Numbers and numerosities
Vieri Benci · 2025
Read Numbers and numerosities by Vieri Benci (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-02639.txt.
Introduction
Vieri Benci develops the theory of numerosity, a way to assign sizes to infinite sets that keeps more detail than the usual notions of infinity. His 2025 paper stresses how numerosity relates to ordinal numbers, cardinal numbers, hyperreal numbers, and surreal numbers, four frameworks that each extend counting in a different direction.
By joining numerosity with the idea of a continuum, Benci arrives at a definition of the Euclidean line, the straight line of classical geometry. That line, in his construction, contains all of the infinite number systems named above at once. The work is foundational rather than applied. It probes what a number system must look like if it is to host counting, ordering, and the continuum together, without giving up any of them.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Vieri Benci |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 121 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-02639
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Numbers and numerosities Vieri Benci Abstract We develop new aspects of the the of numerosity theory; more exactly, we emphasize its relation with the ordinal numbers, cardinal numbers, hyperreal numbers and surreal numbers. In particular, we combine the notion of numerosity with the idea of continuum and we get a definition of Euclidean line which includes all the sets of infinite numbers mentioned above. keywords: Euclid’s principle, Hume’s principle, numerosities, ordinal numbers, cardinal numbers, hyperreal numbers, surreal numbers, Euclidean line. 1 Introduction The theory of numerosity, introduced in [ 1 , 7 ] is a development of the classical cardinality for measuring the size of infinite sets. Unlike Cantor’s theory, where all countably infinite sets have the same cardinality, numerosity theory allows a finer distinction between different infinite sets and it preserves properties more aligned with our intuitive understanding of ”number of elements.” The notion of numerosity has been developed in several direction; see e.g. [ 5 , 8 , 3 , 11 , 17 , 18 , 9 , 29 , 30 , 31 , 32 ] and the references therein. In this paper we summarize some old results and present new aspects. In the first part we introduce the theory of numerosity in a new way. First we analyze the idea of number and we define the structure of counting system ; in this context, we present the notion of numerosity as a natural extension of the notion of natural number. In particular, we emphasize its relation with the ordinal numbers, cardinal numbers, hyperreal numbers and surreal numbers. The relation between numerosities, hyperreal numbers and surreal numbers is a new fulfillment and suggests further developments. Then, we build a model of the numerosities based on labelled sets as in [ 1 , 7 , 9 ] which allows to develop new features. 1.1 Preliminaries ad notation In principle it would be desirable to define the operation of ”counting” for the class of all sets; however, in order to develop the theory, it is convenient to work in a ”universe” which is itself a set provided that it is very large. Hence we will work in a universe in which the classes are replaced by sets of strongly inaccessible cardinality. Definition 1 A cardinal number \chi is inaccessible if it is not a sum of fewer than \chi cardinals that are less than \chi and \zeta<\chi implies 2^{\zeta}<\chi . \chi is strongly inaccessible if it is inaccessible and uncountable. The first inaccessible cardinal number is \aleph_{0}. The first strongly inaccessible cardinal number will be denoted by \mathbf{\kappa}. The existence of sets of strongly inaccessible cardinality is established by the Axiom of Inaccessibility which is independent from ZFC. We will assume this axiom and, in this paper, a set having strongly inaccessible cardinality will be called pseudoclass . We will assume that there exists a set of atoms 1 1 1 In set theory, an atom a is any entity that is not a set, namely a is an atom if and only if \forall x,\ x\notin a \mathbf{Ato} having cardinality \mathbf{\kappa} . Moreover we will denote by \mathbf{Card\ } the pseudoclass of the first \mathbf{\kappa} cardinal numbers an by \mathbf{Ord} the pseudoclass of the first \kappa ordinal numbers. The cardinality of a set X will be denoted by \left|X\right| . Given any set E, let V_{\beta}(E),\ \beta\in\mathbf{Ord,} be the superstructure on E , namely the family of sets which is inductively defined as follows: \displaystyle V_{0}(E) \displaystyle= \displaystyle E; \displaystyle V_{\beta+1}(E) \displaystyle= \displaystyle V_{\beta}(E)\cup\mathbf{\wp}\left(V_{\beta}(E)\right); \displaystyle V_{\beta}(E) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\bigcup\limits_{\gamma<\beta}V_{\gamma}(E)\ \text{if }\beta\text{ is a limit ordinal.