Benchmarking Proton Tunneling Splittings with a Wavefunction-Based Double-Well Model: Application to the Formic Acid Dimer

Krishna Kingkar Pathak · 2025

Read Benchmarking Proton Tunneling Splittings with a Wavefunction-Based Double-Well Model: Application to the Formic Acid Dimer by Krishna Kingkar Pathak (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01903.txt.

Introduction

Krishna Kingkar Pathak builds a deliberately simple benchmark for one of quantum chemistry's basic effects. A proton tunnels through a hydrogen bond. That splits energy levels by a tiny amount, one that spectroscopy can measure. Fully multidimensional instanton and path-integral methods compute such splittings well, but a transparent one-dimensional model remains valuable for concepts and cross-checks.

Pathak's framework uses a Cornell-type double-well potential. It solves for the wavefunctions directly. It compares analytical WKB estimates with numerical finite-difference solutions, across barrier shapes. The two agree consistently. As a test case, the formic acid dimer's barrier is mapped onto a quartic double well matched to its reported height, and the model's splitting, about 0.037 inverse centimeters, matches the reduced-dimensional calculations of Qu and Bowman, while the comparison clarifies where one dimension must give way to many.

Catalog record

CREATORKrishna Kingkar Pathak
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE15 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01903

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Benchmarking Proton Tunneling Splittings with a Wavefunction-Based Double-Well Model: Application to the Formic Acid Dimer Krishna Kingkar Pathak Abstract Proton tunneling across hydrogen bonds is a fundamental quantum effect with implications for spectroscopy, catalysis, and biomolecular stability. While state-of-the-art instanton and path-integral methods provide accurate multidimensional tunneling splittings, simplified one-dimensional models remain valuable as conceptual and benchmarking tools. Here we develop a wavefunction-based framework for tunneling splittings using a Cornell-type double-well potential and apply it as a benchmark for hydrogen-bond tunneling. Analytical WKB estimates and numerical finite-difference solutions are compared across a range of barrier parameters, showing consistent agreement. As a test case, we map the formic acid dimer (FAD) barrier onto a quartic double-well model parameterized to reproduce the reported barrier height of V b ≈ 2848 ​ cm − 1 V_{b}\approx 2848\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}} . The resulting tunneling splitting of ∼ 0.037 ​ cm − 1 \sim 0.037\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}} matches the reduced-dimensional calculations of Qu and Bowman. The close agreement between numerical and semiclassical results highlights the pedagogical and diagnostic value of one-dimensional models, while comparison with molecular benchmarks clarifies their limitations relative to full multidimensional quantum treatments. 1 Introduction Proton transfer across hydrogen bonds is a prototypical quantum process in chemistry and biology. In strong, short hydrogen bonds, tunneling between equivalent donor and acceptor sites produces a characteristic vibrational level splitting that serves as a sensitive probe of nuclear quantum effects. Predicting these tunneling splittings accurately remains a long-standing challenge in quantum chemistry. Recent progress has been made using semiclassical instanton theory and path-integral simulations, which incorporate multidimensional vibrational couplings and yield quantitative agreement with experiment. [ 1 , 13 , 3 , 7 ] However, the complexity of these methods can obscure the simple scaling principles that govern tunneling behavior. For this reason, one-dimensional double-well models continue to play an important role as conceptual and benchmarking tools. [ 8 , 9 , 10 ] They provide transparent insight into the dependence of tunneling splittings on barrier height, separation, and curvature, and they allow direct tests of semiclassical approximations such as the WKB method. In this work, we construct a wavefunction-based double-well model using a Cornell-type potential, adapted from confinement physics, and evaluate tunneling splittings both numerically and semiclassically. Crucially, we test the model against a molecular benchmark: the formic acid dimer (FAD). By parameterizing a quartic double-well to reproduce the reduced-dimensional barrier height of V_{b}\approx 2848\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}} , we recover the tunneling splitting of \sim 0.037\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}} reported by Qu and Bowman. [ 17 ] This demonstrates the utility of simple one-dimensional models as reproducible benchmarks and clarifies their limitations relative to full multidimensional treatments. 