Towards a Unified Framework for Statistical and Mathematical Modeling

Paul N Zivich · 2025

Read Towards a Unified Framework for Statistical and Mathematical Modeling by Paul N Zivich (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01960.txt.

Introduction

Paul Zivich argues that two cultures of quantitative science can share one language. One culture is statistical modeling. The other is mathematical modeling. Both aim to advance knowledge. Yet each grew its own vocabulary and its own habits of inference. They often talk past each other.

The shared language, Zivich argues, is identification from causal inference. He shows what this view means for reading, comparing, and joining models. A simple pharmacodynamic model of hypertension serves as the example. He also maps where the framework should grow next. The hope is to draw the two traditions into closer conversation. That would extend causal thinking well past its usual home in statistics.

Catalog record

CREATORPaul N Zivich
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01960

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Towards a Unified Framework for Statistical and Mathematical Modeling Paul N Zivich Abstract Within the biological, physical, and social sciences, there are two broad quantitative traditions: statistical and mathematical modeling. Both traditions have the common pursuit of advancing our scientific knowledge, but these traditions have developed largely independently using distinct languages and inferential frameworks. This paper uses the notion of identification from causal inference, a field originating from the statistical modeling tradition, to develop a shared language. I first review foundational identification results for statistical models and then extend these ideas to mathematical models. Central to this framework is the use of bounds, ranges of plausible numerical values, to analyze both statistical and mathematical models. I discuss the implications of this perspective for the interpretation, comparison, and integration of different modeling approaches, and illustrate the framework with a simple pharmacodynamic model for hypertension. To conclude, I describe areas where the approach taken here should be extended in the future. By formalizing connections between statistical and mathematical modeling, this work contributes to a shared framework for quantitative science. My hope is that this work will advance interactions between these two traditions. Introduction There are broadly two quantitative traditions in the biological, physical, and social sciences [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] . The first, I will refer to as statistical, empirical, or phenomenological modeling. Statistical modeling relies on using observations to estimate parameters of a model, with examples including randomized trials, regression, structural equation modeling, and g-methods [ 7 , 8 ] . The second, I will refer to as mathematical or mechanistic modeling. Mathematical modeling instead proceeds from a theoretical representation of a system through formulas that does not necessitate direct observations. Examples of this approach including dynamic (e.g., differential equations), microsimulation, and agent-based models [ 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] . Despite their differences in perspective, these traditions each seek to contribute to scientific knowledge. Given the broadness of this topic, I use some of the recent epidemiologic literature as an entry point. Murray et al. provided a comparison between a particular statistical model developed for causal inference, the parametric g-formula, to a microsimulation model for inferring time-varying causal effects [ 14 ] . That research inspired a wider discussion in epidemiology [ 15 , 16 ] , and subsequent work comparing these traditions [ 1 , 17 , 18 , 19 ] . However, less work has focused on studying both traditions from a shared perspective, with some exceptions [ 20 , 21 ] , which have mainly focused on the overlap of mathematical models and graphical causal models in epidemiology [ 18 , 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 ] . While there is no bright line between these traditions [ 19 ] , there remains more work to be done regarding formal comparisons within epidemiology and science more broadly. Here, I consider how to analyze mathematical models using tools from causal inference, a field growing out of the statistical modeling tradition that is popular in the medical and social sciences [ 26 , 27 ] . The proposed framework allows more direct comparisons between statistical and mathematical models through a shared language, which has been previously called for in epidemiology [ 19 ] . My approach to linking the two methodological traditions is through bounds [ 28 ] , or ranges of plausible numeric values, that address a scientific question. First, I review some known results regarding the bound for statistical models for causal effects. Next, I consider how to construct bounds for mathematical models. Some implications of these bounds are reviewed, and then I apply this framework with a simple case study to illustrate the potential of these ideas. Interest Parameter To help fix ideas, suppose our motivating scientific equation was to learn the effect of the tetanus vaccine on symptomatic tetanus in a specific population. One of the first steps in quantitative research is to translate this general scientific question into one that can be addressed through a numerical value, often referred to as the interest parameter [ 29 ] . An interest parameter that addresses this motivating question is the the average causal effect (ACE) [ 30 , 31 ] , which contrasts the case where everyone received the vaccine versus no one received the vaccine. Here, capital letters will be used to denote random variables with lowercase denoting possible realizations. Calligraphic letters denote the support, or the set of possible values that a random variable could take. Lowercase Greek letters will denote parameters with uppercase Greek letters denoting the parameter space (i.e., the set of possible values the parameter can take). To distinguish between equality and assignment, := will be used to denote assignment. To define causal effects, I will use Neyman potential outcomes [ 32 ] , where Y_{i}^{a} denotes the outcome unit i will have under vaccination status a , with a denoting tetanus vaccination and 0 denoting no vaccination for unit i . Therefore, each person has two potential outcomes in this context. Note that potential outcomes cannot be directly observed and can be thought of as a conceptual device with which causal effects can be defined. As tetanus is not considered to be human-to-human transmissible [ 33 ] , we can reasonably assume a person’s potential outcome only depends on their vaccination status (i.e., no interference). The ACE can then be written as \psi:=\mu_{1}-\mu_{0} , where \mu_{a}:=\Pr(Y^{a}=1\mid S=1) and \Pr(\cdot) is the probability function and conditioning on S=1 serves to remind us that our parameter is defined for a particular context or population located in time and space. Normally the S=1 is left implicit, but here it is written explicitly to emphasize that the parameter is defined for a particular context. To make the following notation more compact, I shorten \Pr(Y^{a}=1\mid S=1) as \Pr_{S=1}(Y^{a}=1) and \Pr(Y^{a}=1\mid X=x,S=1) as \Pr_{S=1}(Y^{a}=1\mid X=x) where X is a random variable. Note that \psi must take a value within the range [-1,1] following the axioms of probability [ 34 ] . This set of possible values for \psi (i.e., the parameter space) is denoted by \Psi . As potential outcomes are not directly observed, we consider assumptions that enable \psi to be learned. Identification Within the field of causal inference, the next task is to discern under what conditions the interest parameter would be identified, or expressed as a function of the observed data [ 29 , 35 ] . The steps that license this re-expression of our causal parameter in terms of the observable data can then be understood as claims about the world that allow for a causal interpretation of a quantitative analysis [ 36 ] . Identification can be further delineated. First, identification can be nonparametric or parametric . This modifier refers to whether there are parametric constraints placed on the observed data function. A second classification is partial versus point identification. Partial identification indicates that at best one can only determine a range of values for \psi that is proper subset of \Psi . This range of values is commonly referred to as the bounds (Figure 1 ) [ 28 ] . Alternatively, point identification provides

Read the complete text