} If A\in V_{\beta}(\mathbf{Ato})\backslash\bigcup\limits_{\gamma<\beta}V_{\gamma}(\mathbf{Ato}) , we say that A has rank \beta and we will write rank(A)=\beta. Now we set: \mathbf{U}_{\max}:=\bigcup\limits_{\gamma<\beta}\left\{E\in V_{\gamma}(\mathbf{Ato})\ |\ \ \left|E\right|<\mathbf{\kappa}\right\} It is well known that \mathbf{U}_{\max} is a model of ZFC and we can work in it without the problems related to the theory of classes. Definition 2 A set \mathbf{U}\subseteq\mathbf{U}_{\max}\backslash\mathbf{Ato} is called universe (of sets) if 1. A,B\in\mathbf{U}\Rightarrow A\cup B\in\mathbf{U} 2. A,B\in\mathbf{U}\Rightarrow A\times B\in\mathbf{U} 3. A\in\mathbf{U\ } and \mathbf{\ \ }B\subseteq A\Rightarrow B\in\mathbf{U} Moreover we shall use the following notation: • \mathbf{Inf} will denote the family of infinite subsets in \mathbf{U}_{\max}. • \mathbf{Fin} will denote the family of the finite subsets in \mathbf{U}_{\max}. • if E\in\mathbf{U,\ }\mathfrak{\wp}(E) will denote the family of subsets of E. • \mathfrak{\wp}_{\omega}(E):=\mathfrak{\wp}(E)\cap\mathbf{Fin} will denote the family of finite subsets of E • \mathfrak{F}(A,B) will denote the family of functions f:A\rightarrow B, namely \mathfrak{F}(A,B)=B^{A}. 2 Counting systems 2.1 The numbers One of the aims in counting the elements of sets is the comparison of their sizes. We denote by \preceq is a total preorder 2 2 2 We recall that a total preorder is a trnsitive and reflexive relation such that x\preceq y\ or y\preceq x . relation over \mathbf{U} and, as usual, we set X\cong Y:\Leftrightarrow\left(X\preceq Y\ \ \text{and\ \ }Y\preceq X\right). Definition 3 A comparison system is a couple (\mathbf{U},\preceq) where \mathbf{U} is a universe and \preceq is a total preorder relation, called comparison relation , which satisfies the following properties: 1. Null Set Principle: A\cong\varnothing, if and only if A=\varnothing. 2. Union Principle: If A\cap B=A^{\prime}\cap B^{\prime}=\varnothing,\ and A\cong A^{\prime},\ B\cong B^{\prime}, then A\cup B\cong A^{\prime}\cup B^{\prime} 3. Product Principle: If A\cong A^{\prime} and B\cong B^{\prime} ;then A\times B\cong B\times A\cong A^{\prime}\times B^{\prime}. 4. Unit Principle: \{a\}\times B\cong B 5. Comparison Principle: A\preceq B, if and only if there exists a set A^{\prime}\subseteq B such that A\cong A^{\prime}. If we have a comparison system, then it is possible to build the notion of number: Definition 4 A set of numbers \mathcal{N} is a set of atoms such that there exists a bijection \Phi:\mathbf{U}/\cong\ \rightarrow\mathcal{N} Then given a set A, the number of its elements is given by \mathfrak{n}(A)=\Phi\left(\left[A\right]_{\cong}\right) Notice that in every set of numbers there are two distinguished elements: 0:=\mathfrak{n}(\varnothing) and 1:=\mathfrak{n}(\left\{\varnothing\right\}). Since we have required \preceq to be a total preorder relation, the following fact follows: Proposition 5 The numbers is a linearly ordered set with respect to the following order relation: given \alpha=\mathfrak{n}(A) and \beta=\mathfrak{n}(B) \alpha\leq\beta:\Leftrightarrow A\preceq B. 2.1.1 Operations with numbers Given a set of numbers we can define also the two basic operations: the sum and the product. Definition 6 Given two numbers \alpha=\mathfrak{n}(A) and \beta=\mathfrak{n}(B)\ with A\cap B=\varnothing , we set \alpha+\beta:=\mathfrak{n}(A\cup B) By the Union Principle, it follows that the operation ”+” is well posed, namely it is independent of the choice of A and B . It is immediate to check that the sum satisfies the commutative property and the associative property since A\cup B=B\cup A and \left(A\cup B\right)\cup C=A\cup\left(B\cup C\right) Moreover we have that 0=\mathfrak{n}(\varnothing) is the identity element for the sum. It is obvious that two numbers can always be added and we have that \alpha+\beta=\mathfrak{n}(A)+\mathfrak{n}(B) : in fact if A\cap B\neq\varnothing, we can replace A with the set A\times\{c\} with c\notin A\cup B ; then, \left(A\times\{c\}\right)\cap B=\varnothing, and hence, \alpha+\beta=\mathfrak{n}(\left(A\times\{c\}\right)\cup B)=\mathfrak{n}(A\times\{c\})+\mathfrak{n}(B)=\mathfrak{n}(A)+\mathfrak{n}(B) Definition 7 Given two numbers \alpha=\mathfrak{n}(A) and \beta=\mathfrak{n}(B)\ with A,B as in Def. 3 -( 3 ), we set \alpha\cdot\beta:=\mathfrak{n}(A\times B) By the Union Principle, it follows that also the operation "\cdot" is well posed. In Def. 3 , we have imposed the commutative property. The associative property is satisfied if