Screened Thin-Target Bremsstrahlung with Partially-Ionized High-Z Species

S. Guinchard, Y. Savoye-Peysson, J. Decker · 2025

Read Screened Thin-Target Bremsstrahlung with Partially-Ionized High-Z Species by S. Guinchard, Y. Savoye-Peysson, J. Decker (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-02098.txt.

Introduction

Salomon Guinchard, Yves Savoye-Peysson, and Joan Decker present an analytic model for bremsstrahlung, the radiation electrons emit when they are deflected by atomic nuclei. Reading electron behaviour in high-energy settings depends on describing this emission well. For thin targets containing heavy elements, the electric field of the nucleus is partly screened by its own electrons. That screening changes when atoms are partially ionised, as they often are in hot matter.

The model represents the atomic potential as a sum of Yukawa terms. That yields cross sections for any nuclear charge and ionisation state, for electron energies up to a few tens of MeV (million electron volts). Earlier analytic treatments covered neutral atoms; this framework extends them to partially ionised heavy species.

Catalog record

CREATORS. Guinchard, Y. Savoye-Peysson, J. Decker
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE70 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-02098

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Screened Thin-Target Bremsstrahlung with Partially-Ionized High-Z Species S. Guinchard, Y. Savoye-Peysson, J. Decker Abstract Bremsstrahlung emission remains a cornerstone process in the characterization of electron dynamics in diverse high-energy environments. In particular, the accurate description of thin-target electron-ion bremsstrahlung in the presence of high- Z Z species requires careful treatment of atomic screening effects, especially when atoms are partially ionized. We present a fully analytic screening model based on a multi-Yukawa representation of the atomic potential, enabling the calculation of bremsstrahlung cross sections for arbitrary nuclear charge and ionization state, and electron energies up to a few tens of MeV. This framework extends prior treatments of neutral atoms to include partially ionized high- Z Z elements in a fully analytic framework. Keywords: Bremsstrahlung, Born approximation, Cross section, QED, Relativistic scattering, Screened bremsstrahlung, Furry–Sommerfeld–Maue. I Introduction Accurate and computationally efficient descriptions of thin-target bremsstrahlung remain a central objective of theoretical and applied radiation physics. Building on the foundational analyses of Sauter Sau 34 , Bethe–Heitler BH 34 , and Racah Rac 34 , together with practical prescriptions such as the so-called additivity rule OMW 57 and atomic models for screening Tho 27 ; Fer 28 ; Mol 47 , modern studies concentrate on two tightly interwoven challenges: (i) the systematic inclusion of Coulomb distortion beyond the first Born approximation in a form that remains analytically tractable, and (ii) a faithful representation of atomic screening that smoothly covers charge states from neutral atoms to highly stripped ions. Both challenges are essential for constructing a single method that can reproduce experiments and benchmark calculations across the largest possible range of parameters. The theoretical basis for such developments is the scattering-theory framework in which bremsstrahlung cross sections follow from Fermi’s golden rule Fer 50 ; Sch 68 (see Sec. II ). In this paper we restrict attention to the thin-target, single-collision regime for electron energies up to a few tens of MeV, where quantum-coherence suppression effects (e.g. Landau–Pomeranchuk–Migdal LP53b ; LP53a ; Mig 56 ) are negligible. We note that fully rigorous S-matrix (Furry-picture) treatments Fur 51 ; JR 55 , coupled to double Dirac partial-wave (PW) expansions (the route pioneered by Tseng & Pratt TP 71 , and developed by Pratt and collaborators LKPT 76 ; PTL+ 77 ) provide the most accurate nuclear-bremsstrahlung results available, but they require heavy numerical machinery and become prohibitive as the number of required PW increases exponentially with energy PT 75 ; YS 10 ; JA 21 . We do not consider that PW S-matrix route in the present work. Instead, we focus on analytic and semi-analytic expressions that are directly compatible with our screening ansatz. A recurring limitation of analytic bremsstrahlung treatments is the incorporation of screening. Classical prescriptions (Molière parameterizations Mol 47 , Thomas–Fermi–like screening lengths Tho 27 ; Fer 28 , and tabulated atomic form factors HVB+ 75 ; SMMP 87 ) describe neutral-atom behavior but do not by themselves provide a compact analytic route to interpolate across charge states. Alternative analytic screening laws have also been proposed, such as the Thomas–Fermi–Kirillov form (TFK), which replaces the Yukawa exponential by a power n=3/2 KTT 75 , see Eq. ( 32 ), but these