A generic network theoretic based model to classify SDG indicators
Gaurav Kottari, Qazi J. Azhad, Niteesh Sahni · 2025
Read A generic network theoretic based model to classify SDG indicators by Gaurav Kottari, Qazi J. Azhad, Niteesh Sahni (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-02289.txt.
Introduction
Gaurav Kottari, Qazi Azhad, and Niteesh Sahni build a tool for governments deciding which of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals to push first. The goals' many indicators are interlinked, so progress on one can accelerate others. Most research studies those links at the level of whole goals while policy is made at the level of individual indicators and targets. The authors review the existing prioritisation methods and find important drawbacks in them.
Their model represents the indicators as a network and uses network theory to quantify each indicator's importance for maximum combined benefit. The method is generic, meant to work for any country, and the team illustrates it with data from India, naming the indicators that matter most there. Supporting evidence from the published literature backs several of the key observations.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gaurav Kottari, Qazi J. Azhad, Niteesh Sahni |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-02289
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A generic network theoretic based model to classify SDG indicators Gaurav Kottari, Qazi J. Azhad, Niteesh Sahni Abstract To achieve the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, coordinated action across their interlinked indicators is required. Although most of the research on the interlinkages of the SDGs is done at the goal level, policies are usually made and implemented at the level of indicators (or targets). Our study examines the existing literature on SDG interlinkages and indicator (or target) prioritization, highlighting important drawbacks of current methodologies. To address these limitations, we propose a generic network-based model that can quantify the importance of the SDG indicators and help policymakers in identifying indicators for maximum synergistic impact. Our model applies to any country, offering a tool for national policymakers. We illustrate the application of this model using data from India, identifying important indicators that are crucial for accelerating progress in the SDGs. While our main contribution lies in developing this network-theoretic methodology, we also provide supporting empirical evidence from existing literature for selected key observations. Keywords: classification, network, SDG indicator, synergy, trade-off 1. Introduction Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) were adopted by the member states of the United Nations in 2015, which is a universal call to eradicate poverty, protect the environment, and guarantee peace and prosperity for all by 2030 [ Assembly, 2015 ] . It addresses a wide range of social, economic, and environmental issues and consists of 17 goals and 169 related targets. Progress toward one goal rarely occurs in isolation because these objectives are wide-ranging and interrelated. Improvements in fields such as health, education, or clean energy can support successes in other fields, but they can also lead to unexpected setbacks or new pressures in other areas. Therefore, identifying these interdependencies is essential for understanding the overall dynamics of sustainable development. Since each goal is further broken down into specific targets that guide concrete actions and measurement, it becomes important to study interactions not only among goals but also among their underlying targets, where the most direct trade-offs and synergies often emerge. Analyzing the interlinkages between the targets is essential to find synergies that can speed up progress, and trade-offs that could impede it [ Allen et al., 2019 ] . To address this need for understanding interlinkages, existing studies have employed two broad approaches: qualitative and quantitative. In qualitative studies, the strength of the interlinkages between targets is determined by expert opinions, policy analysis, or literature reviews [ Allen et al., 2019 , Nilsson et al., 2016 , Weitz et al., 2018 , Tremblay et al., 2020 , Pham-Truffert et al., 2020 , Xiao et al., 2023 , Fader et al., 2018 ] . In contrast, quantitative studies establish these strengths of interlinkage in a data-driven manner, often using techniques such as pairwise correlation analysis or principal component analysis on indicator-level datasets [ Pradhan et al., 2017 , de Miguel Ramos and Laurenti, 2020 , Hegre et al., 2020 , Kostetckaia and Hametner, 2022 , Miao et al., 2025 ] . Because policy interventions are made at the level of specific indicators, determining which of these are synergistic becomes essential for maximizing development gains. By “synergistic”, we mean indicators whose progress tends to produce net positive effects across other indicators, where the positive spillovers from improving these indicators outweigh any negative effects on others. Since interventions on these indicators reinforce progress not only within their immediate domain but also across multiple interconnected areas, identifying such indicators guarantees that available resources are invested in generating the maximum systemic payoffs. Also, finding indicators that entail substantial trade-offs is equally important. If taken carelessly, actions based on these indicators could unintentionally impede or even reverse progress in other areas. Policymakers can create strategies that maximize the overall efficiency and effectiveness of sustainable development efforts by strengthening complementarities while minimizing potential conflicts because they are aware of the indicators that generate trade-offs as well as those that reinforce synergies. Ranganathan and Swain [ Swain and Ranganathan, 2021 ] proposed a methodology using network theory to prioritize SDG indicators. They constructed regional correlational networks of SDG indicators and applied a medium correlation threshold of 0.5 , thus considering both strong synergies (correlations >0.5 ) and strong trade-offs (correlations <–0.5 ). Their results showed that strong negative correlations were absent in the four global regions (OECD, East Asia, Latin America, and MENA). Only one was observed in Sub-Saharan Africa, and two in South Asia. Since the net impact of trade-offs appeared to be weak, they used centrality measures to identify the most influential indicators in each regional network. However, when we applied this methodological approach to the data set for India, we observed a substantial number of trade-offs, many with significant negative correlations (below –0.9 ). This contradicts the regional results revealed in their study [ Swain and Ranganathan, 2021 ] , where such strong trade-offs were rarely observed. This observation suggests that while the method proposed by Ranganathan and Swain [ Swain and Ranganathan, 2021 ] is useful in broader regional contexts, it may not be directly applicable to national or local-level decision-making. In 2023, Song and Jang [ Song and Jang, 2023 ] suggested another framework to rank SDG targets, by constructing a network based on the similarity between target keywords using semantic analysis. Their approach only establishes a link when two targets share moderate semantic similarities. This method, however, overlooks the possibility of trade-offs between targets, which are crucial for understanding the full range of interactions. The drawbacks observed at the national level highlight the need for a more flexible method of identifying important indicators. In this paper, we propose a generic model that addresses key limitations of existing approaches. Our methodology allows more flexibility and adaptability across several nations by not depending on fixed correlation cutoffs. In addition, it explicitly captures both synergies and trade-offs between indicators, allowing a more comprehensive and country-specific classification of SDG indicators into synergy-dominated and trade-off-dominated. In this paper, we make several contributions. First, we formalize the definition of when an indicator can be considered synergy-dominated or trade-off–dominated. To the best of our knowledge, such a measure has not been proposed in the existing literature, where researchers have mainly focused on quantifying the pairwise strength of relationships between indicators. Our formulation instead provides a way to assess the overall systemic influence of a particular indicator across the network. Second, to demonstrate the practical utility of the model, we conduct a case study using SDG indicator data for India. We classify the indicators into synergy-dominated and trade-off–dominated categories, highlighting those that generate strong positive spillovers and those that create widespread negative effects. Notably, we find that access to piped water is trade-off–dominated: investments in this indicator exhibit negative correlations with several other indicators, especially those related to health. This suggests that while improving piped water coverage is valuable in itself, it may simultaneously introduce new systemic challenges. Finally, we validate our findings by comparing them with existing sector-specific research. In particular, studies focusing on piped water provision report similar adverse interactions with health outcomes, supporting the robustness of our model’s results. The structure of this paper is as follows. Section 2 outlines the construction of complete weighted SDG