Regularization Through Reasoning: Systematic Improvements in Language Model Classification via Explanation-Enhanced Fine-Tuning

Vivswan Shah, Randy Cogill, Hanwei Yue, Gopinath Chennupati, Rinat KhazievAmazon Central Analytics and Research Science · 2025

Read Regularization Through Reasoning: Systematic Improvements in Language Model Classification via Explanation-Enhanced Fine-Tuning by Vivswan Shah, Randy Cogill, Hanwei Yue, Gopinath Chennupati, Rinat KhazievAmazon Central Analytics and Research Science (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-02044.txt.

Introduction

Vivswan Shah, Randy Cogill, Hanwei Yue, Gopinath Chennupati, and Rinat Khaziev test a simple idea for training language models to classify text: attach a short explanation to each training label. They rate conversational replies for naturalness, completeness, and staying on topic, using data generated by an ensemble of models to fine-tune a model with seven billion parameters.

Across six datasets and eighteen settings, training with explanations beat label-only training. Surprisingly, even nonsense explanations, made by shuffling the real ones, kept much of the benefit. The authors argue the extra tokens act as a regularizer, forcing richer internal computation before a decision, a claim supported by measurements of the model's internal activity.

Catalog record

CREATORVivswan Shah, Randy Cogill, Hanwei Yue, Gopinath Chennupati, Rinat KhazievAmazon Central Analytics and Research Science
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE57 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-02044

