Infrared divergences and the photon mass in QED
Orlando Oliveira · 2025
Read Infrared divergences and the photon mass in QED by Orlando Oliveira (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-02666.txt.
Introduction
Orlando Oliveira studies the low-energy behavior of quantum electrodynamics, the theory of light and electrons, in a 2025 paper. Working with Dyson-Schwinger equations, he asks what the theory itself demands of the photon, the particle of light. A key test is whether the photon's self-energy stays finite at all momenta.
Oliveira finds that this finiteness, plus a smooth photon-fermion vertex, forces the photon to have no mass. Its propagator must then blow up at low momentum in a set way. He also maps which form factors could give the photon mass through the Schwinger mechanism, where that link breaks. The fermion and vertex equations, he notes, stay safe from such infrared trouble.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Orlando Oliveira |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-02666
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Infrared divergences and the photon mass in QED Orlando Oliveira Abstract The infrared properties of QED are investigated within the framework of the Dyson-Schwinger equations. Our study finds that, independently of the value of the coupling constant, requiring the photon self-energy to be finite for any momenta, combined with a smooth behavior for the photon-fermion vertex, is equivalent to state that the photon is massless and that the photon propagator diverges at low momenta as 1 / k 2 1/k^{2} . Furthermore, the Schwinger mechanism to generate, in a gauge invariant way, a photon mass is investigated and the form factors that can be at the origin of a possible photon mass are identified. For the Schwinger mechanism the link between the finiteness of the photon self-energy and the masslessness of the photon is lost. The infrared behavior of the fermion gap equation and the vertex equation are found to be infrared safe integral equations. Moreover, by studying chiral fermions within QED it is observed that the requirement of the finiteness of the photon self-energy translates into a fermion propagator that behaves as p̸ / p 4 \not{p}/p^{4} . I Introduction and Motivation Quantum Electrodynamics (QED) has guided our understanding of quantum field theory (QFT). The construction of the perturbative solutions in QED encounters infinities arising from both the ultraviolet (UV) and the infrared (IR) regimes. The treatment of ultraviolet divergences led to the development of renormalization, that is a cornerstone of modern QFT. However, the nature of IR divergences is quite different from that of their UV counterparts. These IR infinities are linked to the photon being a massless particle. The current experimental upper limit on the photon mass, as listed in the particle data book PDGphotonmass ; ParticleDataGroup:2024cfk , is m_{\gamma}<10^{-18} eV, making it reasonable to assume that m_{\gamma}=0 . Furthermore, QED is an Abelian gauge theory, and gauge symmetry prevents the inclusion of an explicit mass term for the photon in the Lagrangean. The reasoning on an explicit mass term in the Lagrangean applies also to the gauge sector of non-Abelian theories. As long as U(1) gauge symmetry is not a broken symmetry, the photon remains massless. In the perturbative Feynman diagrammatic expansion for QFT, the presence of zero-mass particles leads to low-momentum divergences. These can be prevented by replacing massless propagators with massive ones; that is, by assigning a fictitious small mass to the massless particles. Typically, the infrared problem associated with the presence of massless particles manifests as an infinite contribution to certain cross-sections. In QED, the computation of the Bremsstrahlung cross-section to lowest order in the coupling constant is a textbook example of this phenomenon. If the photon is indeed massless, then adding any number of zero-frequency photons |\gamma\rangle_{0} to a Fock-space state |\psi\rangle , results in a new state |\psi^{\prime}\rangle=|\psi\rangle\otimes|n\,\gamma\rangle_{0} that is degenerate in energy. Consequently, conventional Fock-space states are ill-defined. Furthermore, these infrared divergences imply that all S -matrix elements between conventional Fock-space states vanish. The infrared divergences in the computation of cross-sections between Fock-space states can be resolved by considering inclusive cross-sections. Summing over all possible final states hides the IR divergences beneath the experimental resolution Bloch:1937pw ; Yennie:1961ad ; Kinoshita:1962ur ; Lee:1964is , yielding a finite transition probability. Alternatively, one can replace the conventional Fock-space basis states with dressed states, where the Fock-space states are surrounded by clouds of soft photons. This approach solves the problem of IR divergences in QED Chung:1965zza ; Kibble:1968oug ; Kibble:1968npb ; Kibble:1968lka ; Kulish:1970ut but increases the complexity of any calculation. The introduction of infinitely degenerate vacuum states can also properly handle the infrared divergences of QED, provided one accounts for transitions between these different vacuum states Kapec:2017tkm ; Strominger:2017zoo . The infrared and ultraviolet divergences can be handled simultaneously within Bogolubov–Parasuk–Hepp–Zimmermann (BPHZ) renormalization procedure that relies on the R^{\star} -operation, see Chetyrkin:1982nn ; Chetyrkin:1984xa ; Herzog:2017ohr and references therein, and render finite probability transitions. Our objective is to discuss the infrared divergences in QED from the perspective of the Dyson-Schwinger equations (DSEs). The DSEs form an infinite tower of integral equations that relate all QED Green functions. For practical reasons, one must consider a truncated version of the full set. In this work, we consider only the equations for the fermion propagator (the gap equation), the photon propagator (the photon gap equation), and the photon-fermion one-particle irreducible Green function (photon-fermion vertex) integral equation. The discussion applies to a general linear covariant gauge, identified by the gauge-fixing parameter \xi . The integral equations will not be derived here, but the interested reader can find a derivation in Oliveira:2022bar , whose notation we adopt, or in, for example, Roberts:1994dr . As our starting point, we assume that the DSEs and the self-energies are finite. This is always the case before taking the limit i\epsilon\rightarrow 0 , and all manipulations should be understood as being performed with a small but non-vanishing \epsilon . We emphasize that our analysis does not require solving any of the integral equations. As will be discussed, the photon gap equation does not lead necessarily to an infrared finite photon propagator. However, the requirement of finiteness for the photon self-energy, together with a smooth behavior for the photon-fermion vertex, is equivalent to state that the photon is necessarily a massless particle. Furthermore, the photon propagator DSE implies also that the photon propagator diverges as 1/k^{2} for small photon momentum k . Thus, the requirement of finiteness for the self-energy links the infrared properties of QED, the masslessness of the photon, and the divergence of the photon propagator at low momentum. In addition to conventional QED, we investigate the Schwinger mechanism Schwinger:1962tn ; Schwinger:1962tp for photon mass generation, which can occur via a singular behavior in the transverse component of the photon-fermion vertex. We show that certain transverse components of the vertex can indeed generate a finite and non-vanishing photon mass, and we identify the specific components responsible for this effect via the Schwinger mechanism. However, within the Schwinger mechanism the photon is not necessarily a massless particle. Regarding the photon mass, we remind the reader that, as discussed in Oliveira:2025ftr , conventional perturbation theory results in a photon mass that is proportional to the fermion mass that appears in the loops. The fermion gap equation is also investigated and our conclusion is that it is infrared safe. The particular case of QED with chiral fermions is also studied. From the finiteness of the photon self-energy, the corresponding fermion propagator properties are derived. Surprisingly, it follows that the chiral fermion propagator exhibits an improved UV behavior compared to the conventional perturbative solution. The infrared properties of the DSE for the photon-fermion vertex are investigated by applying the same type of reasoning, enabling us to prove that the vertex is infrared finite, and is compatible with our initial assumption. All the results described, with the exception of those associated with the Schwinger mechanism, assume a smooth vertex behavior and require the DSEs to be finite. The analysis performed in the current work and its conclusions are independent of the value of the QED coupling constant. The results derived suggest that the typical infrared problems of perturbation theory are a limitation of the perturbative framework