{2\,m}+V, (10) \displaystyle H_{\rm n}= \displaystyle\ \biggl(\frac{1}{2\,m_{A}}+\frac{1}{2\,m_{B}}\biggr)\,\vec{P}^{\;2}+\frac{1}{2\,(m_{A}+m_{B})}\,\Bigl(\sum_{a}\vec{q}_{a}\Bigr)^{2}=H_{\rm n}^{\prime}+H_{\rm n}^{\prime\prime}. (11) This form of the nuclear Hamiltonian is convenient for the calculation of nonadiabatic effects. Next, the angular momentum operator \vec{J} , for states with vanishing total momentum, is \vec{J}=\sum_{a}(\vec{r}_{a}-\vec{R}_{G})\times\vec{p}_{a}+(\vec{r}_{A}-\vec{R}_{G})\times\vec{p}_{A}+(\vec{r}_{B}-\vec{R}_{G})\times\vec{p}_{B}, (12) and in new variables \vec{J}=\sum_{a}\vec{x}_{a}\times\vec{q}_{a}+\vec{R}\times\vec{P}\equiv\vec{J}_{\rm el}+\vec{J}_{\rm n} (13) it can also be split into electronic \vec{J}_{\rm el} and nuclear \vec{J}_{\rm n} parts. Let us now introduce NAPT [ 5 , 6 ] . The total nonrelativistic wave function \phi of an arbitrary molecule is the solution of the stationary Schrödinger equation [H-E]\,|\phi\rangle=0\,, (14) with the Hamiltonian H being a sum of the electronic H_{\rm el} and nuclear H_{\rm n} parts, Eq. ( 11 ). In the adiabatic approximation the wave function \phi=\phi_{\rm a} , where \phi_{\rm a}(\vec{x},\vec{R})=\phi_{\rm el}(\vec{x})\;\chi(\vec{R}), (15) is represented as a product of the electronic wave function \phi_{\rm el} and the nuclear wave function \chi . We note that \phi_{\rm el} depends parametrically on the nuclear relative coordinate \vec{R} . The electronic wave function obeys the clamped nuclei electronic Schrödinger equation \bigl[H_{\rm el}-{\cal E}_{\rm el}(R)\bigr]\,|\phi_{\rm el}\rangle=0, (16) while the nuclear wave function is a solution to the Schrödinger equation in the effective potential generated by electrons \bigl[H_{\rm n}+{\cal E}_{\rm a}(R)+{\cal E}_{\rm el}(R)-E_{\rm a}\bigr]\,|\chi\rangle=0\,, (17) where {\cal E}_{\rm a}(R)=\bigl\langle\phi_{\mathrm{el}}|H_{\rm n}|\phi_{\mathrm{el}}\bigr\rangle_{\rm el}\,. (18) In NAPT, the total wave function is the sum of the adiabatic solution and a nonadiabatic correction \phi=\phi_{\rm a}+\delta\phi_{\rm na}=\phi_{\rm el}\,\chi+\delta\phi_{\rm na}\,. (19) The nonadiabatic correction \delta\phi_{\rm na} is decomposed into two parts, \delta\phi_{\rm na}=\phi_{\rm el}\,\delta\chi+\delta^{\prime}\phi_{\rm na}\,, (20) obeying the following orthogonality conditions \displaystyle\langle\delta^{\prime}\phi_{\rm na}|\phi_{\rm el}\rangle_{\rm el}= \displaystyle\ 0\,, (21) \displaystyle\langle\delta\chi|\chi\rangle= \displaystyle\ 0\,, (22) which imply the normalization condition \langle\phi_{a}|\phi\rangle=1 . In the first order of NAPT one has \displaystyle|\delta^{\prime}\phi_{\rm na}\rangle^{(1)}= \displaystyle\ \frac{1}{({\cal E}_{\rm el}-H_{\rm el})^{\prime}}\,H_{\rm n}\,|\phi_{\rm el}\,\chi\rangle, (23) where 1/({\cal E}_{\rm el}-H_{\rm el})^{\prime} denotes the resolvent with the reference state \phi_{\rm el} subtracted out. This correction to the wave function can be used to derive the finite nuclear mass corrections to various matrix elements. Consider the Hermitian electronic operator Q (without derivatives with respect to nuclear variables) and its matrix element between (different) rovibrational states. In the BO approximation, this matrix element can be represented in terms of the diagonal electronic matrix element nested in the nuclear matrix element, namely \displaystyle\langle Q\rangle^{(0)}\equiv \displaystyle\ \langle\phi_{\rm el}\,\chi_{\rm f}|Q|\phi_{\rm el}\,\chi_{\rm i}\rangle=\langle\chi_{\rm f}|\langle Q\rangle_{\rm