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Regularization Through Reasoning: Systematic Improvements in Language Model Classification via Explanation-Enhanced Fine-Tuning Vivswan Shah, Randy Cogill, Hanwei Yue, Gopinath Chennupati, Rinat KhazievAmazon Central Analytics and Research Science Abstract Traditional approaches to fine-tuning large language models for classification applications rely on direct label prediction without additional context. This work explores the impact of augmenting classification labels with explanatory text during the fine-tuning process to enhance model performance. Our investigation centers on evaluating conversational response quality across three dimensions: naturalness of language use, response comprehensiveness, and adherence to conversational topics, each assessed using 5-point rating scales. We employ ensemble-generated training data from multiple large language modelTraditional approaches to fine-tuning large language models for classification applications rely on direct label prediction without additional context. This work explores the impact of augmenting classification labels with explanatory text during the fine-tuning process to enhance model performance. Our investigation centers on evaluating conversational response quality across three dimensions: naturalness of language use, response comprehensiveness, and adherence to conversational topics, each assessed using 5-point rating scales. We employ ensemble-generated training data from multiple large language models to fine-tune a 7B parameter architecture, subsequently testing performance across six diverse conversational datasets. The experimental results demonstrate that models trained with combined label-explanation pairs achieve superior performance compared to label-only training approaches across all 18 dataset-task configurations tested. Remarkably, our experiments reveal that models benefit from explanatory content even when it consists of certain types of randomly generated word sequences that maintain vocabulary overlap with original explanations, indicating that structured noise can function as a regularization mechanism during the training process. Internal model analysis demonstrates that explanation-augmented training produces models with elevated entropy levels in intermediate computational layers coupled with more concentrated prediction confidence in output layers, suggesting enhanced deliberation processes prior to final decision-making. These results establish that explanation-augmented fine-tuning represents a viable approach for enhancing both accuracy and reliability in language model classification applications, while simultaneously offering valuable understanding of how explanatory components shape model computational patterns during inference. 1 Introduction Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities across diverse natural language processing tasks ( Zhang et al. 2023 ) , excelling particularly in text generation and complex reasoning scenarios ( Mula et al. 2023 ) . However, adapting these models for domain-specific classification tasks through fine-tuning presents unique challenges ( Bai et al. 2022 ) . A critical concern is ensuring that fine-tuned models develop robust decision-making processes rather than exploiting superficial correlations between inputs and labels ( Aghajanyan et al. 2023 ) . This challenge becomes particularly pronounced in conversational quality evaluation, where models must demonstrate nuanced understanding of multiple communication aspects simultaneously. Building on recent advances in explanation-based learning ( Lampinen et al. 2022 ; Zhao et al. 2024 ) , this paper investigates how incorporating explanations during fine-tuning affects model performance on conversational quality assessment tasks. We focus on three fundamental dimensions of conversation quality: naturalness of language, comprehensiveness of responses, and adherence to topic. These dimensions represent critical components of effective human-computer interaction and are applicable across diverse conversational contexts ( Zheng et al. 2023 ) . For each dimension, models learn to predict ratings on a 5-point scale, with higher scores indicating superior quality. Our experimental approach centers on fine-tuning a 7B parameter student model using training data generated from an ensemble of larger teacher models. This methodology leverages the knowledge of more capable teacher models while maintaining the computational efficiency of smaller student models for practical deployment ( Ho et al. 2022 ) . We systematically compare two fine-tuning strategies: training exclusively on class labels versus training on both class labels and natural language explanations that justify those labels. To ensure comprehensive evaluation, we test these approaches across 6 diverse conversational datasets, evaluating performance on 3 quality dimensions each, yielding 18 distinct dataset-task combinations that span various conversational contexts and domains. Our investigation reveals a consistent pattern: models fine-tuned with explanations outperform those trained on labels alone across all 18 dataset-task combinations. The improvement is robust and generalizable, occurring regardless of the specific conversational domain or quality dimension being evaluated. Intriguingly, even when explanations consist of random word sequences, models still achieve better performance than baseline approaches, suggesting that explanation tokens may provide regularization benefits during training. To understand the mechanisms underlying these performance gains, we conducted comprehensive analyses of model internals and behavior patterns. Our entropy analysis across transformer layers reveals that explanation-trained models maintain higher uncertainty in intermediate processing stages while producing more confident final predictions. This suggests a fundamentally different decision-making process: explanation-trained models appear to explore multiple possibilities more thoroughly before converging on their final outputs, whereas models trained without explanations commit to decisions earlier in their computational pipeline. We also investigate how explanation characteristics affect learning outcomes. Our experiments with varying explanation lengths demonstrate that substantial benefits can be achieved with relatively short explanations (25-50 words), with diminishing returns for longer texts. Analysis of explanation content reveals that the most informative portions typically appear at the beginning, providing early contextual cues that guide the model’s reasoning process. Our contributions are threefold. First, we provide systematic empirical evidence that explanation-based fine-tuning consistently improves classification performance across diverse conversational domains. Second, we offer mechanistic insights into how explanations influence model behavior, revealing distinct computational patterns in explanation-trained versus standard fine-tuned models. Third, we demonstrate practical applications of these findings, showing how explanation-based approaches can enhance model robustness and generalization capabilities. These results have important implications for language model development and deployment. They suggest that incorporating explanations during fine-tuning represents a practical strategy for improving model reliability and performance, particularly in applications requiring nuanced judgment and robust generalization. Our work also opens new research directions in understanding how auxiliary training objectives can shape model learning dynamics and decision-making processes. Figure 1: The objective for this study is to minimize the difference between human and LLM rating. 2 Background and Related Work 2.1 Related Work The integration of explanations in machine learning has garnered significant attention as a means to improve model performance and interpretability. Camburu et al. 2018 pioneered the use of natural language explanations in NLP with e-SNLI, demonstrating that models can be trained to generate explanations alongside predictions for natural language inference tasks. This work established the foundation for explanation-augmented training in language models. Recent advances in explanation-based fine-tuning have shown promising results across various domains. Aghajanyan et al. 2023 demonstrated that explanation-based fine-tuning makes models more robust to spurious correlations, leading to better generalization on challenging inference tasks. Similarly, Zhao et al. 2024 investigated the role of explanations in fine-tuning and found that explanation-augmented training consistently improves model performance compared to standard approaches. The development of reasoning capabilities in smaller language models has been a key focus of recent research. Mula et al. 2023 showed that smaller models can achieve remarkable performance when trained with step-by-step explanations from larger teacher models, while Ho et al. 2022 demonstrated effective methods for teaching reasoning to small language models through explanation-based fine-tuning. These works highlight the potential for explanation-based approaches to bridge the performance gap between large and small models. Lampinen et al. 2022 provided a formal framework for understanding when and how models can learn from explanations,

Read the complete text