SOME REMARKS ON THE OBJECTIVITY AND THERMODYNAMIC CONSISTENCY OF KORTEWEG-TYPE FLUIDS This paper is dedicated to Liliana Restuccia, because she is already closer to 60 than 50.
P. Ván · 2025
Read SOME REMARKS ON THE OBJECTIVITY AND THERMODYNAMIC CONSISTENCY OF KORTEWEG-TYPE FLUIDS This paper is dedicated to Liliana Restuccia, because she is already closer to 60 than 50. by P. Ván (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2511-01876.txt.
Introduction
Peter Ván writes a short note on Korteweg-type fluids. These are fluids whose stress depends on density gradients. They serve to model capillarity and phase interfaces. Two schools build their theory in unlike ways. One, from Dunn and Serrin, rests on the entropy principle and one line of argument about objectivity. A newer school uses weakly nonlocal thermodynamics.
Ván compares the two schools head-on. Their unlike objectivity arguments, he finds, lead to the same constitutive functions. So the seeming clash is not there. The real split lies in the pressure tensors each school allows for perfect Korteweg fluids. That split traces back to unlike symmetry demands made along the way. The note sorts what is mere convention from what is physics.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | P. Ván |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 20 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511-01876
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
SOME REMARKS ON THE OBJECTIVITY AND THERMODYNAMIC CONSISTENCY OF KORTEWEG-TYPE FLUIDS This paper is dedicated to Liliana Restuccia, because she is already closer to 60 than 50. P. Ván Abstract In this note we compare the entropy principle and the objectivity arguments in the methodologies of Dunn and Serrin [ 1 ] and in the more recent weakly nonlocal thermodynamic analysis of Korteweg-type fluids in [ 2 ] . It is concluded that the different objectivity approaches lead to the same constitutive functions, and that the difference in the thermodynamically compatible pressure tensors of perfect Korteweg fluids is due to different symmetry requirements. Keywords: Korteweg fluids, weakly nonlocal thermodynamics, Liu procedure, material frame indifference 1 Introduction Material frame indifference, also known as material objectivity is one of the most discussed fundamental principles of classical continuum physics. It appears evident that material properties are independent of frames of reference. The principle has several different mathematical realizations. The formulation of Noll is based on the transformation properties of vectors in a three-dimensional Euclidean vector space, a mathematical representation of the spatial part of our spacetime [ 3 , 4 , 5 ] . This formulation has been criticized and reformulated by others [ 6 , 7 ] . The correct method is fundamental, as it is demonstrated by its role in the well-posedness of partial differential equations of Rational Extended Thermodynamics [ 8 ] or in the case of extended heat conduction in moving media [ 9 , 10 ] . A geometric formulation requires a reference frame independent representation of the corresponding functions and relations in a flat, four dimensional model of our nonrelativistic spacetime [ 11 , 5 ] . Some properties of the two approaches are compared in [ 12 , 13 ] . In [ 14 ] the transformation properties of the moment series expansion of Rational Extended Thermodynamics are explained in terms of transformation properties derived in a four-dimensional Galilean relativistic spacetime model. The difference between the two approaches is significant. Noll’s formulation is based on rigid rotating reference frames and requires invariance with respect to transformations between these frames. In contrast, Matolcsi’s spacetime approach requires a reference frame independent formulation of material properties and transformations between reference frames are derived, secondary concepts. Why is this a difficult problem? Firstly, in continuum theory, there is a distinguished reference body: the continuum itself. In this context, a spacetime-based formulation is far from evident, since the properties of the matter must be formulated in a way that takes into account the existence of the matter itself. This is particularly important in dissipative processes, since energy dissipation is objective, measurable, technologically significant and costly. Secondly, in nonrelativistic physics time passes independently of observers, therefore space and spacelike parts of four tensors appear independent of time. The two approaches can be compared by its consequences as well. A good example is the thermodynamic consistency of weakly nonlocal Korteweg-type fluids. Dunn and Serrin, [ 1 ] , applies Noll’s concept of objectivity and combines with the Coleman-Noll procedure to derive the constitutive function of the Korteweg pressure. They obtain \displaystyle{\mathbf{P}}_{\rm Dunn-Serrin} \displaystyle=\left(\varrho^{2}\frac{\partial\psi}{\partial\varrho}-\varrho\nabla\cdot\frac{\partial\varrho\psi}{\partial\left(\nabla\varrho\right)}\right)\mathbf{1}+\nabla\varrho\circ\frac{\partial\varrho\psi}{\partial\left(\nabla\varrho\right)}, (1) where \varrho is the density, p_{\rm fl} is the fluid pressure, \psi is called free energy in the paper of Dunn and Serrin and \nabla denotes the spatial derivative. In the special case of \psi=K\frac{(\nabla\varrho)^{2}}{2\varrho} , with K=\rm const. one gets \displaystyle{\mathbf{P}}_{\rm DS-quadratidc} \displaystyle=\left(\varrho K\Delta\varrho-\frac{K}{2}(\nabla\varrho)^{2}\right)\mathbf{1}+K\nabla\varrho\circ\nabla\varrho, (2) which is the pressure for diffuse interfaces derived in the framework of phase field models as well [ 15 ] On the other hand a different pressure tensor was derived in [ 2 ] : \displaystyle{\mathbf{P}}_{\rm st} \displaystyle=\left(\varrho^{2}\frac{\partial u}{\partial\varrho}-\frac{\varrho^{2}}{2}\nabla\cdot\frac{\partial u}{\partial\left(\nabla\varrho\right)}\right)\mathbf{1}-\frac{\varrho^{2}}{2}\nabla\frac{\partial u}{\partial\left(\nabla\varrho\right)}, (3) where u is the specific internal energy. In the special case of u=K\frac{(\nabla\varrho)^{2}}{2\varrho} , with K=\rm const. one obtains \displaystyle{\mathbf{P}}_{\rm st-quadratic} \displaystyle=\left(-\frac{\varrho K}{2}\Delta\varrho\right)\mathbf{1}-\frac{\varrho K}{2}\nabla\circ\nabla\varrho+\frac{K}{2}\nabla\varrho\circ\nabla\varrho. (4) Moreover, in [ 2 ] the material frame indifference is hidden, relative quantities are used to characterize the fluid, like current densities and relative velocity. Also ( 1 ) and ( 3 ) are different: in ( 1 ) interstitial working is introduced, in ( 3 ) the entropy flux is a constitutive function 1 1 1 One can get the same result with constitutive entropy flux as well [ 16 ] . Both papers use rigorous methods: Liu procedure in ( 3 ) and Colemann-Noll procedure in ( 1 ). In the following we shortly compare the objectivity arguments and analyze the reason of the difference of the above pressure tensors. 2 Galilean relativity Noll’s concept of objectivity is based on specific transformation rules between reference frames. Covariance with respect to these transformations is a necessary condition for material frame indifference. However, this is not sufficient: reference frame independence requires covariance with respect to all transformations. Nevertheless, it is difficult to find experimental counterexamples, so the principle appears to hold true. A reference frame independent spacetime approach, however, is different. In this approach, transformation rules can be derived between any reference frames. Also, a geometrical formulation is not always necessary. One can be sure that the theory is Galilean covariant even though it seems to be composed of relative elements. Spacetime, including the non-relativistic one, is four-dimensional. There are several known formulations (see e.g. [ 17 , 18 , 7 , 19 , 20 ] ), and there are some known consequences, for example the covariance of the Maxwell equations in Galilean electrodynamics [ 21 ] . In non-relativistic continua, the usual framework with relative, reference frame dependent quantities result in good models of observed phenomena. However, the story of the principle of material frame indifference indicates that a clear mathematical formulation without conceptual clarity is not enough. Despite absolute time, four-dimensional spacetime concepts are unavoidable in non-relativistic physics to remove relative quantities and reference frame dependence. Their conscious usage clarifies several concepts, like the conductive and convective current densities in local and substantial balances: their relation is a Galilean transformation between the laboratory and material frames. Rigorous spacetime treatment of nonrelativistic fluid mechanics reveals that the energy-momentum tensor is more sophisticated than in special relativity [ 11 , 22 ] . There is a covariant concept of energy, but only as part of a third-order four-tensor. However, keeping in mind the spacetime background, it is easy to avoid problematic aspects and keep the theory covariant despite using relative quantities. For example, the spatial derivatives ( i.e., the gradients) are legitimate, objective constitutive variables; they are spacelike covectors, that do not transform when the reference frame changes [ 19 ] . Moreover, the balance form is a four-divergence of a four-quantity (scalar, vector or tensor), therefore it is invariant, that does not transform either [ 22 ] . In addition, the entropy current density is a four-vector, therefore, if its timelike part, the entropy density, is a constitutive quantity, then its spacelike part, the entropy current density, must also be a constitutive quantity. Therefore, keeping in mind that the – constitutive state space is spanned by thermodynamic state variables and its gradients, – the constraints are fundamental balances, – entropy flux is a constitutive quantity, one can conclude that Korteweg fluids are safe from the point of view of material frame indifference. The final proof