el}^{(0)}|\chi_{\rm i}\rangle, (24) where \displaystyle\langle Q\rangle_{\rm el}^{(0)}\equiv \displaystyle\ \langle Q\rangle_{\rm el}=\langle\phi_{\rm el}|Q|\phi_{\rm el}\rangle. (25) We will show that the same holds for the leading nonadiabatic corrections, which is \displaystyle\langle Q\rangle^{(1)}= \displaystyle\ \langle\phi_{\rm el}\,\chi_{\rm f}|H_{\rm n}\,\frac{1}{({\cal E}_{\rm el}-H_{\rm el})^{\prime}}\,Q|\phi_{\rm el}\,\chi_{\rm i}\rangle+\langle\phi_{\rm el}\,\chi_{\rm f}|Q\,\frac{1}{({\cal E}_{\rm el}-H_{\rm el})^{\prime}}\,H_{\rm n}|\phi_{\rm el}\,\chi_{\rm i}\rangle. (26) Namely, \displaystyle\langle Q\rangle^{(1)}= \displaystyle\ \int d^{3}R\,\biggl\{(\chi^{*}_{\rm f}\,\chi_{\rm i})\,\biggl[\langle H_{\rm n}\,\phi_{\rm el}|\frac{1}{({\cal E}_{\rm el}-H_{\rm el})^{\prime}}\,Q\,|\phi_{\rm el}\rangle+\langle\phi_{\rm el}|Q\,\frac{1}{({\cal E}_{\rm el}-H_{\rm el})^{\prime}}\,|H_{\rm n}\,\phi_{\rm el}\rangle\biggr] \displaystyle\ -\frac{\vec{\nabla}\bigl(\chi^{*}_{\rm f}\,\chi_{\rm i}\bigr)}{2\,m_{\rm n}}\,\biggl[\langle\vec{\nabla}_{R}\phi_{\rm el}|\frac{1}{({\cal E}_{\rm el}-H_{\rm el})^{\prime}}\,Q\,|\phi_{\rm el}\rangle+\langle\phi_{\rm el}|Q\,\frac{1}{({\cal E}_{\rm el}-H_{\rm el})^{\prime}}\,|\vec{\nabla}_{R}\phi_{\rm el}\rangle\biggr] (27) \displaystyle\ -\frac{\Bigl(\chi_{\rm i}\,\vec{\nabla}\chi^{*}_{\rm f}-\chi_{\rm f}^{*}\,\vec{\nabla}\chi_{\rm i}\Bigr)}{2\,m_{\rm n}}\,\biggl[\langle\vec{\nabla}_{R}\phi_{\rm el}|\frac{1}{({\cal E}_{\rm el}-H_{\rm el})^{\prime}}\,Q\,|\phi_{\rm el}\rangle-\langle\phi_{\rm el}|Q\,\frac{1}{({\cal E}_{\rm el}-H_{\rm el})^{\prime}}\,|\vec{\nabla}_{R}\phi_{\rm el}\rangle\biggr]\biggr\}. Assuming Q is invariant with respect to time reversal, the third term vanishes, and with the help of integration by parts, we obtain \displaystyle\langle Q\rangle^{(1)}= \displaystyle\ \langle\chi_{\rm f}|\langle Q\rangle^{(1)}_{\rm el}|\chi_{\rm i}\rangle, (28) \displaystyle\langle Q\rangle^{(1)}_{\rm el}= \displaystyle\ \langle\phi_{\rm el}|\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\leftrightarrow}}{{H_{\rm n}}}\frac{1}{({\cal E}_{\rm el}-H_{\rm el})^{\prime}}\,Q\,|\phi_{\rm el}\rangle+\langle\phi_{\rm el}|\,Q\,\frac{1}{({\cal E}_{\rm el}-H_{\rm el})^{\prime}}\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\leftrightarrow}}{{H_{\rm n}}}|\phi_{\rm el}\rangle, (29) where for arbitrary \psi_{\rm el} and \psi^{\prime}_{\rm el} \langle\psi^{\prime}_{\rm el}|\!\!\stackrel{{\scriptstyle\leftrightarrow}}{{H_{\rm n}}}\!\!|\psi_{\rm el}\rangle=\langle\vec{\nabla}_{R}\,\psi^{\prime}_{\rm el}|\vec{\nabla}_{R}\,\psi_{\rm el}\rangle/(2\,m_{\rm n})+\langle\psi^{\prime}_{\rm el}|H^{\prime\prime}_{\rm n}|\psi_{\rm el}\rangle, (30) and where m_{\rm n} is the reduced nuclear mass. 3 Electric quadrupole moment The electric quadrupole moment operator is \displaystyle D^{ij}= \displaystyle\ \sum_{\alpha}e_{\alpha}\,(r_{\alpha M}^{i}\,r_{\alpha M}^{j}-r_{\alpha M}^{2}\,\delta^{ij}/3)\,, (31) where the summation index \alpha refers to both electrons and nuclei, and \vec{r}_{\alpha M} are particle positions with respect to the center of mass, \vec{r}_{M} , \displaystyle\vec{r}_{M}= \displaystyle\ \sum_{\alpha}\frac{m_{\alpha}\,\vec{r}_{\alpha}}{M}\,. (32) For the hydrogen molecule, \sum_{\alpha}e_{\alpha}=0 , and M_{A}=M_{B}=m_{N} , so the total mass M is \displaystyle M= \displaystyle\ 2\,m_{N}+2\,m\,. (33) Let us rewrite the quadrupole moment operator in terms of position vectors \vec{x}_{a}=\vec{r}_{aG} with respect to the geometric center \vec{r}_{G}