The curious case of parabolic encounters: gravitational waves with linear & non-linear memory
Samik Dutta, Ankur Chhabra, Aritra Banerjee, Sajal Mukherjee, and Subhendra Mohanty · 2025
Read The curious case of parabolic encounters: gravitational waves with linear & non-linear memory by Samik Dutta, Ankur Chhabra, Aritra Banerjee, Sajal Mukherjee, and Subhendra Mohanty (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01968.txt.
Introduction
Samik Dutta, Ankur Chhabra, Aritra Banerjee, Sajal Mukherjee, and Subhendra Mohanty compute gravitational waves from a flyby. Two massive objects swing past each other on a parabolic path. That path is the knife-edge between elliptical and unbound hyperbolic encounters. Such flybys carry the gravitational wave memory effect. It is a permanent displacement left in detectors after the wave passes. It comes in a linear form tied to the source, and a nonlinear form sourced by the waves themselves.
The authors warn against a shortcut. Extrapolating memory formulas from eccentric or hyperbolic cases to the parabola gives wrong answers. So they treat the parabolic case intrinsically, with its parameterization. Within effective field theory, it derives the signals and their energy spectrum. New features appear in the zero-frequency limit, absent in the hyperbolic case. The study uses the parabola as a separatrix to expose the challenges of memory physics.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Samik Dutta, Ankur Chhabra, Aritra Banerjee, Sajal Mukherjee, and Subhendra Mohanty |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01968
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The curious case of parabolic encounters: gravitational waves with linear & non-linear memory Samik Dutta, Ankur Chhabra, Aritra Banerjee, Sajal Mukherjee, and Subhendra Mohanty Abstract The memory effect is known to introduce a permanent displacement in the gravitational wave (GW) detectors after the passage of a GW signal. While the linear memory adheres to the source properties, the non-linear memory is a secondary effect sourced by the GW itself. In the present work, we discuss GW signals with both these kinds of memory effects, while focusing on the parabolic limit of an encounter. This special case is theoretically intriguing and emerges as a limiting situation for both eccentric and hyperbolic events. However, in this paper, we argue that a simple extrapolation of memory calculations for eccentric or hyperbolic cases to the parabolic case may lead to incorrect estimations. Therefore, we treat the parabola as a special case and use an intrinsic parameterization, with which we calculate gravitational wave signals and their energy spectrum via an effective field theory formalism. Unlike the hyperbolic case, which is known to have linear memory, we notice that parabolic encounters bring out new features in the zero frequency limit (ZFL). Our work highlights some of the key challenges and salient aspects of these encounters, and paves the way to study such binary evolution with nonzero memory. 1 Introduction & Motivation The detection of GWs by the LIGO-Virgo-Kagra (LVK) collaboration LIGOScientific:2016aoc has opened a new window to explore the universe . It provides an excellent scope for testing predictions of Einsteinian gravity LIGOScientific:2021sio ; PhysRevD.103.122002 ; universe7120497 , and possibly constrain alternatives to general relativity (GR) PhysRevD.108.024027 ; Arun13:altgr . While it is of interest to continue exploring events such as mergers with present detectors Abac_2025 , there is significant motivation to model relativistic effects that are prime targets for future GW detectors PhysRevD.107.064048 ; PhysRevD.110.122006 . GW memory Zeldovich:1974gvh ; Braginsky:1985vlg is one such possible effect that could serve as a potential source for upcoming detectors like Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA) LISA:2022kgy ; PhysRevD.111.044044 ; Ghosh_2023 , Cosmic Explorer (CE) LIGOScientific:2016wof ; Grant:2022bla , and Einstein Telescope (ET) Hild:2010id ; Goncharov:2023woe . A GW signal with nonzero memory manifests as a permanent relative displacement of two detectors at the early and late time Favata_2010 . Such a signal is characterized by the difference between asymptotic values of the strain amplitudes in particular polarizations: \Delta h_{+,\times}^{mem}=\lim_{t\to\infty}h_{+,\times}(t)-\lim_{t\to-\infty}h_{+,\times}(t), (1) and a nonzero value of the above would render the fact that there is a permanent separation before and after the wave passes, and hence a nonzero memory! The GW memory is primarily categorized into two, namely, linear and non-linear. While linear memory is present in specific GW sources, in contrast, the non-linear memory can be associated with any GW source. For example, a