remain difficult to integrate consistently into bremsstrahlung cross-section formalisms. Model-potential approaches, most notably that of Avdonina and Pratt AP 93 , provide analytic screened atomic form factors (AFF) and explicitly address ionic charge states, demonstrating that screening significantly alters spectral and polarization observables. Their framework, however, relies on a specific one-parameter potential and is not easily generalized to reproduce high-quality tabulations or to interpolate smoothly between neutral and bare-ion limits. At the same time, investigations of Coulomb corrections emphasize that screening and higher-order distortion must be treated together to achieve percent-level accuracy in the application-relevant \sim 1–100 MeV window and for moderate to high- Z targets RDP 72 ; MM 16 . To overcome these difficulties, we introduce an analytic AFF representation built from a finite sum of Yukawa screening potentials Hau 08 ; SPMB+ 23 . Each term admits a simple analytic momentum-space component suitable for insertion into differential cross sections, while the linear combination can be fitted to high-quality atomic data (Dirac–Hartree–Fock–Slater (DHFS) fits SMMP 87 ; FTS+ 16 ; FGJB 19 or Hubbell tabulations HVB+ 75 ) and adjusted to account for removed bound charge, thereby extending from neutral atoms to fully stripped ions. Practically, screening is implemented by adding the fitted multi-Yukawa (MY) form factor into the Bethe–Heitler (BH) differential cross section while higher-order Coulomb distortion is retained through the Roche–Ducos–Proriol (RDP) expression for the unscreened contribution RDP 72 . Following the Olsen–Maximon–Wergeland (OMW) additivity rule OMW 57 (see Sec. II ), the screened doubly differential cross section is obtained as the sum of the unscreened, exact expression in a pure Coulomb field, and a screening correction in the first Born approximation, such that both neutral-atom and bare-nucleus limits are preserved. The result is a compact, rapidly evaluable expression for the doubly differential cross section (DDCS) that is inexpensive compared with full PW models. The motivation for such a compact and accurate treatment spans several application domains. Relativistic electrons physics in nuclear fusion experiments PD 08 , radiation-safety calculations, and astrophysical radiative-transfer problems KMTY 88 ; CRB 20 , among others, all require reliable bremsstrahlung cross sections for partially ionized targets. Recent advances in unified atomic physics models for Fokker–Planck solvers SPMB+ 23 , underline the need for analytic parameterizations that interpolate smoothly across charge states without reliance on large precomputed databases such as open-ADAS Sum 04 . The present scheme is designed for direct integration into such kinetic and transport frameworks, offering fast evaluation and high accuracy. The aims of the paper are therefore: (i) to present the multi-Yukawa AFF representation as a practical model for screening across ionization degrees; (ii) to derive bremsstrahlung differential cross sections obtained by combining this representation with a Sommerfeld–Maue-based formalism and consistent Coulomb corrections following the OMW additivity rule; and (iii) to validate the resulting scheme through systematic comparisons with existing models and experiments Mot 55 ; SK 56 ; RD 67 ; RE 72 ; PT 75 . The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section II recalls the unscreened bremsstrahlung formalism from Fermi’s golden rule, and introduces the unscreened components of the model, namely the RDP and unscreened BH differential cross sections. Section III defines the MY AFF and incorporates it in the derivation of the DDCS. Section IV presents the numerical results and comparisons with experiments, and Section V summarizes conclusions and outlines future applications. II Theoretical Framework for Electron–Ion Bremsstrahlung In the present work, we assume that the reader is familiar with the theory of bremsstrahlung, and in particular with how the differential cross sections for bremsstrahlung interactions are derived. We recall that all formulae considered in this work originate from Fermi’s golden rule Fer 50 ; Sch 68 that we remind here: \displaystyle\frac{d^{3}\sigma_{e-i}}{dkd\Omega_{k}d\Omega_{p}} \displaystyle:=\frac{\alpha}{(2\pi)^{4}}\lambdabar_{C}^{2}\frac{E_{0}Epk}{p_{0}}\frac{1}{2}\sum_{s,s_{0},\mathbf{e^{*}}}|M|^{2} (1) \displaystyle M \displaystyle:=\int\psi^{\dagger}(\mathbf{r})(\bm{\alpha}\mathbf{\cdot e^{*}})e^{-\frac{i}{\lambdabar_{C}}\bm{k\cdot r}}\psi_{0}(\mathbf{r})d^{3}\mathbf{r}. (2) The symbols involved are the usual for the context: \sigma_{e-i} denotes the cross-section, \alpha is the fine structure constant and \lambdabar_{C} the reduced Compton wavelength of the electron. \Omega_{k},\Omega_{p} denote the solid angles of emission for the photon and scattering of the

Read the complete text