2 Theoretical Framework We begin with the time-independent Schrödinger equation for a particle of mass m in a one-dimensional potential V(x) : -\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2m}\frac{d^{2}\psi(x)}{dx^{2}}+V(x)\psi(x)=E\psi(x). (1) To construct a symmetric double-well potential, we adapt the Cornell form, V(x)=-\frac{\alpha}{|x|}+\beta|x|, (2) where \alpha and \beta are positive constants. By shifting and symmetrizing this form, we generate a double-well profile suitable for modeling proton tunneling across hydrogen bonds. We introduce a wavefunction Ansatz motivated by the localized nature of states in each well: \psi(x)\approx A\left[\phi_{L}(x)\pm\phi_{R}(x)\right], (3) where \phi_{L} and \phi_{R} are trial functions localized in the left and right wells, respectively. The energy splitting \Delta E arises from the overlap of these localized states. Tunnelling splitting: two-state and semiclassical expressions In the two-state (tight-binding) picture, localized single-well states \phi_{L}(x) and \phi_{R}(x) form a 2\times 2 effective Hamiltonian with off-diagonal matrix element H_{LR}=\langle\phi_{L}|H|\phi_{R}\rangle, so that the lowest doublet splitting is \Delta E\;=\;E_{1}-E_{0}\;=\;2\,|H_{LR}|. (4) If the overlap S=\langle\phi_{L}|\phi_{R}\rangle is small and the isolated-well ground energy is E_{0}^{\rm(well)} , a simple estimate valid for weakly coupled wells is \Delta E\approx 2\,S\,E_{0}^{\rm(well)}. (5) This expression motivates the use of localized trial functions (Section 2) and analytical evaluation of overlap integrals for the Cornell-type ansatz. A complementary semiclassical estimate is provided by WKB/instanton theory. For a symmetric double well one obtains, to leading semiclassical order, \Delta E\;\approx\;\frac{\hbar\omega}{\pi}\,\exp\!\Big(-\frac{S}{\hbar}\Big), (6) where \omega is the harmonic frequency at the well minimum, \omega=\sqrt{\frac{V^{\prime\prime}(x_{\rm min})}{m}}, and S is the Euclidean action under the barrier, S\;=\;2\int_{x_{1}}^{x_{2}}\sqrt{2m\,[V(x)-E]}\,dx. (7) The integration limits x_{1}<x_{2} are the classical turning points that enclose the classically forbidden region and E is the energy used in the action (in practice we use the numerically obtained ground state energy E_{0} or the harmonic zero-point energy \tfrac{1}{2}\hbar\omega as appropriate). Equations ( 6 )–( 7 ) capture the exponential suppression of tunnelling and provide a semiclassical prefactor. In the present work we report (i) ansatz overlap estimates via explicitly evaluated integrals, (ii) WKB estimates obtained by numerical quadrature of S , and (iii) full finite-difference numerical diagonalization of the Hamiltonian. Agreement among these three approaches validates the model and clarifies the range of parameters where the one-dimensional approximation is reasonable. 3 Methodology The tunneling splitting was computed using two complementary approaches: 1. Analytical Approximation: We employed the WKB method [ 11 , 12 ] to estimate tunneling rates through the classically forbidden region, extracting the splitting as a function of barrier height V_{b} and separation d . 2. Numerical Solution: The Schrödinger equation was solved numerically via finite-difference discretization, allowing direct computation of the ground and first excited states. The splitting \Delta E=E_{1}-E_{0} was obtained as the difference between the two lowest eigenvalues. Potential parameters (\alpha,\beta) were chosen to yield realistic barrier heights consistent with hydrogen bond tunneling in biomolecular systems. All numerical calculations were implemented in Python using standard linear algebra solvers. Numerical parameters and convergence All numerical Schrödinger solutions reported in this work were obtained by finite-difference discretization of the kinetic operator on a uniform grid with second-order central differences. For the FAD quartic model the following parameters were used to produce the results shown in Table 3 and Figures 4 – 5 : • Proton mass: m_{p}=1.007276466812\ \mathrm{u} (converted to kg). • Spatial domain: x\in[-6a,6a] , where a=0.7236\ \text{\AA} (converted to meters). • Grid points: N=3000 (uniform grid spacing \Delta x ). • Hamiltonian construction: second-derivative finite-difference matrix with Dirichlet boundary conditions. • Eigenvalue solver: dense symmetric eigensolver for the lowest 6 states. We performed convergence tests with respect to grid density and box size. Table 1 shows the splitting \Delta E computed for three representative grid sizes at fixed domain [-6a,6a] , demonstrating that \Delta E converges to within the tolerance needed for comparison to reduced-dimensional literature values. Table 1 : Convergence of the computed splitting \Delta E (cm -1 ) for the FAD 1D quartic model as a function of grid size N . N \Delta x (Å) \Delta E (cm -1 ) 2000 0.0043 0.03712 2400 0.0036 0.03709 3000 0.0029 0.03710 4 Results and Discussion 4.1 Scaling of Tunneling Splittings in the Cornell-Type Model Figure 1 illustrates representative ground- and first-excited-state wavefunctions in the symmetric Cornell-type double-well potential. As expected, the states are nearly degenerate, localized in opposite wells, and mixed weakly by tunneling. Figure 2 shows the dependence of tunneling splittings \Delta E on barrier separation for different barrier heights V_{b} , showing the expected exponential decay. Figure 1 : Numerical ground-state (blue) and first-excited-state (red) wavefunctions in the symmetric Cornell-type double-well potential. The two states are nearly degenerate and localized in opposite wells, with a small admixture due to tunneling.

Read the complete text