binary on an unbound/hyperbolic orbit, with sources that go through non-oscillatory motion, can emit GWs with nonzero linear memory. Similarly, asymmetry can also introduce a GW memory, which can often be found in supernova explosion Burrows:1995bb ; Kotake:2005zn ; Murphy:2009dx , neutrino emission Epstein:1978dv ; Turner:1978jj , kicks Favata:2008ti and gamma-ray burst jets Takashi:2005 ; Sago:2004 ; Segalis:2001 . Interestingly, these effects pertaining to linear memory will affect the emitted GW, and may cause a dephasing 10.1093/mnras/stz2925 ; Vartanyan_2020 . On the other hand, non-linear memory (or Christodoulou memory) Blanchet:1992br ; Payne ; Christodoulou:1991cr is a second-order effect and originates due to the stress-energy tensor of GWs themselves, more precisely due to the self interaction thereof Misner:1973prb . The stress energy tensor is proportional to the GW energy radiation, and therefore, the perturbation too is proportional to GW radiation. It turns out that the oscillatory part of the non-linear GW appears at a 2.5 PN order, while the non-oscillatory part kicks in at an order higher than that Favata:2011qi . There has been some recent progress in this particular aspect, particularly in detecting memory effects through GW observations PhysRevD.111.044044 ; PhysRevD.101.083026 ; Ghosh_2023 . The upcoming detectors, such as LISA, CE, and ET, are expected to achieve sensitivities that could discern non-linear memory from binary mergers Goncharov:2023woe ; Grant:2022bla . If detected, distinctly from other non-linear effects, non-linear memory will definitely shed light on processes involving graviton-graviton coupling or the sheer non-linear nature of Einstein’s field equations 1 1 1 For such linear/non-linear memory waveforms used in the context of detectors, one can see Detect1 ; Detect2 ; Detect3 . For numerical relativity (NR) based approaches, the reader is referred to Pollney:2010hs ; Mitman:2020bjf and references therein. . With the above discussion stored as background, we can now realize that unbound sources like hyperbolic encounters do have both linear and non-linear memory Favata:2011qi ; Hait:2022ukn . However, the bound eccentric orbits, on the other hand, only have non-linear memory and no linear memory component Favata:2011qi ; Hait:2022ukn , a fact easily attributed to the symmetry in velocity asymptotes. In this paper, we discuss a very specific case, i.e., what happens when the eccentricity becomes 1 , and we have parabolic encounters! These encounters are expected to be common in dense clusters and provide an interesting parameter space to study high eccentric GW observations Kocsis:2006hq ; OLeary:2008myb . Several studies expand on the formation of binaries through captures PhysRevD.102.083016 ; Gondan:2020svr ; Gond_n_2022 , while marking the importance of the parabolic limit Bae:2017crk ; Gond_n_2018 . These events may provide a closer look at the strong field regime since they represent marginally bound orbits where one compact object may momentarily pass very close to another compact body. In contrast to widely separated orbits, one expects that the burst produced during such a brief but intense encounter would contain these signatures within Mukherjee:2020hnm . In the present context, our motivation is primarily theory-driven and two-fold. First, we would like to have a deeper look at the linear memory component in parabolic encounters. To be more precise, we would first like to understand how eccentricity ( e ) ranges from hyperbolic signals with memory ( e>1 ) to the eccentric ones without memory ( e<1 ), and especially how orbits behave at the e\rightarrow 1 limit. It turns out that the last bit has some very subtle difficulties to be achieved smoothly. In doing so, one would also like to take a look at an approach to memory grounded in Quantum Field Theory (QFT), viz. the soft-graviton theorem weinberg1965photons ; weinberg1965infrared which connects low frequency graviton emission phenomena to the memory effect . Specifically, the zero frequency regime of the amplitude has a pole in frequency space sitting inside the kinematic factor that relates the hard and soft amplitudes, and this manifests as a irreversible step in the fourier space strominger2016gravitational . However, direct computations from this perspective also has some subtlety since it assumes the presence of well separated asymptotic states. We thus pursue calculating memory directly via a frequency space derivation of the energy radiated, by using the stress tensors of the parabolic orbits as a source and effectively computing the tree level amplitude. The other/second motivation of the paper is to work out the non-linear memory contribution to the parabolic encounters, which one does by using emitted gravitons themselves as a source. One would